Modern Wisdom
Modern Wisdom

May 9, 2026 · 2h 19m

Algorithms are rewriting the rules of modern metal music

Nik Nocturnal - How TikTok Hijacked the Future of Music - #1095

The survival of independent music depends on how artists navigate the forced transition from pure creators to algorithmic content producers.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1TikTok and YouTube have altered songwriting structures by prioritizing short, viral moments over cohesive album experiences.
  2. 2The metal genre is actively shifting from traditional thrash to atmospheric and groove-oriented subgenres.
  3. 3Modern musicians are forced to act as full-time content creators to maintain visibility on digital platforms.

The brief

The traditional path to musical success has been dismantled by digital platforms, forcing modern metal artists to choose between authentic creative expression and writing songs designed to satisfy social media algorithms.

Music creator Nik Nocturnal argues that platforms like TikTok have fundamentally altered songwriting structures, pushing artists toward short, hook-heavy moments rather than cohesive, full-length album experiences.

This digital shift coincides with a major stylistic evolution in heavy music, as the genre transitions away from classic thrash metal toward more atmospheric, groove-oriented subgenres that thrive online.

To survive in the modern landscape, musicians must navigate the exhausting reality of becoming full-time content creators, balancing the demands of self-promotion with the preservation of their artistic integrity.

What was said on this episode

68 statements · 38 positive · 16 negative · 5 mixed · 9 neutral

  1. Nik Nocturnalon TikTokPositive0:07

    TikTok has significantly influenced modern metal through younger listeners.

    “it has a pretty big impact because all the young kids growing up right now on TikTok”

    Listen at 0:07

  2. Nik Nocturnalon TikTokPositive1:34

    TikTok’s short clips make modern metal immediately intriguing to new listeners.

    “TikTok, I think, really enforces that, where people will be scrolling and they'll just hear like this crazy noise or breakdown or some dude screaming and doing goblin noises, and it'll be like, oh, I want more of this.”

    Listen at 1:34

  3. Nik Nocturnalon Modern metal musicPositive1:52

    TikTok has helped expand metal music into a more normalized audience.

    “And I think that has really helped play push metal into a bigger kind of, more just normalized audience.”

    Listen at 1:52

  4. Nik Nocturnalon TikTokPositive1:53

    TikTok has helped metal reach and normalize a broader audience.

    “I think that has really helped play push metal into a bigger kind of, more just normalized audience.”

    Listen at 1:53

  5. Knocked Loose naturally fits short-form platforms because its music is intense and well paced.

    “because their music is so intense and so. Well, moment, like. What's the right word? It's. It's paced so well. They. They naturally work in that way.”

    Listen at 4:35

  6. Nik Nocturnalon Songs engineered around viral momentsNegative5:21

    Songs built around viral moments often lack replayability and lasting appeal.

    “you won't get replayability. You won't get that timelessness of a song.”

    Listen at 5:21

  7. Nik Nocturnalon Mick Gordon’s Doom soundtrackPositive10:06

    Mick Gordon’s Doom soundtrack remains a major influence on modern metal.

    “that is still one of the biggest influences on modern metal.”

    Listen at 10:06

  8. Nik Nocturnalon LoathePositive12:05

    Loathe’s music gained popularity because it had unusually timeless qualities.

    “they had a bit more of that timeless effort”

    Listen at 12:05

  9. Nik Nocturnalon LoathePositive12:05

    Loathe’s songs had lasting qualities that helped explain their delayed growth.

    “they had a bit more of that timeless effort where they.”

    Listen at 12:05

  10. Nik Nocturnalon Sleep TokenPositive21:35

    Sleep Token and similar modern metal bands appeal across multiple generations.

    “These very particular modern metal bands are like. They seem to be like going through all the generations.”

    Listen at 21:35

  11. Bring Me the Horizon will redefine a generation by reviving 2000s deathcore.

    “I think they're going to literally do that because there's already been the movement of, like, reintroducing 2000 death core.”

    Listen at 30:49

  12. Bring Me the Horizon is uniquely returning to deathcore after making pop music.

    “I don't see another band that says, hey, we started Deathcore, made a pop record, and now we're making deathcore music again.”

    Listen at 32:24

  13. Bring Me the Horizon popularized production and synth techniques for modern metal.

    “the band that. That made it massive. So all these other bands could come along and be like, oh, you made it work.”

