Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing
Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing

Nov 21, 2026 · 13 min

A Japan-style crash is possible—but today’s risks look different

Is a Japan-Style Downturn Possible in the U.S.?

A prolonged market slump would affect young savers and retirees differently, making diversification, cash reserves, and withdrawal planning consequential.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Current U.S. valuations are elevated, but they remain less extreme than Japan’s 1980s asset bubble.
  2. 2Long downturns can help younger contributors while threatening retirees exposed to poor early returns and ongoing withdrawals.
  3. 3Historical backtests show broader diversification and near-term cash reserves can improve outcomes during extended market weakness.

Don't miss

The six-asset backtest produces a smaller drawdown and substantially more ending wealth than the conventional 60/40 portfolio.

The brief

Robert Brokamp asks whether the United States could endure Japan’s decades-long post-1990 market decline, arguing that the outcome is possible but unlikely under current conditions.

Japan’s 1980s bubble pushed stock, real-estate, and debt valuations to extreme levels before rate increases helped trigger a collapse and a prolonged Nikkei recovery.

The episode contrasts Japan and the Great Depression with today’s elevated U.S. valuations, then shows why a long downturn would burden retirees more than steady contributors.

A backtest of a retiree starting with $1 million in 2000 shows how inflation-adjusted withdrawals and poor early returns can strain a conventional 60/40 portfolio.

A six-asset portfolio spanning U.S. stocks, small caps, international stocks, REITs, bonds, and cash suffered a smaller drawdown and ended with substantially more wealth.

What was said on this episode

16 statements · 7 positive · 7 negative · 2 neutral

  1. Robert Brokampon Japan-style U.S. stock-market downturnNegative1:26

    A Japan-style U.S. stock-market downturn is unlikely under current conditions.

    “My thought is it's not likely, at least not now.”

    Listen at 1:26

  2. Robert Brokampon U.S. stock, real-estate, and debt marketsNeutral1:40

    U.S. stock, real-estate, and debt markets are far below Japan’s bubble levels.

    “all three were at levels nowhere close to what we see in the U.S. right now.”

    Listen at 1:40

  3. Robert Brokampon Japan-style U.S. stock-market downturnNeutral3:27

    A Japan-style downturn is possible in the United States.

    “of course the answer is it's possible.”

    Listen at 3:27

  4. Robert Brokampon U.S. market conditionsPositive3:40

    Current U.S. market conditions are much less extreme than Japan’s 1980s bubble.

    “the conditions in the US today are nowhere near as frothy as they were in Japan”

    Listen at 3:40

  5. Robert Brokampon U.S. market collapseNegative3:45

    The U.S. is not currently near a Japan-style market collapse.

    “I don't think the US is on the verge of anything like what Japan experienced.”

    Listen at 3:45

  6. Robert Brokampon American stocksNegative3:50

    American stocks are currently expensive rather than cheap.

    “American stocks aren't cheap.”

    Listen at 3:50

  7. Robert Brokampon U.S. market cyclically adjusted P/ENegative4:01

    The U.S. market’s cyclically adjusted P/E is at its second-highest level ever.

    “the cape is at its second highest level ever”

    Listen at 4:01

  8. The U.S. stock market is not undervalued.

    “It's hard to argue that the U.S. stock market is undervalued.”

    Listen at 4:19

  9. Robert Brokampon InvestorsNegative4:23

    Investors should prepare for a possible sequence of very poor market years.

    “I do think it makes sense for investors to always be prepared for the possibility of a string of really bad years.”

    Listen at 4:23

  10. Robert Brokampon Long-term stock contributions during downturnsPositive5:10

    Long-term contributions during downturns buy more shares and benefit from eventual recovery.

    “every contribution to an IRA, 401k, brokerage account... It's buying stocks at lower prices, you're accumulating more shares, which will benefit from the eventual rebound.”

    Listen at 5:10

  11. Robert Brokampon Near-term investors and retireesNegative5:20

    Near-term investors and retirees should prepare for a stagnant stock market.

    “those with more near-term goals, such as fools getting close to or in retirement, you should always prepare for the possibility of a stagnant stock market”

    Listen at 5:20

  12. Robert Brokampon Near-term savingsPositive7:52

    Money needed within three to five years should be held in cash and bonds.

    “protect the money you need in the next three to five years by keeping it in cash and bonds.”

    Listen at 7:52

  13. Robert Brokampon Stock portfoliosPositive8:03

    Investors should own at least 50 stocks.

    “own at least 50 stocks.”

    Listen at 8:03

  14. Robert Brokampon Low-cost ETFs and index fundsPositive8:20

    Investors should complement stock holdings with low-cost ETFs and index funds.

    “Complement your stocks with low-cost ETFs and index funds”

    Listen at 8:20

  15. Robert Brokampon Stock and fund portfoliosPositive8:27

    Stock and fund portfolios should diversify across sectors, industries, styles, and countries.

    “Make sure your collection of stocks and funds are diversified across sectors, industries, styles, and countries.”

    Listen at 8:27

  16. Robert Brokampon Portfolio diversificationPositive11:56

    Diversification improved historical retirement-portfolio outcomes during an extended stock-market downturn.

    “the historical verdict is that diversification paid off during this period of an extended downturn in the stock market.”

    Listen at 11:56

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Books & mentions

Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.

A Japan-style crash is possible—but today’s risks look different · PodLume