Aug 25, 2026 · 52 min
Fantasy analysts wrestle with football’s toughest rankings
The 8 Hardest Players to Rank with Andy Behrens
The episode shows how workload, team context, health and role uncertainty can outweigh talent when setting fantasy rankings.
- 1Patrick Mahomes remains difficult to rank as rushing value and potentially lower passing volume reshape his fantasy outlook.
- 2Josh Jacobs’ goal-line role and workload support his value, while injury history and suspension risk complicate the case.
- 3Garrett Wilson, Marvin Harrison Jr. and Dalton Kincaid each carry elite-skill arguments weakened by uncertain usage or opportunity.
Don't miss
The hosts’ discussion of Marvin Harrison Jr. crystallizes the episode’s central tension: elite expectations meeting persistently low fantasy production and uncertain usage.
The brief
Matthew Berry and Andy Behrens begin with Kayshon Boutte’s move to Houston, asking whether a deep-threat opportunity signals anything about Tank Dell’s recovery and outlook.
The ranking debate starts with Patrick Mahomes and De’Von Achane, then widens to how quarterback rushing, passing volume and preseason flashes distort fantasy expectations.
Josh Jacobs offers a clearer workload case through goal-line work and historical usage, but injury history and suspension risk keep his ranking unsettled.
Garrett Wilson remains a likely top receiver despite Jets uncertainty, while DJ Moore and Brian Thomas Jr. face crowded or changing target environments.
Marvin Harrison Jr. and Dalton Kincaid supply the sharpest talent-versus-usage tension: both have appealing skills, but limited production or playing time clouds their rankings.
The episode’s central lesson is that fantasy rankings become hardest when talent is obvious but workload, health, quarterback play or team context remains unresolved.