Aug 24, 2026 · 50 min
BYU weighs playoff hopes against measurable progress
BYU's Biggest Questions Before Game One
The episode tests whether BYU’s 2026 season should hinge on a playoff berth or on evidence of sustained growth against stronger competition.
- 1Bear Bachmeier’s efficiency, L.J. Martin’s health, and receiver development define BYU’s offensive ceiling.
- 2Takeaways and wins over Arizona or Notre Dame could reshape BYU’s Big 12 title and playoff résumé.
- 3Trevor Matich argues that line play, physicality, and meaningful wins matter more than an underrated label.
Don't miss
Trevor Matich rejects playoff-or-bust framing while arguing that BYU has enough talent to make and advance in the playoff.
The brief
BYU’s opening what-ifs are concrete: Bear Bachmeier’s passing production, L.J. Martin’s rushing health, defensive takeaways, and the consequences of an early loss to Arizona.
A win over Notre Dame followed by an 11-2 finish could give BYU a stronger at-large playoff résumé, even if the Cougars lose the Big 12 championship game.
Trevor Matich shifts the focus from playoff-or-bust expectations to receiver development, efficient quarterback play, and stronger offensive and defensive lines.
Walker Lyons offers a view from the tight end room, describing his preparation, the leadership of Bear Bachmeier and L.J. Martin, and BYU’s distinctive brotherhood.
The episode closes with women’s soccer’s 2-0 win over USC and a tribute to Dave Cragthorpe, who helped shape BYU’s early passing attack.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.