Excess Returns
Excess Returns

Oct 7, 2026 · 1h 12m

Small caps seek a comeback as AI spending broadens

Tom Maher on Small-Cap Investing, AI Infrastructure and Opportunities Beyond Big Tech

After years of large-cap market concentration, improving earnings and AI infrastructure investment could reopen opportunities in smaller companies, but higher rates and weak businesses raise the bar for selection.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Small- and mid-cap stocks may benefit as earnings improve and AI infrastructure spending reaches beyond dominant technology companies.
  2. 2Active management matters in a diverse universe where business quality, self-funding growth, management discipline, and valuation vary widely.
  3. 3Higher interest rates, passive flows, and shifting AI valuations can reshape portfolio construction even when research remains primarily bottom-up.

Don't miss

Monaghan’s most practical lesson is to take profits as an investment thesis plays out rather than let analysis become an excuse for inaction.

The brief

Tom Monaghan of Hilton Capital argues that years of large-cap dominance may be giving way to a broader opportunity set as smaller companies’ earnings improve and AI infrastructure spending expands.

The case for small caps is not simply a size premium: Monaghan emphasizes quality, self-funding growth, disciplined management, and valuation in a universe crowded with unprofitable businesses.

His process is primarily bottom-up, but inflation, interest rates, passive flows, and AI-driven valuation shifts still influence how he builds a portfolio.

Ideas come from thematic research and cross-sector comparisons, with expectations adjusted for a company’s growth stage and management’s ability to execute.

The closing lesson is disciplined rather than complicated: avoid excessive analysis, take profits as a thesis plays out, and remain selective when market conditions change.

What was said on this episode

39 statements · 22 positive · 7 negative · 10 neutral

  1. Tom Maheron AI infrastructure buildoutPositive2:47

    AI infrastructure investment is a significant driver of GDP growth.

    “the AI buildout, which we'll get into more detail, I'm sure, but that's a significant driver of GDP growth”

    Listen at 2:47

  2. Tom Maheron Small- and mid-cap companiesPositive3:08

    Small- and mid-cap earnings are expected to grow 20–30% over the next few years.

    “you have 20%, 30% kind of earnings growth expected over the next few years”

    Listen at 3:08

  3. Tom Maheron Operational efficiency at industrial companiesPositive7:57

    Operational efficiency is boosting earnings through margin improvements.

    “you are seeing some of that come through”

    Listen at 7:57

  4. Tom Maheron Small-cap versus large-cap earnings growthPositive9:22

    Small-cap earnings growth has begun to improve relative to large caps.

    “that seems to have reversed to some extent”

    Listen at 9:22

  5. Tom Maheron Small-cap stocksPositive9:36

    Improving small-cap earnings should attract more investor interest.

    “you should probably start to see a little more interest in the market space”

    Listen at 9:36

  6. Tom Maheron U.S. small- and mid-cap stocksPositive11:07

    U.S. small- and mid-cap stocks will capture reshoring and domestic development activity.

    “all of that is going to be captured by small mid-cap stocks here in the United States”

    Listen at 11:07

  7. Tom Maheron Small- and mid-cap stocksPositive12:18

    Investors should consider small- and mid-cap stocks for diversification and growth exposure.

    “you should be thinking about small and mid-cap stock”

    Listen at 12:18

  8. Tom Maheron Hilton Capital small- and mid-cap strategyNeutral14:13

    The strategy’s investable range extends down into micro-cap stocks.

    “the low end is really kind of down to, you name it, micro caps”

    Listen at 14:13

  9. Tom Maheron Hilton micro-cap exposureNegative14:17

    Hilton is less exposed to micro-caps because many are non-earners and fail its quality filters.

    “we're a little bit less exposed to the micro cap space. primarily because a lot of those are non-earners and we like a little bit more quality, so it may not necessarily make it through our filters.”

    Listen at 14:17

  10. Tom Maheron Hilton small- and mid-cap rangeNeutral14:30

    Hilton’s small- and mid-cap range currently tops out around $25–30 billion.

    “We think about top of our sort of small and mid cap range as call it 25, 30 billion right now.”

    Listen at 14:30

  11. Tom Maheron Hilton portfolioNeutral14:42

    About 20% of Hilton’s portfolio is currently invested below $4 billion market capitalization.

    “right now we have about 20% of the portfolio below 4 billion.”

    Listen at 14:42

  12. Tom Maheron Hilton portfolioNeutral14:46

    A large portion of Hilton’s portfolio lies between $4 billion and $10 billion market capitalization.

    “a big chunk of it between four and 10 billion, and then a little more above that.”

    Listen at 14:46

  13. Tom Maheron Small-cap stocks during the meme-stock eraNeutral14:58

    Small-cap stocks during the meme-stock era were effectively large-cap stocks.

    “small cap, during the meat stock era, the small cap stocks were, you know, large cap stocks.”

    Listen at 14:58

  14. Tom Maheron Small- and mid-cap classificationNeutral15:10

    Small- and mid-cap classification should also consider company type and stock dynamics.

    “definition also relies on the type of company or how that stock dynamic works.”

    Listen at 15:10

  15. Tom Maheron Small-cap stocksPositive16:06

    Small-cap stocks can carry a valuation premium at the individual-stock level.

