First Take
First Take

Sep 7, 2026 · 51 min

Clemson’s Dabo dilemma meets college football’s early tests

Hour 2: Could this be Dabo's Final Season with Clemson?

The episode weighs whether Clemson’s blowout loss exposes a deeper program problem while measuring Michigan, Texas, Ohio State, and Miami against championship expectations.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Michigan’s disputed finish raises questions about Bryce Underwood’s readiness and the Wolverines’ ability to challenge the Big Ten’s elite.
  2. 2LSU’s rout of Clemson intensifies scrutiny of Dabo Swinney’s roster-building approach and the program’s championship trajectory.
  3. 3Texas and Ohio State offer contrasting cases for early confidence, while Miami emerges as the panel’s most impressive contender.

Don't miss

The panel connects LSU’s blowout of Clemson to mounting questions about Dabo Swinney’s refusal to rely on the transfer portal.

The brief

Michigan’s last-second win over Western Michigan was preserved after officials restored a second to the clock, prompting a debate over fairness, Bryce Underwood, and playoff potential.

The panel questions whether Underwood can lead a roster that remains short of the Big Ten’s top tier, even as Michigan treats him as its quarterback of the future.

LSU’s blowout of Clemson turns the spotlight on Dabo Swinney, whose reluctance to use the transfer portal now faces sharper scrutiny after a historic defeat.

Texas–Ohio State becomes a referendum on confidence: Arch Manning and Texas’s roster appeal to some, while others defend Ryan Day’s accomplishments and Ohio State’s ceiling.

Miami earns the panel’s strongest Week One endorsement, with Malachi Toney’s production driving championship and Heisman discussion despite Kevin Clark’s admitted Hurricanes allegiance.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.