Nov 12, 2026 · 1h 22m
A railroad moat meets a capital-efficiency test
TIP860: Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited (CP.TO): Irreplaceable Moat, Unproven Compounding w/ Kyle Grieve & Shawn O'Malley
Canadian Pacific Kansas City owns an unusually difficult-to-replicate network, but its acquisition, leverage, and incentives may limit shareholder returns.
- 1Canadian Pacific Kansas City’s three-country network creates a rare physical moat across Canada, the United States, and Mexico.
- 2The Kansas City Southern acquisition expanded strategic reach while weakening return on invested capital and increasing balance-sheet risk.
- 3A valuation near $165 implies roughly 7% expected returns, below the hosts’ hurdle despite the business’s quality.
Don't miss
The hosts conclude that an irreplaceable railroad network can still fail to deliver attractive returns if the acquisition permanently depresses capital efficiency.
The brief
Kyle Grieve and Shawn O’Malley examine whether Canadian Pacific Kansas City’s historic railroad network can turn an exceptional physical moat into superior shareholder returns.
The Kansas City Southern acquisition created a single Canada–United States–Mexico network, reducing handoffs and strengthening the railroad’s strategic position while enlarging its capital base.
The hosts distinguish irreplaceable corridors, bridges, terminals, and land rights from pricing power, noting that customers can still switch to trucks or competing rail routes.
Their central test is return on invested capital: post-acquisition weakness could reflect temporary integration drag, or signal that Canadian Pacific overpaid for growth.
Debt-funded buybacks, management incentives, merger threats, trade policy, and refinancing costs add risks to an otherwise durable business.
A valuation around $165 produces roughly 7% expected returns, leading both hosts to call Canadian Pacific Kansas City high quality but too close to fair value.
What was said on this episode
65 statements · 32 positive · 26 negative · 3 mixed · 4 neutral
Canadian Pacific transformed from one of North America’s least efficient railroads into one of its best.
“Canadian Pacific, Kansas City, they kind of went from being one of the least efficient railroads in North America to one of the best.”
Listen at 0:46
Canadian Pacific Kansas City shareholder returns have disappointed relative to expectations.
“But the returns for shareholders haven't been nearly as impressive as I would have thought.”
Listen at 1:07
The Kansas City Southern acquisition may either pay off slowly or permanently reduce capital efficiency.
“Either that bet is a slow burn that's ready to pay off, or the price is... permanently lowered the company's capital efficiency.”
Listen at 1:14
BNSF revenue and pretax income compounded below 3%.
“It has grown, but revenue and pre-tax income have basically compounded at less than 3%.”
Listen at 4:15
BNSF does not have growth rates that attract significant investor attention.
“It's definitely not a business with growth rates that would really make you look twice”
Listen at 4:34
Canadian Pacific profited from selling its unused Vancouver corridor.
“Canadian Pacific held its ground and still ended up making a little bit of money on that asset.”
Listen at 5:56
Canadian Pacific Kansas City produced exceptional financial results before COVID.
“Canadian Pacific Kansas City before COVID was putting up some exceptional numbers.”
Listen at 7:34
Canadian Pacific delivered 26% EPS growth and roughly 20% share-price growth plus dividends.
“26% growth in EPS while the share price grew about 20% plus a 1% dividend.”
Listen at 7:43
Canadian Pacific Kansas City EPS growth slowed and share-price growth reached only 5.5%.
“Earnings per share has slowed considerably into mid-single-digit growth, while the share price has compounded at just 5.5% correspondingly.”
Listen at 7:58
Canadian Pacific Kansas City and BNSF do not appear to be obvious bargains.
“neither of them have really seemed to look like screaming buys.”
Listen at 8:14
Canadian Pacific Kansas City is the only North American railroad spanning three countries.
“It's the first and only railroad to run through three different countries in North America.”
Listen at 8:45
No other railroad can currently replicate Canadian Pacific Kansas City’s network.
“No other railroad currently can replicate the network that they have.”
Listen at 8:51
Canadian Pacific increased diluted shares 37% to fund the acquisition.
“the diluted share count increased by 37% just to fund the deal.”
Listen at 9:00
Canadian Pacific materially shaped Canada’s present geographic and political form.
“Canadian Pacific isn't just a railroad. It's really a big reason that Canada exists in the shape that it is today.”
Listen at 10:20
CP had one of the industry’s lowest operating ratios before its activist campaign.
“During this time, CP had one of the lowest operating ratios in the entire industry.”
