
Aug 23, 2026 · 1h 19m
Campaigns chase voters who rarely think about politics
How to Reach the Unreachable Voter
Democrats’ digital problem is not simply spending less, but failing to understand where disengaged voters spend attention and how politics reaches them.
- 1Everyday internet behavior may predict political shifts better than traditional demographic indicators.
- 2Most observed searches were nonpolitical, yet searches about ordinary needs can reveal politically relevant concerns.
- 3Campaigns need platform-native creative, continuous research, and broader measures of digital advertising performance.
Don't miss
Butterfield reveals that fewer than 100,000 of roughly six million observed searches were political or politically adjacent.
The brief
Danielle Butterfield of Priorities USA explains why Democrats struggled online after 2024 despite outspending Republicans, as consultant incentives kept television at the center of campaign strategy.
YouTube is increasingly television, but campaigns still treat it like a conventional ad slot. Smart-TV viewing, second screens, skip buttons, and shrinking attention spans demand different creative choices.
Priorities USA studied roughly six million searches across search engines, social platforms, and AI tools; fewer than 100,000 were political or politically adjacent, revealing how rarely voters seek politics directly.
The organization’s research suggests internet habits can predict vote swings better than many traditional demographics, while everyday searches about benefits and other needs expose political concerns indirectly.
Butterfield says campaigns should prepare continuously for 2028, use high-leverage moments to define candidates such as J.D. Vance and Marco Rubio, and measure ads through response, comments, completion, and creative testing.
What was said on this episode
36 statements · 18 positive · 9 negative · 9 neutral
Democrats outspent Republicans two-to-one on digital advertising after 2024.
“In the aftermath of 2024, Democrats outspent Republicans 2 to 1 on digital.”
Listen at 6:17
Democrats still design digital programs to resemble television advertising.
“we're still running digital programs to mirror what goes on on television.”
Listen at 7:00
Nine of 2024’s ten top YouTube ads had first run on television.
“9 out of the 10 top YouTube ads in 2024 were just 30-second ads that ran on TV first.”
Listen at 8:13
Repurposing television ads on YouTube wastes advertising money.
“that is quite literally lighting money on fire.”
Listen at 8:28
Treating YouTube as a broadcast channel misses its distinctive value.
“if you are treating it like a broadcast channel, you are fully missing the point.”
Listen at 11:29
YouTube consumption predicted vote choice and vote swing better than other measured indicators.
“your consumption of YouTube was more predictive of your vote choice and your vote swing from '20 to '24 than anything else.”
Listen at 15:14
Men watching over three hours of YouTube showed among the largest vote swings.
“men who are watching more than 3 hours of YouTube had some of the highest swing of any other crosstab that we were looking at.”
Listen at 15:28
Priorities’ search study analyzed approximately six million searches.
“it was about 6 million searches.”
Listen at 23:11
Google retains the dominant share of search activity.
“Google is still king. Like, let's, let's just be really clear. Google is still huge market share, predominant market share”
Listen at 25:11
Users tend to fact-check on Google but develop detailed plans through ChatGPT.
“people are going to Google to really fact-check and get basic information, but then they're going to ChatGPT to really like put together robust plans and really go back and forth.”
Listen at 25:52
YouTube is the second-largest search engine after Google.
“I think that YouTube is the number 2 search engine behind Google.”
Listen at 26:44
YouTube search results are easier to influence than chatbot results.
“It's a lot easier to manipulate what comes up when someone searches for something on YouTube in a way that I think the Democratic Party needs to be spending a lot more time producing video than they do manipulating chatbot results.”
Listen at 27:21
Fewer than 100,000 of six million observed searches were political or politically adjacent.
“Of the 6 million searches that we acquired, less than 100,000 were political or even politically adjacent.”
Listen at 28:27
Political campaigns should create advertising relevant to people’s everyday interests.
“we got to create campaigns that are actually, you know, relevant to someone's day.”
Listen at 30:43
Over 90% of Democratic advertising investment has been geographically targeted.
“90-plus percent of Democratic advertising investments to date have been based on where you live”
Listen at 32:09
Cost is not a sufficient reason to avoid behaviorally targeted digital campaigns.
“If someone's bringing up cost as an excuse not to do a campaign like this, they're probably not fully grasping what we're talking about.”
Listen at 35:16
Most described behaviorally targeted political advertising is technically feasible, except Google offline-data targeting.
“everything else that you described, yes, would be doable.”
Listen at 36:39
Public-benefit searches are a major politically adjacent search category.
“People searching for how to download a FAFSA form, how to apply for Medicaid, what is Medicaid called in my state.”
Listen at 38:20
Fifty-four percent of voters do not pay attention to news.
“54% of voters writ large are just not paying attention to news.”
Listen at 41:50
Beauty, fashion, true crime, and parenting reach many politically mobile, news-avoiding voters.
“beauty and fashion, true crime, parenting, those are 3 categories that are reaching a really large set of voters who are both swingy and switch from party to party, but also don't pay attention to the news.”
Listen at 42:58
Political ads on YouTube should resemble the surrounding content.
“our ads should natively look like the content that someone is otherwise watching on YouTube.”
Listen at 46:34
Priorities’ Ohio campaign reportedly prevented users from reaching right-leaning content.
“we were able to effectively stop someone from getting to that right-leaning content.”
Listen at 48:16
TikTok does not permit political advertising.
“You cannot run political ads on TikTok.”
Listen at 48:58
Answer Engine Optimization is an updated form of search-engine optimization.
“AEO is just SEO 2.0”
Listen at 50:36
Chatbot results can be influenced through websites, AP stories, and Reddit posts.
“You change it by updating your website, you change it by pitching stories to the AP or posting shit on Reddit because that's a place that's often getting picked up by chatbots.”
Listen at 50:59
Super PACs have more time than campaigns to conduct political work.
“we also have time that a campaign doesn't have.”
Listen at 56:03
Priorities USA aims to use internet data to guide political decisions.
“how can we do a better job of listening to the internet to be able to drive decision-making?”
Listen at 56:30
Republicans invested nearly one billion dollars in always-on infrastructure and communication over a decade.
“the Republicans are investing close to $1 billion over the last decade in always-on infrastructure and communication.”
Listen at 1:01:40
Republican always-on infrastructure and communication has produced political benefits.
“I think it is quite obvious that it has paid off”
Listen at 1:01:48
Audiences prefer humorous, less-serious political advertising.
“People want humor. They want things— they want the poli— they want politics to be a little bit less serious.”
Listen at 1:05:43
No single metric can establish whether a political ad is effective.
“there's no singular metric that's ever gonna tell you your ad is working.”
Listen at 1:06:34
Online comment sections about J.D. Vance were often negative.
“comment sections about J.D. Vance were often, you know, quite negative”
Listen at 1:11:51
Online comments about Marco Rubio were more positive than those about J.D. Vance.
“Marco Rubio's comments were a lot more positive.”
Listen at 1:11:59
Digital strategy must be central to presidential campaign decision-making.
“digital has to be at the table.”
Listen at 1:15:47
Political campaigns should produce substantially more video.
“my singular answer to that question is more is more and more video.”
Listen at 1:16:13
Campaigns should treat the internet as a feedback environment, not merely a distribution channel.
“We need to stop thinking about it as just a distribution channel and instead think about it as a place where we can do a lot of good in listening and observing how people are responding to our content.”
Listen at 1:16:59
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.