Sep 15, 2026 · 11 min
Two Reel formats turn viral reach into lasting followers
Two Types of Reels to Turn Viral Views into New Followers
Viral views have limited value when they do not translate into an audience that chooses to follow and return.
- 1“That’s Me!” reels help viewers recognize themselves in content and see a reason to follow.
- 2Signature series create repeatable content patterns that give audiences something specific to anticipate.
- 3Consistent testing, including trial reels, helps creators identify which formats reach and convert the right viewers.
Don't miss
Shanna’s central distinction is that viral reach is not the same as follower growth, making conversion the real test of a reel.
The brief
Shanna McKinstrie frames the problem clearly: viral reels can attract plenty of views without giving those viewers a reason to follow.
The episode introduces “That’s Me!” reels, a format built around recognition, and signature series, which make content repeatable enough to follow.
Hooks matter, but the larger challenge is creating a series with a clear promise—something an audience wants to see again rather than a one-off hit.
Shanna emphasizes consistent testing, including trial reels, as a way to discover which ideas reach the right viewers and convert attention into followers.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.