Listen at 12:42
Canadian Pacific’s operating ratio was 80% before Hunter Harrison’s reforms.
“At this time, Canadian Pacific had an operating ratio of 80%, which is just plain bad.”
Listen at 13:22
Precision scheduled railroading increased Canadian Pacific’s operating margins above 40%.
“Canadian Pacific's operating margins went from the mid-teens all the way up to over 40%.”
Listen at 14:45
Canadian Pacific’s stock compounded above 17% annually during the reform period.
“the stock price compounded at over 17% a year during that same period.”
Listen at 14:51
Canadian Pacific Kansas City customers must pay to move freight across its network.
“customers basically have to pay it to move their freight from one point to another.”
Listen at 16:47
Canadian Pacific’s geographic and freight diversification cushions weakness in individual markets.
“a weak year in one commodity or one economy does get cushioned by the others”
Listen at 18:27
Grain is Canadian Pacific Kansas City’s largest freight business, exceeding 20% of revenue.
“Grain is their single largest business line making up well over 20% of its freight revenue.”
Listen at 19:24
Canadian Pacific’s fuel-surcharge revenue rose 74%, adding approximately $258 million.
“the fuel surcharge revenue increased by a mind-boggling 74%, adding roughly $258 million to revenue.”
Listen at 20:20
Underlying Canadian Pacific revenue growth was mid-single-digit after excluding fuel and grain effects.
“if you strip out the fuel and the record grain harvest, underlying revenue growth comes in the mid single digits”
Listen at 20:46
Rail is three to four times more fuel-efficient per ton-mile than trucking.
“rail is roughly three to four times more fuel efficient per ton mile than trucking.”
Listen at 21:52
A single train can replace hundreds of trucks on the road.
“one train can take hundreds of trucks off of the road.”
Listen at 21:57
Canadian Pacific won the bidding process for Kansas City Southern.
“they ended up winning that bid.”
Listen at 27:25
Canadian Pacific Kansas City can move freight from Mexico through the US into Canada on one line.
“And now for Canadian Pacific, Kansas City, they can do it on a single line from Mexico through the US and into Canada.”
Listen at 28:15
Canadian Pacific’s irreplaceable network does not provide unlimited pricing power.
“the fact that pretty much nobody can go out and build a new railroad doesn't mean that Canadian Pacific Kansas City can go out there and just charge whatever price they want to.”
Listen at 29:51
Railroads’ durable assets do not necessarily make them good investments.
“while railroads are great assets because of their kind of lasting power, they aren't always the best investments.”
Listen at 30:28
Canadian Pacific’s rail infrastructure replacement cost is estimated at $8–20 million per mile.
“the actual price today should probably go in a range more like between $8 and $20 million per mile.”
Listen at 31:48
Canadian Pacific Kansas City’s network replacement cost is estimated at $250–500 billion.
“the estimated replacement cost is probably somewhere between $250 billion to $500 billion.”
Listen at 32:03
Oligopolistic railroad structures tend to raise prices and improve returns on capital.
“pricing tends to drift upward over time and returns on capital tend to improve accordingly.”
Listen at 33:24
Air freight costs roughly $5,000 per ton versus about $50 by rail.
“air freight costs per ton. So it's about $5,000 and that compares to roughly $50 per ton by rail freight.”
Listen at 35:48
Mexican regulators can set railroad rates or grant competitors track access.
“in Mexico, regulators can actually set rates or even grant competitors access to your tracks if they decide there isn't enough competition.”
Listen at 38:06
Class One railroads raised prices above inflation for most of two decades.
“class one railroads have pushed through price increases above inflation for most of the last two decades.”
Listen at 39:04
Customers integrated with Canadian Pacific are unlikely to switch to Canadian National.
“it's really unlikely that they're going to try and switch to Canadian National”
Listen at 41:36
Canadian Pacific still must prove its moat produces superior post-merger returns.
“the part that Canadian Pacific Kansas City still needs to prove on the other side of this big merger that they've done.”
Listen at 44:12
Canadian Pacific Kansas City has an exceptionally large business moat.
“Canadian Pacific Kansas City has one of the largest moats in a business that I've ever seen.”
Listen at 44:19
Canadian Pacific earned adjusted ROIC of approximately 14–17% before the acquisition.
“from 2016 to 2020, it earned adjusted returns on invested capital of about 14 to 17%.”
Listen at 45:32
Canadian Pacific’s adjusted ROIC was 6.9% in 2025.
“And then for 2025, the number is just 6.9%.”
Listen at 46:13
Post-acquisition capital efficiency has not recovered as quickly as a temporary timing issue would imply.
