WSJ's Take On the Week
WSJ's Take On the Week

Nov 22, 2026 · 34 min

Birkin bags challenge luxury stocks as AI wealth reshapes demand

Luxury Stocks Are Down. Is Now the Time to Invest (in Birkin Bags)?

The episode tests whether scarce physical luxury assets can outperform luxury equities as new AI wealth, resale markets, and shopping technology change the sector.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Luxury stocks face pressure from weaker aspirational demand, especially in China and the Middle East.
  2. 2Birkin and Kelly bags offer a scarcity-driven alternative, but resale liquidity and changing tastes remain important risks.
  3. 3AI wealth may expand luxury demand while agentic commerce makes prices more transparent and favors experiential retail.

Don't miss

Dana Auslander explains how Luxus sources scarce Birkin and Kelly bags, then compares their resale economics with luxury stocks.

The brief

Luxury stocks are weakening even as AI creates fresh fortunes. The episode links the contrast to aspirational shoppers, China and Middle East exposure, and uncertainty around the AI economy’s durability.

The Anthropic IPO and Nvidia’s financing role frame a broader question: will newly wealthy technology workers become traditional luxury consumers, or spend on experiences, cars, art and collectibles?

Guest Dana Auslander, who previously worked at Blackstone, explains why her Luxus fund buys and resells scarce Hermès Birkin and Kelly bags rather than luxury-company shares.

The comparison turns on supply and access: handbags can benefit from scarcity and resale demand, while equities remain exposed to macroeconomic weakness and changing consumer tastes.

Agentic commerce could make luxury prices easier to compare, but the discussion argues that in-person shopping and experiential retail may retain value as quiet luxury gains ground.

What was said on this episode

27 statements · 16 positive · 9 negative · 1 mixed · 1 neutral

  1. Telis Demoson AI tradeNegative3:36

    Anthropic’s IPO may signal that the AI trade has peaked.

    “whether that's a sign that like things have kind of topped out for the AI trade.”

    Listen at 3:36

  2. Telis Demoson AnthropicPositive10:02

    Anthropic may become the future focus of the AI investment trade.

    “Is Anthropic the future of that trade?”

    Listen at 10:02

  3. Dana Auslanderon Luxury stocks’ aspirational exposureNegative13:24

    Luxury stocks are hurt by substantial exposure to aspirational shoppers.

    “the luxury stocks that are hurting this year, LVMH, Caring, even Hermes is down 40%, have a big, big, big exposure piece to the aspirational shopper.”

    Listen at 13:24

  4. Dana Auslanderon China’s economy and luxury stocksNegative13:44

    China’s weak economy has significantly harmed luxury stocks.

    “China's hurt it quite a bit. The Chinese economy is faltering and having fits and starts in its growth.”

    Listen at 13:44

  5. Dana Auslanderon HermesPositive16:00

    Hermes and its leather-goods segment recently posted strong growth.

    “Hermes is actually doing pretty well. I mean, it was up 6% year over year in the last quarter. Leather goods are up 10.8.”

    Listen at 16:00

  6. Dana Auslanderon Experience economyPositive17:48

    The experience economy is currently thriving.

    “So the experience economy is thriving.”

    Listen at 17:48

  7. Dana Auslanderon Collectible-asset investorsPositive18:32

    Investors in collectible-asset funds are likely to consume those assets themselves.

    “My thesis has always been that the investor and the collector are the same person. So if the investor is investing in funds that create these kinds of assets, they're also going to be the consumer of those assets.”

    Listen at 18:32

  8. Dana Auslanderon Luxury goods pricingPositive21:20

    Higher prices for Birkin, Kelly, Patek, and Ferrari products increase demand.

    “when the brands raise the prices, demand goes up, which is contrary to most economic philosophy.”

    Listen at 21:20

  9. Dana Auslanderon Basic Birkin bagPositive22:28

    A basic Birkin can resell for approximately $35,000.

    “we can probably resell it. You find it on the secondary market for $35,000.”

    Listen at 22:28

  10. Dana Auslanderon Birkin bagsPositive22:40

    Birkin bags remain the most attractive luxury asset class.

    “still the most attractive asset class and luxury, in my opinion.”