    Listen at 34:38

  14. Nik Nocturnalon Musical note sequencesNeutral37:10

    All musical note sequences have already been used in music history.

    “I think in terms of music, every single one has ever been done is done”

    Listen at 37:10

  15. Nik Nocturnalon Metal industry relationshipsPositive43:05

    In metal’s interconnected industry, avoiding bad behavior generally protects professional relationships.

    “if you're a dick, it's really obvious. Just don't be a dick to people and then you'll usually be fine.”

    Listen at 43:05

  16. Nik Nocturnalon Musical copyingNegative43:11

    Musicians should avoid copying another artist’s song because imitation is easily detected.

    “trying not to copy paste someone's song session because it can be very, like, super obvious.”

    Listen at 43:11

  17. Nik Nocturnalon Modern genre-fluid metalPositive52:46

    Genre-fluid metal still requires strong songwriting to retain listeners after initial virality.

    “it still comes down to you gotta have good songwriting or like, no one's gonna care after the first initial.”

    Listen at 52:46

  18. Nik Nocturnalon Sleep TokenPositive57:08

    Sleep Token’s breakthrough resulted from a strong catalog, a great song, and Internet momentum.

    “It was just. It was the perfect storm.”

    Listen at 57:08

  19. Nik Nocturnalon Internet music viralityPositive57:34

    Internet-driven music virality can be engineered to some extent.

    “The other stuff I think you can engineer to a point, especially in modern day with the Internet”

    Listen at 57:34

  20. Nik Nocturnalon Record labelsNegative58:28

    Labels may use Reddit accounts and clip farming to manufacture attention for new bands.

    “I'm not surprised if people post Reddit posts of their brand new band and it's like the label actually getting a new account or something where they're posting a bunch or clip farming with that”

    Listen at 58:28

  21. Nik Nocturnalon Music marketing campaignsNeutral58:49

    Labels will increasingly use burner accounts and paid clip promotion to market music.

    “that's gonna happen more and more. That happens a lot in content.”

    Listen at 58:49

  22. Chris Williamsonon Fabricated social-media interactionsPositive1:00:53

    Fabricated social interactions can raise songs in platform recommendation rankings.

    “These ginned up interactions push the songs and the discussion around them higher up platforms Algorithm rankings”

    Listen at 1:00:53

  23. Nik Nocturnalon Engineered music promotionNegative1:01:44

    Engineered music promotion turns discovery into a competitive game.

    “It gamifies it.”

    Listen at 1:01:44

  24. Nik Nocturnalon Metal fansPositive1:05:52

    Metal fans are more personally invested in bands than typical pop or rap listeners.

    “I think a lot of metal fans are more, are more invested in like the actual band and it means a lot more to them than just like, oh, another like you know, pop record or rap record.”

    Listen at 1:05:52

  25. Chris Williamsonon Creator burnoutNegative1:30:54

    Creators burn out because online feedback is weaker and slower than live-performance feedback.

    “I think creators burn out because they don't have sufficiently loud and sufficiently quick feedback mechanisms to give them the positive reinforcement that bands and comedians and DJs get when they go on the road.”

    Listen at 1:30:54

  26. Nik Nocturnalon Creator lifestyleNegative1:31:18

    The creator lifestyle is highly isolating.

    “It is a very isolating thing.”

    Listen at 1:31:18

  27. Chris Williamsonon Band-member separationNegative1:33:48

    Greater separation among band members worsens their mental health.

    “I think that mental health will decline in line with how separated the members of a band get.”

    Listen at 1:33:48

  28. Nik Nocturnalon Platform diversificationPositive1:39:17

    Content creators and musicians should diversify beyond a single platform or income source.

    “I would always advise this to, like, other content people and as well as even musicians of just like, please, God, do not just trust this one thing.”

    Listen at 1:39:17

  29. Nik Nocturnalon Platform dependence for creators and musiciansNegative1:39:21

    Creators and musicians should diversify beyond reliance on one platform.

    “please, God, do not just trust this one thing.”

    Listen at 1:39:21

  30. Nik Nocturnalon Creator income diversificationPositive1:40:03

    Diversifying income makes creators less vulnerable to unilateral platform changes.

    “if you diversify yourself, you're also much less of a, like, susceptible to like, just, just a platform”

    Listen at 1:40:03

  31. Nik Nocturnalon Music streaming paymentsNegative1:41:21

    Music streaming payments are insufficient for artists.

