
Oct 31, 2026 · 12 min
1890 tariff backlash offers a warning for Republicans
The Democrats Will Sweep The Midterms — Here’s Why
The episode uses Benjamin Harrison’s defeat-era unpopularity to examine how tariffs and pro-business policies can turn affordability pressures into political liability.
- 1Benjamin Harrison’s tariff increases helped fuel an affordability crisis and public backlash in 1890.
- 2The episode links economic pressure to the political consequences facing Republicans in midterm elections.
- 3Historical precedent frames today’s political risks without treating electoral outcomes as inevitable.
Don't miss
The episode’s key historical turn is the argument that Benjamin Harrison’s tariff increases helped convert affordability pressures into political backlash.
The brief
Ed Elson introduces Simply Put through the political backlash against Benjamin Harrison, whose presidency became associated with tariff increases and pro-business policies.
The episode’s central argument is that policies designed to favor business can become politically toxic when households experience them as an affordability crisis.
Benjamin Harrison’s unpopularity in 1890 provides the historical case: economic pressure translated into consequences for the governing Republican Party.
The episode uses that history to frame why Republicans could face a major midterm defeat, connecting policy choices with voter backlash.
What was said on this episode
30 statements · 7 positive · 22 negative · 1 neutral
Benjamin Harrison’s 50% tariffs caused prices to rise and an affordability crisis.
“After increasing import duties to 50%, prices immediately shot up and an affordability crisis followed.”
Listen at 1:52
“Harrison's party lost 93 seats across the House and the Senate”
Listen at 2:16
“I predict a similar outcome.”
Listen at 2:39
Trump’s second presidency is arguably America’s worst presidency.
“Trump 2.0 has been arguably the worst presidency in the history of America.”
Listen at 2:47
Republicans are about to be swept in the midterm elections.
“Prediction, the Republicans are about to get swept.”
Listen at 3:10
Trump failed to reduce inflation, end foreign wars, or balance the budget.
“The man who promised to bring down inflation, put an end to foreign wars, and balance the budget has not only accomplished none of these goals, he's done the exact opposite.”
Listen at 3:20
Trump’s tariffs would cause rampant inflation.
“tariffs, which I and many others said would result in rampant inflation.”
Listen at 3:32
Inflation rose nearly one percentage point within a year of Liberation Day.
“Within a year of Liberation Day, inflation had risen nearly a full percentage point.”
Listen at 3:41
The United States remained at war with Iran eight months after the conflict began.
“Eight months later, we are still at war.”
Listen at 3:57
Inflation rose another percentage point and gas prices increased 40%.
“Inflation has risen another percentage point, and gas prices are up 40%.”
Listen at 3:59
Inflation outpaced wage growth for six months, reducing workers’ purchasing power.
“For six straight months, inflation has outpaced wage growth, meaning American workers are getting poorer.”
Listen at 4:12
Corporate profits increased nearly 40% since Trump took office.
“corporate profits have exploded nearly 40% since Trump took office.”
Listen at 4:19
Today’s economic problems were created by one individual, Donald Trump.
“Today's economic problems, however, are unique in that they were invented by one individual.”
Listen at 4:52
Trump’s tariffs and war caused the current inflation crisis.
“If it weren't for Trump, specifically his tariffs and his war, our inflation crisis would not exist.”
Listen at 5:04
Donald Trump’s overall approval rating has fallen to historic lows.
“Trump's overall approval rating has fallen to historic lows”
Listen at 5:20
Trump personally profited $1.4 billion from crypto projects last year.
“Last year, Trump personally profited $1.4 billion from his crypto projects.”
Listen at 6:19
Trump Coin buyers lost roughly $2 billion.
“who lost roughly $2 billion buying Trump coin.”
Listen at 6:28
Trump traded as much as $1.5 billion in stocks.
“Trump also traded as much as $1.5 billion in stocks.”
Listen at 6:32
Trump and associates likely traded stocks using insider information.
“it's highly likely that he and his associates were making bets based on insider information.”
Listen at 6:40
SEC and CFTC officials were ordered to stop investigating Trump’s trades.
“When officials at the SEC and the CFTC tried to investigate these trades, though, they were immediately ordered to stop”
Listen at 6:45
The alleged Trump-related stock trading represents exceptionally obvious corruption.
“Corruption does not get more obvious than this.”
Listen at 6:57
Two-thirds of Americans say Trump uses the presidency for personal enrichment.
“Two-thirds now say that Trump is using the office to enrich himself.”
Listen at 7:36
Trump has damaged Republican candidates’ electoral chances nationwide.
“Trump's been so terrible, he's ruined the chances for everyone else.”
Listen at 7:46
“the Democrats' odds of sweeping the Republicans have more than doubled since the beginning of the year.”
Listen at 7:54
Democrats will likely need two victories among three named competitive candidates.
“Democrats will likely need two wins from Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan, Troy Jackson in Maine, or James Tallarico in Texas.”
Listen at 8:05
Donald Trump has damaged Republican candidates nationwide.
“Trump has poisoned Republican wells across the nation.”
Listen at 8:31
Two-thirds of competitive-race GOP candidates are distancing themselves from Trump.
“two-thirds of GOP candidates in competitive races are now distancing themselves from the president.”
Listen at 8:40
Democrats should avoid a bold agenda and let Trump self-destruct politically.
“That's why I advise Democrats to commit to the following political strategy. Do nothing.”
Listen at 9:04
Democrats should avoid major action and let Trump continue damaging himself politically.
“The key will be to sit still. and let the man continue to self-destruct.”
Listen at 9:24
The 2026 midterms will produce an unprecedented Democratic blue wave.
“I'm confident the story of 1890 will repeat itself. A blue wave, unlike anything we've seen.”
Listen at 9:42
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.