    Listen at 22:40

  11. Dana Auslanderon Physical luxury assets versus luxury equitiesPositive23:22

    Physical luxury assets outperform luxury-company equities.

    “the asset performs really well compared to the equity.”

    Listen at 23:22

  12. Dana Auslanderon Retail investors in alternative assetsNegative23:53

    Retail investors should not be guinea pigs for emerging alternative assets.

    “We don't think retail investors should be the guinea pigs for emerging alternative asset classes.”

    Listen at 23:53

  13. Dana Auslanderon Luxury-company equitiesNegative24:32

    Luxury-company equities are substantially more expensive than desired.

    “The equity to me was a little bit too expensive. Not a little bit, a lot more expensive.”

    Listen at 24:32

  14. Dana Auslanderon The RealReal and eBayPositive25:22

    The RealReal and eBay have recently performed strongly in resale markets.

    “they've crushed it for the last four years. four or five quarters, eBay also reported record earnings.”

    Listen at 25:22

  15. Dana Auslanderon Agentic CommercePositive28:07

    Agentic shopping will make luxury-goods pricing more transparent.

    “we are going to see a much clearer focus on pricing.”

    Listen at 28:07

  16. Dana Auslanderon Agentic CommerceMixed29:00

    Agentic shopping will initially support research while humans complete luxury purchases.

    “I still think it'll be minimal, but I do think there'll be a hybrid between the shoppers, at least doing the agentic shoppers, doing research, looking for things, and then... the end human client closing the transaction.”

    Listen at 29:00

  17. Dana Auslanderon Luxury holiday seasonPositive29:28

    The upcoming holiday season will be strong, especially among top luxury consumers.

    “I do. I'm optimistic. You know, I'm usually a pessimist, but I think this is going to be a really interesting holiday season”

    Listen at 29:28

  18. Dana Auslanderon In-person luxury shoppingPositive30:29

    In-person luxury shopping will persist despite agentic commerce.

    “that's never going to go away”

    Listen at 30:29

  19. Dana Auslanderon Large luxury conglomeratesNegative30:59

    Large luxury conglomerates dependent on aspirational shoppers will have a difficult fourth quarter.

    “we're going to have a tough fourth quarter for the big, big luxury conglomerates that are very heavily dependent on the aspirational shopper.”

    Listen at 30:59

  20. Dana Auslanderon Logo-heavy luxury fashionNegative31:08

    Logo-heavy luxury fashion is currently out of fashion.

    “Logomania has also come out of fashion.”

    Listen at 31:08

  21. Dana Auslanderon Quiet luxuryPositive31:42

    Quiet luxury is outperforming louder aspirational luxury.

    “the quiet luxury win”

    Listen at 31:42

  22. Dana Auslanderon Luxury stocksNeutral32:12

    Investors should wait for full-year results before building a small luxury-stock position.

    “I would wait until full year results are in. So maybe February, take a look, build a small position.”

    Listen at 32:12

  23. Dana Auslanderon Luxury brandsNegative32:24

    Luxury brands need an adjustment period to regain footing outside the U.S. and Japan.

    “there will need to be some adjustment period for those luxury brands to gain their footing around the world outside the U.S. and Japan.”

    Listen at 32:24

  24. Dana Auslanderon Luxury beauty businessesPositive32:55

    Beauty businesses within luxury conglomerates have recovered well.

    “you've seen that recover quite nicely.”

    Listen at 32:55

  25. Dana Auslanderon Luxury wines, champagne, and spiritsPositive32:58

    Luxury wines, champagne, and spirits have recovered.

    “Wines have recovered.”

    Listen at 32:58

  26. Dana Auslanderon Luxury fashion and leather goodsNegative33:07

    Luxury fashion and leather goods remain under pressure.

    “I just think fashion and leather might be a little bit under pressure for now.”

    Listen at 33:07

  27. Dana Auslanderon Branded jewelryPositive33:34

    Branded jewelry remains an attractive area for investors to consider.

    “branded jewelry, in my opinion, is still very much to look at.”

    Listen at 33:34

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.

Birkin bags challenge luxury stocks as AI wealth reshapes demand · PodLume