    “streaming doesn't pay enough.”

    Listen at 1:41:21

  32. Nik Nocturnalon Record-label contractsNegative1:41:29

    Some bands lose royalty and streaming revenue through contract terms.

    “a lot of bands also are on contracts and, And a lot of the. On those contracts, they're not realizing maybe, hey, they didn't. They signed off, like, all of their royalties or all of their, you know, streaming revenue”

    Listen at 1:41:29

  33. Nik Nocturnalon Music streaming royaltiesMixed1:42:01

    Artists’ low streaming income also reflects contracts and recoupment obligations, not only Spotify’s rates.

    “Spotify should pay more, but there's other stuff involved.”

    Listen at 1:42:01

  34. Nik Nocturnalon Record-label contractsNegative1:46:33

    A typical five-record deal can commit a band to roughly ten years of releases.

    “If we do the two year cycle of most majority of bands of release schedule, you signed away 10 years of your life.”

    Listen at 1:46:33

  35. Nik Nocturnalon Multi-album record dealsNegative1:46:38

    Multi-album record deals can commit musicians to roughly a decade of work.

    “you signed away 10 years of your life.”

    Listen at 1:46:38

  36. Nik Nocturnalon Inexperienced musiciansNegative1:47:48

    Musicians lacking business guidance are likely to be exploited by the music industry.

    “they're going to get taken advantage of because that's how the industry works”

    Listen at 1:47:48

  37. Nik Nocturnalon Alternative musicPositive1:56:35

    Alternative music is becoming increasingly genreless.

    “I think the scene is becoming more and more genreless”

    Listen at 1:56:35

  38. Nik Nocturnalon Alternative musicPositive1:56:35

    Alternative music is becoming less genre-bound, potentially producing more good songs.

    “I think the scene is becoming more and more genreless, which I get excited about, because then the focus is not, hey, can we make a deathcore or a metalcore or a pop, you know, popcorn, whatever the fuck banger is. Can we just make a good song? You know, like. And, you know, I love that because then there's going to be a higher quantity of good music.”

    Listen at 1:56:35

  39. Nik Nocturnalon Genre fluidity in alternative musicPositive1:56:55

    Greater genre fluidity will produce more good music.

    “then there's going to be a higher quantity of good music.”

    Listen at 1:56:55

  40. Nik Nocturnalon Metal musicPositive1:57:17

    Metal is currently more popular than ever.

    “metal is the good and the bad. Metal's becoming more popular than ever.”

    Listen at 1:57:17

  41. Nik Nocturnalon Octane Core songwritingNegative1:57:26

    Growing metal popularity is encouraging formulaic Octane Core songwriting.

    “it's becoming more of like a specific structure of how to write like an Octane Core song”

    Listen at 1:57:26

  42. Nik Nocturnalon Heavy musicMixed1:59:34

    Metal’s rising popularity is producing both more creative and more formulaic bands.

    “heavy music's getting more popular. Great. And that's getting injected in a way where bands are becoming more creative with it, but then also bands are becoming more sterile with it.”

    Listen at 1:59:34

  43. Nik Nocturnalon Commercialization of heavy musicMixed1:59:37

    Metal’s growing popularity is producing both creative and sterile music.

    “bands are becoming more creative with it, but then also bands are becoming more sterile with it.”

    Listen at 1:59:37

  44. Nik Nocturnalon Extreme metal genre fusionPositive2:02:12

    Cross-genre experimentation is creating unusually distinctive extreme metal.

    “So there's bands that do that. I've been doing that for a while. And then there's a band like the small band Marauder, which they took that and they're like, oh, dubstep sick. Oh, I love like Beethoven. And so they infuse, you know what I mean? So they infuse that with these sounds and it's like a whole nother world of like music.”

    Listen at 2:02:12

  45. Chris Williamsonon Independent music publishingPositive2:02:53

    Independent creators can reach markets without record labels.

    “because everybody can reach the market freely. There are no. If you don't, you don't even need a record label.”

    Listen at 2:02:53

  46. Scarce mainstream placements confer greater prestige.

    “the people who can get there have even more prestige”

    Listen at 2:03:13

  47. Chris Williamsonon YouTube publishingNegative2:03:53

    Open YouTube publishing has low prestige because anyone can do it.

    “It's low prestige for precisely the same reason. Anyone can do it.”

