Oct 21, 2026 · 1h 18m
Border veteran says Britain’s enforcement system lacks the tools to work
"I Policed the Border for 40 Years - the System is Broken" - Tony Smith CBE
The episode connects the small-boats crisis to legal constraints, weak removal mechanisms, smuggling networks, and missing border infrastructure.
- 1Legal obligations and limited removal routes constrain Britain’s ability to deter irregular entry and enforce rejected asylum decisions.
- 2Small-boat crossings are only the visible edge of a wider border operation that screens millions of potential visitors.
- 3Effective reform would require political backing, changes to domestic and international-law arrangements, and comprehensive biometric entry-exit tracking.
Don't miss
Smith explains why towing small boats back to France is not a straightforward solution, citing unsafe vessels, rescue obligations, and French refusal to accept returns.
The brief
Former Border Force leader Tony Smith traces four decades of changing asylum and border policy, arguing that powers once considered adequate no longer match the system’s demands.
Smith says smugglers coach migrants to present standardized claims, while international gangs exploit legal and practical limits that make removals difficult after arrival.
The discussion tests the idea of towing small boats back to France, but rescue duties, unsafe vessels, and French refusal expose the limits of a simple pushback policy.
Smith separates the small-boats crisis from the wider border operation, defending unseen work by Border Force and its partners while warning against broad attacks on frontline staff.
His reform agenda combines changes to human-rights and modern-slavery rules with stronger political leadership, realistic legislation, and biometric records of arrivals and departures.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.