Nov 4, 2026 · 1h 7m
AI volatility tests the market’s appetite for growth
The AI Theme Isn’t Dead, Apple and Palantir Report, Alphabet’s Very Bad Day, HALO Is Back
The episode separates genuine deterioration in technology fundamentals from sentiment, positioning, and a potentially healthy rotation into value and defensive stocks.
- 1Strong results from AMD, Toast, and Palantir contrast with sharp reactions that expose how fragile AI-related sentiment has become.
- 2Alphabet’s search and YouTube misses intensify questions about AI monetization, while Apple’s resilience supports its role as a stability-oriented hedge.
- 3Rising AI hedging, huge capital expenditures, and a value-growth reversal suggest leadership may remain unstable rather than permanently broken.
Don't miss
The hosts use Apple’s historical tendency to rise when the semiconductor index falls to test whether it can hedge concentrated AI exposure.
The brief
Josh Brown and Michael Batnick begin with earnings from Toast, AMD, Apple, Palantir, and Uber, finding strong operating results alongside unusually unforgiving market reactions.
The hosts argue that losses in prominent AI and technology stocks obscure healthier breadth, with equal-weight performance and advancing-stock data challenging the idea of a market-wide catastrophe.
Alphabet’s 30% drawdown raises two linked concerns: AI-generated answers could weaken search monetization, while short-form video pressures YouTube’s growth.
The discussion turns to defensive “HALO” investments and Apple, whose resilience and tendency to rise when semiconductors fall make it a possible hedge against AI exposure.
Huge hyperscaler spending, memory costs, AI-bubble anxiety, and puts on CoreWeave lead to a broader question: does hedging signal danger or a self-correcting bull market?
A final value-versus-growth chart shows leadership reversing dramatically, leaving the hosts open to a temporary rotation while expecting the cycle to remain unstable.
What was said on this episode
31 statements · 20 positive · 9 negative · 1 mixed · 1 neutral
Toast is rapidly becoming hospitality’s most important payments and vertical-software platform.
“Toast is becoming, rapidly becoming. the most important platform in the hospitality industry for payments and vertical software”
Listen at 4:39
Toast’s market capitalization is too small if it reaches $10 billion recurring revenue.
“if this company can hit that $10 billion goal over the long term and they can continue to progress at this rate, like I just feel like the market cap is too small for the size of the business”
Listen at 6:12
Josh Brown remains bullish on Toast as a long-term opportunity.
“I remain long and I still think this is a great long term. opportunity.”
Listen at 7:31
Apple’s earnings were good but not great, and its stock reaction was reasonable.
“I thought they were good, not great. And I thought the stock's reaction was an adult reaction.”
Listen at 11:55
Apple buyers primarily seek earnings stability rather than quarterly growth.
“I think the people that have been buying Apple have a different motivation. They're looking for the stability of earnings.”
Listen at 12:09
Apple stands apart from data-center-driven XLK exposure.
“Apple really stands alone outside of that.”
Listen at 15:30
Palantir’s commercial business now exceeds its government business.
“the commercial business is now larger than the government contracting business”
Listen at 17:18
Palantir’s commercial revenue grew 148% year over year.
“It's 148% commercial revenue growth year over year.”
Listen at 17:53
Palantir could recover sharply after its earnings decline.
“Yeah, for sure.”
Listen at 19:18
Michael Batnick will buy Uber if it opens below $60.
“if Uber face plants tomorrow, if Uber opens below 60, I'll buy the stock.”
Listen at 19:43
Uber stock has declined after six of its last seven earnings reports.
“Uber has fallen six out of the last seven earnings reports.”
Listen at 19:48
Uber’s autonomous-taxi partnerships lack visible deployment while Waymo advances rapidly.
“They are putting out a ton of press releases about. partnerships with autonomous uh taxi companies but people do not see them on the streets and waymo is full speed ahead”
Listen at 20:24
“two thirds of all stocks in the index have had a 20% entry year drawdown”
Listen at 23:00
Ninety-three percent of technology stocks experienced a 20% drawdown in 2026.
“93% of all tech stocks have experienced a 20% drawdown in 2026.”
Listen at 23:41
Historically, Nasdaq never closed lower seven months after this reversal pattern.
“The index never closed lower seven months out.”
Listen at 27:33
Google monetizes AI search results at a lower rate than traditional search.
“The monetization rate on AI results or AI mode. versus traditional search is lower.”
Listen at 28:49
AI threatens Google’s search business.
“AI is a threat to Google.”
Listen at 29:55
A small decline in Google search share could halve its stock price.
“That number could fall 2%. The stock could go down 50%.”
Listen at 30:38
YouTube cannot compete effectively with short-form video clips.
“they can't compete with this with the short term with the short-term clips or the short clips”
Listen at 33:02
Michael Batnick would buy substantial Google stock near $215.
“If it got to 215. If it got to that gap from September of 2025. That's 20-ish, 22% lower. I would be very happy to buy a lot there.”
Listen at 33:47
Josh Brown expects Google to bounce near $270.
“I like this 270 area for a shorter term bounce.”
Listen at 34:29
Michael Batnick views current market conditions as bullish.
“I think this is so bullish.”
Listen at 38:43
Rising estimates, lower multiples, and investor worry support bull-market sustainability.
“I think it's awesome for the sustainability of a bull market.”
Listen at 39:01
Josh Brown expects memory-market conditions to improve.
“I can't imagine it stays this way.”
Listen at 44:31
Apple rose 65% of days when the semiconductor index fell at least 2%.
“this year, 65% of the time, when the socks is down 2% or more, Apple is higher.”
Listen at 47:36
Higher capital costs can push companies toward equity issuance and dilution.
“Higher cost of capital. Actually, you know what? We're not going to issue more debt. We're actually going to do some dilution.”
Listen at 51:28
Investors buying AI protection is inconsistent with a typical bubble peak.
“not something you typically say at the top of a bubble.”
Listen at 51:54
Anthropic reportedly holds more cash than every Magnificent Seven company except Alphabet.
“Anthropic has more cash on its balance sheet than any of the MAG7s other than Alphabet at $131 billion.”
Listen at 56:26
Anthropic is managing its cash better than Michael Batnick expected.
“They're doing a lot better job managing the cash than I would have thought.”
Listen at 56:58
Josh Brown may short the Roundhill NeoCloud ETF.
“I might short some of this thing.”
Listen at 1:02:14
Josh Brown expects value leadership to last six weeks to six months before Nvidia reaches $300.
“It'll run for six weeks to six months and then... And then NVIDIA goes to 300”
Listen at 1:04:05
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.