    Listen at 2:03:53

  48. Chris Williamsonon Music scenesNeutral2:04:25

    Scarce mainstream access will incentivize music scenes to split further.

    “that is going to create an incentive. So I think you're right that you're going to end up with sort of two scenes splintering off in additional directions.”

    Listen at 2:04:25

  49. Nik Nocturnalon Sleep TokenNeutral2:05:11

    Sleep Token is primarily pop-oriented music with metal elements.

    “They are a. They're more Of a pop leaning band with metal elements”

    Listen at 2:05:11

  50. Nik Nocturnalon Sleep TokenPositive2:05:31

    Sleep Token’s newer record combines top-50 songs with extreme passages.

    “That was great. Had like top 50 bangers, but then also had some of the most. I'm gonna use the word extreme instead of heavy extreme moments”

    Listen at 2:05:31

  51. Chris Williamsonon UK Grammy nominationsPositive2:06:48

    The UK should embrace every Grammy nomination it receives.

    “we should take every Grammy nomination that we can get”

    Listen at 2:06:48

  52. Nik Nocturnalon Billy TalentNegative2:09:21

    Billy Talent is not well known in America.

    “I don't think in America they're very well known”

    Listen at 2:09:21

  53. Chris Williamsonon HolywaterPositive2:10:23
    “On Friday, they supported Architects, bro. Fucking three quarters of a mil now.”

    Listen at 2:10:23

  54. Chris Williamsonon HolywaterPositive2:10:51

    Holywater makes progressive metal.

    “these guys are really fucking like that progressive metal”

    Listen at 2:10:51

  55. Nik Nocturnalon Modern metalNeutral2:12:31

    The discussed genre is broadly modern metal.

    “it's all modern metal, basically”

    Listen at 2:12:31

  56. Nik Nocturnalon MirarNeutral2:13:21

    Mirar consists of two musicians and has no vocals.

    “It's just two dudes. Two dudes, no vocals.”

    Listen at 2:13:21

  57. Nik Nocturnalon MirarPositive2:13:34

    Mirar creates the featured sound using a guitar.

    “He's making that noise with a fricking guitar.”

    Listen at 2:13:34

  58. Nik Nocturnalon MirarPositive2:14:12

    Mirar’s musical moment ranks among Nik’s coolest of the past decade.

    “It's one of those. Where it is one of the coolest moments I've heard in music in the past, like 10 years”

    Listen at 2:14:12

  59. Boundaries combines 2000s nostalgia with a modern heavy sound.

    “They're a mix of kind of like that 2000 nostalgic stuff with a very Modern, heavy edge.”

    Listen at 2:15:15

  60. Nik Nocturnalon BoundariesNeutral2:15:58

    Boundaries uses clean singing from its drummer and screaming from its vocalist.

    “the drummer is clean singing and then the vocalist is screaming.”

    Listen at 2:15:58

  61. Chris Williamsonon Metal scenePositive2:16:19

    The metal scene continues to exist and remain active.

    “The scene continues to live on”

    Listen at 2:16:19

  62. Nik Nocturnalon Nik NocturnalPositive2:16:54

    Nik and his wife will write songs daily on livestreams.

    “We're gonna be writing songs every day on stream from start to finish”

    Listen at 2:16:54

  63. Nik Nocturnalon Nik NocturnalPositive2:17:13

    Nik will release songs when audience demand is sufficiently strong.

    “you're gonna release them if people want them enough.”

    Listen at 2:17:13

  64. Songs from the project will be released based on audience demand.

    “you're gonna release them if people want them enough. So it's gonna be based fully on demand.”

    Listen at 2:17:13

  65. Song releases will be determined entirely by audience demand.

    “So it's gonna be based fully on demand.”

    Listen at 2:17:16

  66. Nik Nocturnalon Nik NocturnalPositive2:17:30

    Strongly demanded songs will receive full campaigns including music videos.

    “I'll do the music video in the room or like in. You know, in the swamp in Florida.”

    Listen at 2:17:30

  67. Nik Nocturnalon Nik Nocturnal’s wifePositive2:18:00

    Nik Nocturnal’s wife will produce and create her own music during the project.

    “she's gonna be producing and doing her own stuff”

    Listen at 2:18:00

  68. Nik and his wife will collaborate livestreamed when a project gains major traction.

    “when something goes crazy and you want to do it together, let's go. We'll do it together on stream”

    Listen at 2:18:10

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.