
Nov 22, 2026 · 58 min
Ben Macdui’s Grey Man links Scottish and Appalachian folklore
Haunted Hiking Trails | Scotland’s Big Grey Man of Ben Macdui - Episode 400
The episode tests whether recurring reports from two historically connected mountain ranges reflect folklore, perception, or something less easily explained.
- 1Ben Macdui’s Am Fear Liath Mor appears in reports of fog, dread, pressure, enormous footsteps, and a towering hairy figure.
- 2The hosts connect Scottish Highlands and Appalachian traditions through shared geology, migration, and parallel stories of mountain beings.
- 3Skeptical explanations include fear, dehydration, hallucination, and Brocken spectres, but recurring footsteps and unseen presences remain unresolved.
Don't miss
John Norman Collie’s account of enormous footsteps following him through Ben Macdui’s fog becomes the legend’s defining historical moment.
The brief
The 400th episode opens in the Scottish Highlands, where a fogbound hike on Ben Macdui becomes an encounter with Am Fear Liath Mor, the Big Grey Man.
The hosts connect the Scottish Highlands and Appalachia through shared geological history and compare their traditions of remote mountains, hairy beings, and stories people hesitate to tell.
John Norman Collie’s 1891 account of enormous footsteps helped bring the legend into public view, while later witnesses described pressure, shadows, fog, and a towering figure.
The episode weighs Bigfoot, paranormal, extraterrestrial, psychological, and optical explanations, including the Brocken spectre, without resolving why similar reports persist.
A listener’s Scottish mimic story closes the investigation with a familiar voice heard in mist, then replaced by an unexpected figure at a race finish.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.