“I think enough time has now passed that if this were a timing issue, we'd probably see the capital efficiency number at least approximate historical levels or get closer to that.”
Listen at 53:12
The premium paid for Kansas City Southern will permanently increase Canadian Pacific’s invested capital base.
“Because they paid this large premium for Kansas City Southern, it's permanently going to change their invested capital base.”
Listen at 53:43
Canadian Pacific’s incremental ROIC exceeded 12% from 2024 to 2025.
“The number for that period from 2024 until 2025 has actually crept up to over 12%.”
Listen at 55:56
Canadian Pacific likely repurchased shares around or above intrinsic value.
“much of the buybacks over the past few years, they seem to have been done at sort of what I would call a rough approximation of exactly at intrinsic value or perhaps above it.”
Listen at 56:49
Canadian Pacific partly funded buybacks with new bonds and an asset sale.
“part of these buybacks were funded by issuing new bonds and selling a stake in the Panama Canal Railway.”
Listen at 58:08
Canadian Pacific’s current leverage does not pose a major concern.
“I don't think there's too much to worry about here.”
Listen at 58:53
Canadian Pacific’s net debt equals approximately ten times free cash flow.
“Canadian Pacific, Kansas City's net debt to free cash flow is actually 10 times.”
Listen at 1:00:08
Canadian Pacific’s operating income covers interest expense more than six times.
“Interest is covered more than six times by operating income.”
Listen at 1:00:34
Canadian Pacific’s future interest costs will rise significantly as debt refinances.
“the interest costs for them going forward structurally are going to increase significantly”
Listen at 1:01:36
Canadian Pacific’s post-merger shareholder value creation has been disappointing.
“the value creation for shareholders since this deal has gone through just hasn't been amazing by any means.”
Listen at 1:03:49
Keith Creel’s target compensation is approximately 93% performance-linked.
“about 93% of target pay is at risk.”
Listen at 1:04:29
Changes to a company’s compensation framework are a warning sign for shareholders.
“it's always a yellow flag when the compensation framework shifts.”
Listen at 1:05:55
Canadian Pacific Kansas City management is capable operationally.
“my overall take on management is that they are good at what they do”
Listen at 1:07:59
The Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern merger could reduce Canadian Pacific’s growth prospects.
“it probably would put a dent in the growth story.”
Listen at 1:10:04
Higher tariffs and slower nearshoring would materially hurt Canadian Pacific Kansas City.
“if terrorists between any of these countries are to go up dramatically and nearshoring slows down, then Canadian Pacific Kansas City is going to be a real victim of that and feel the pain of it.”
Listen at 1:11:05
Canadian Pacific’s post-merger non-coal volumes increased 22%.
“Since the merger, if you exclude coal, their volumes are up 22% as seen by revenue track miles.”
Listen at 1:12:48
Canadian Pacific’s automotive freight grew 19% in the latest quarter.
“automotive just grew 19% last quarter”
Listen at 1:14:28
Kyle Grieve assumes Canadian Pacific revenue grows 6% annually for five years.
“in my base case for revenue growth, I assume about a 6% growth rate over the next five years.”
Listen at 1:17:29
Kyle Grieve assumes Canadian Pacific reaches approximately 53% EBITDA margins.
“I'm using EBITDA margins of about 53%”
Listen at 1:17:51
Kyle Grieve values Canadian Pacific at about $165, implying roughly 7% returns including dividends.
“with those assumptions, I get a value of about $165, which offers a return of about 7%, including dividends.”
Listen at 1:18:14
Kyle Grieve’s bear case values Canadian Pacific at $111 if merger and trade risks worsen.
“In the bear case, the merger goes through with minimal conditions and trade with Mexico slows. With all that, I get a value of $111”
Listen at 1:18:39
Kyle Grieve recommends not buying Canadian Pacific at its current valuation.
“I'm perfectly fine taking a pass on this business.”
Listen at 1:18:53
Canadian Pacific is a high-quality business whose valuation reflects its quality.
“Canadian Pacific, Kansas City is a great business that is also already priced like one”
Listen at 1:19:28
A roughly 7% annual return is insufficient for the portfolio’s hurdle rate.
“if you have a base case of roughly 7% a year, it just doesn't move the needle for the portfolio”
Listen at 1:19:51
The portfolio already has indirect railroad exposure through Berkshire Hathaway’s BNSF ownership.
“we already have indirect railroad exposure through Berkshire Hathaway and their ownership of BNSF.”
Listen at 1:19:58
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.