Sep 1, 2026 · 30 min
Amber Frey exposes Scott Peterson’s shifting lies
The Double Life of Scott Peterson: The Other Woman — Ep. 1 | MK Confidential
Amber Frey’s cooperation gave investigators recorded evidence of Peterson’s deception as the search for Laci and Connor intensified.
- 1Scott Peterson began a relationship with Amber Frey while falsely claiming he was single.
- 2After learning about Laci’s disappearance, Frey recorded Peterson’s calls and publicly disclosed their affair.
- 3The discovery of nearby remains in San Francisco Bay raised hopes of resolving the search for Laci and Connor.
Don't miss
Amber secretly records Scott Peterson while confronting him about his claim that his wife had died, giving investigators evidence of his evasions.
The brief
Scott Peterson meets Amber Frey on New Year’s Eve and presents himself as a single fertilizer salesman, building a relationship around elaborate stories and concealed facts.
Peterson eventually claims his wife has died, but his confession only extends the deception; even after Amber learns about Laci’s disappearance, his explanations keep shifting.
Detectives ask Amber to cooperate, then equip her to record Peterson’s calls. Her confrontation captures a pattern investigators describe as constant lying, even when simpler answers would suffice.
Amber goes public, confirms the affair, and receives support from Sharon Rocha, Laci’s mother. She later cuts contact with Peterson and returns the recording equipment and tapes.
Two months later, a baby’s body and a nearby woman’s body are found in San Francisco Bay, near the area where Peterson said he took his boat.
What was said on this episode
11 statements · 1 positive · 6 negative · 1 mixed · 3 neutral
Lacey Peterson was alive, living in Modesto, and pregnant at that time.
“At this point, Lacey Peterson is very much alive and living in Modesto, pregnant with their son.”
Listen at 6:55
Scott Peterson appeared upset and almost scared to Amber Frey.
“He looked upset, almost scared.”
Listen at 8:17
Scott Peterson had lied to Amber Frey about being married.
“he had lied about being married”
Listen at 8:28
Amber Frey considered that Scott Peterson’s wife might have died in a car accident.
“I didn't know maybe she died in a car accident.”
Listen at 8:45
Amber Frey secretly recorded more than 140 calls with Scott over seven weeks.
“The next seven weeks amber secretly records more than 140 calls with scott”
Listen at 18:47
Amber Frey said Scott Peterson told her he was unmarried.
“I was told he was unmarried. Scott told me he was not married.”
Listen at 23:22
Amber Frey immediately contacted Modesto police after learning of Scott’s involvement.
“When I discovered he was involved in the Lacey Peterson disappearance case, I immediately contacted the Modesto Police Department.”
Listen at 23:31
Amber Frey recommended ending contact with Scott until the case was resolved.
“I think it'd be best if you and I didn't talk anymore until there's resolution in this.”
Listen at 26:39
The discovered remains were identified as a full-term baby boy’s body.
“It is unmistakably the full-term body of a very small baby boy.”
Listen at 27:38
Authorities suspected but had not confirmed the remains were Lacey and Connor.
“it is suspected but not certain. that this is Lacey Peterson and her baby, Connor.”
Listen at 28:55
DNA confirmation was required to identify the remains as Lacey and Connor.
“Authorities must wait for DNA to confirm their identities.”
Listen at 29:01
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.