Sep 1, 2026 · 1h 50m
AFC East contenders face very different tests
2026 AFC East preview
The division’s four teams enter 2026 with sharply different definitions of success, from Buffalo’s Super Bowl pursuit to Miami’s rebuild.
- 1Buffalo’s ceiling depends on whether new offensive and defensive ideas fix recurring weaknesses around Josh Allen.
- 2New England must prove its breakout season was sustainable despite thin depth and uncertain defensive foundations.
- 3The Jets and Dolphins are primarily evaluating young cores, quarterbacks, and coaching systems rather than chasing immediate contention.
Don't miss
The hosts use the 2021 Lions as a model for Miami, arguing that competitive play and young-player development could define a successful reset even with few wins.
The brief
Robert Mays, Derrik Klassen, and Dave Helman frame the AFC East around four separate questions: can Buffalo win it all, can New England repeat, and can New York and Miami build foundations?
Buffalo’s additions and coaching changes could raise the ceiling around Josh Allen, but the Bills still must solve familiar concerns at pass catcher, pass rusher, and offensive explosiveness.
New England’s A.J. Brown-led offense and rebuilt line give Drake Maye more support, yet the Patriots must show last season’s defensive improvement was real and their thin roster can survive.
The Jets’ experiment hinges on Geno Smith making Frank Reich’s offense functional while young linemen, Garrett Wilson, and a rebuilt defense reveal whether the roster has a durable core.
Miami offers the strangest reset: Malik Willis, Devon Achane, and a run-heavy system could create an identity, but the Dolphins’ thin roster and financial burden make competitiveness the real benchmark.
The clearest throughline is that success is not one-size-fits-all: Buffalo needs a Super Bowl, New England needs validation, and New York and Miami need evidence of a future.