    “I think that there is a premium”

    Listen at 16:06

  16. Tom Maheron Small- and mid-cap companiesNegative16:30

    Only a small minority of small- and mid-cap companies graduate into larger-cap status.

    “Very few of them actually graduate”

    Listen at 16:30

  17. Tom Maheron Small-cap portfolio managementPositive20:22

    Small-cap investors should actively manage sector exposures rather than track index weights.

    “you need to be genuinely active”

    Listen at 20:22

  18. Tom Maheron Small-cap active managementPositive21:22

    Small-cap managers should vary both stock selection and sector weights.

    “you want a manager who's not only active in terms of the stock level decisions, but I think also the willingness to let those sector weights move”

    Listen at 21:22

  19. Tom Maheron Hilton Capital portfolio constructionNeutral23:22

    The portfolio expands its number of holdings during major market or macro changes.

    “when things are sort of in a change point, you'll see that number expand”

    Listen at 23:22

  20. Tom Maheron Hilton Capital portfolio constructionPositive23:33

    The portfolio concentrates into higher-conviction holdings during difficult conditions.

    “when things are getting rough, our number of names actually shrinks”

    Listen at 23:33

  21. Tom Maheron Small-cap indexesNegative24:31

    The quality of small-cap indexes has declined because more constituents are unprofitable.

    “the overall aggregate quality is a little bit lower”

    Listen at 24:31

  22. Tom Maheron Private-capital-backed companiesPositive28:54

    Private-capital exits will eventually produce good mid-cap public companies.

    “there will be some good companies coming out that way”

    Listen at 28:54

  23. Tom Maheron Groundbreaking technology companiesPositive31:17

    Groundbreaking technology companies can be relatively insulated from macroeconomic conditions.

    “the macro may have very little impact on that company's fortunes in the near term or even in the long term”

    Listen at 31:17

  24. Tom Maheron Equity portfolio constructionNeutral32:48

    Stock selection should incorporate both bottom-up analysis and macroeconomic conditions.

    “you need to incorporate both”

    Listen at 32:48

  25. Tom Maheron Small- and mid-cap companiesPositive36:47

    Higher interest rates increase the importance of balance-sheet and business quality.

    “quality should start to matter more”

    Listen at 36:47

  26. Tom Maheron Equity valuation multiplesNegative38:14

    Higher interest rates should theoretically reduce equity valuation multiples.

    “multiple theoretically should come down”

    Listen at 38:14

  27. Tom Maheron Small-cap stocks in thematic ETF basketsPositive42:15

    Small-cap stocks can massively outperform when ETF inflows target their thematic baskets.

    “the small cap stock may massively outperform”

    Listen at 42:15

  28. Tom Maheron Small-cap stocks in ETF basketsPositive42:55

    Basket-driven selling can create opportunities in fundamentally sound small-cap stocks.

    “you can find opportunities where a stock gets clobbered because it's in a basket that people are selling off”

    Listen at 42:55

  29. Tom Maheron Small-cap investingPositive44:46

    Small-cap investors should place greater emphasis on earnings growth than multiple expansion.

    “you really have to sort of have more of an emphasis on that earnings growth”

    Listen at 44:46

  30. Tom Maheron Small-cap companies with improving earningsPositive46:55

    The market will eventually recognize companies delivering materially improved earnings growth.

    “eventually I think market will come around to the attention on that company”

    Listen at 46:55

  31. Tom Maheron Small-cap stock valuationsNeutral51:37

    Investors should be equally cautious about extremely cheap and expensive stocks.

    “we're as wary of really cheap stocks as we are really expensive stocks”

    Listen at 51:37

  32. Tom Maheron Consistent earnings-growth companiesPositive56:01

    Consistent earnings growth can eventually lead to higher valuation multiples.

    “the valuation may actually start to go up again”

    Listen at 56:01

  33. Tom Maheron Small-cap company managementPositive57:07

    Management assessment is especially important when evaluating small-cap companies.

    “assessing management is very important”

    Listen at 57:07

  34. Tom Maheron Small-cap company management decisionsNegative57:34

    Poor management decisions affect small enterprises quickly and dramatically.

    “if you make bad moves, it can sort of manifest itself rather quickly and more dramatically”

    Listen at 57:34

  35. Tom Maheron U.S. manufacturing reshoringPositive1:01:43

    Manufacturing reshoring and a domestic industrial renaissance are occurring.

    “I think they're happening”

    Listen at 1:01:43

  36. Tom Maheron GlobalizationNegative1:04:10

    Globalization has partially unwound, increasing demand for local production capacity.

    “you've had a little bit of an unwind of the globalization”

    Listen at 1:04:10

  37. Tom Maheron Company analysisNegative1:06:28

    Excessive company analysis can reduce investment decision quality.

    “there is a diminishing return on knowing in some cases too much about a company”

    Listen at 1:06:28

  38. Tom Maheron Profit-takingPositive1:08:10

    Investors should take partial profits as a stock appreciates.

    “don't be afraid to book some of the profits on the way up”

    Listen at 1:08:10

  39. Tom Maheron Stock-price reactions to newsNeutral1:09:13

    Unexpected stock reactions to news warrant deeper investigation.

    “if a stock responds to a piece of news or a development, the reverse of what you expect, pay close attention”

    Listen at 1:09:13

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Books & mentions

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.