The NPR Politics Podcast
The NPR Politics Podcast

Sep 18, 2026 · 29 min

Anti-Muslim rhetoric returns to Republican campaign ads

Campaign messaging, concerts & Can't Let It Go

The episode examines how fear-based messaging about Muslim candidates and communities is reshaping political campaigns, alongside a debate over artists’ political speech.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Republican campaign ads revive claims about Sharia law, Muslim candidates, and threats to American identity through cinematic fearmongering.
  2. 2Macklemore’s removal from Ed Sheeran’s tour raises questions about whether commercial consequences for political speech amount to silencing.
  3. 3The closing stories move from royal drama and skunks to a bizarre fitness-race controversy over winning after defecating mid-competition.

Don't miss

The hosts debate whether a fitness competitor’s first-place finish should stand after she defecated during the race and later surrendered the victory.

The brief

Barbara Sprunt outlines the return of anti-Muslim rhetoric in Republican campaign ads, following prominent victories by Muslim candidates and a broader shift toward fear-based messaging.

The ads use cinematic imagery, AI-generated visuals, red-green alliance claims, and warnings about Sharia law to portray Muslim candidates and communities as threats.

Isabella Gomez Sarmiento reports on Macklemore’s removal from Ed Sheeran’s tour after pro-Palestinian remarks, while the hosts debate speech, backlash, and the Streisand effect.

The episode closes with “Can’t Let It Go” stories about Harry and Meghan, skunks driven from a crawl space by NPR broadcasts, and a fitness competitor who surrendered a victory after defecating during the race.

What was said on this episode

13 statements · 2 positive · 8 negative · 3 neutral

  1. Political rhetoric is shifting from portraying Muslims as security threats to civilizational threats.

    “there is a sort of language shift in the way that we're seeing this play out from the tropes of Muslims as a security threat. to a civilizational threat.”

    Listen at 1:53

  2. Barbara Sprunton Great Replacement conspiracy theoryNegative3:33

    Great Replacement conspiracy theory has inspired or driven deadly attacks.

    “there have been deadly attacks in, gosh, Buffalo, Pittsburgh, El Paso, San Diego. I mean, sadly, the list goes on and on that have all been sort of inspired or driven by this conspiracy theory.”

    Listen at 3:33

  3. Danielle Kurtzlebenon Sharia law in the United StatesNeutral6:45

    Sharia law is not being imposed in the United States.

    “Sharia law in the U.S., not a thing that's happening.”

    Listen at 6:45

  4. Barbara Sprunton Sharia law in the United StatesNegative7:23

    Islamic religious principles cannot override the U.S. Constitution.

    “It can't usurp the U.S. Constitution.”

    Listen at 7:23

  5. Republican messaging about Sharia law is a scare tactic.

    “I think it's clear it's a scare tactic.”

    Listen at 8:26

  6. Barbara Sprunton Muslim-community development project near DallasNegative9:50

    A Muslim-community development project became a major Texas Republican issue.

    “it just became this sort of like huge issue among Republicans in Texas.”

    Listen at 9:50

  7. Tamara Keithon Fear in political campaignsPositive10:28

    Fear motivates voters more effectively than contentment.

    “fear is a motivator in a way that contentment is not.”

    Listen at 10:28

  8. Danielle Kurtzlebenon Republican campaign issuesNeutral10:52

    Anti-Muslim messaging replaced immigration as a key Republican issue.

    “anti-Muslim messaging supplanted immigration as a key issue for Republicans.”

    Listen at 10:52

  9. Barbara Sprunton Fear-based political messagingPositive11:34

    Fear can be an effective political messaging strategy.

    “fear can be an effective political messaging strategy.”

    Listen at 11:34

  10. Barbara Sprunton Republican anti-Muslim messagingNegative12:27

    Anti-Muslim fear messaging may backfire against Republicans in some places.

    “in some places it may actually backfire for Republicans.”

    Listen at 12:27

  11. Barbara Sprunton Privacy and residence photographyNegative25:19

    People concerned about privacy should not publicly share images revealing their residence.

    “perhaps like don't photograph. like where you live and then send it on blast if you're, you know, concerned about your privacy.”

    Listen at 25:19

  12. Many people believe Joanna Wettrick should have left the race after defecating.

    “it seems like many people are lining up behind. She should have been pulled off the course. She should have quit, but she did not quit.”

    Listen at 28:04

  13. Joanna Wettrick’s defecation during the race was accidental.

    “I do believe this was accidental.”

    Listen at 28:42

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Books & mentions

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.

Anti-Muslim rhetoric returns to Republican campaign ads · PodLume