Apr 23, 2026 · 54 min
Cowherd makes the case for Mendoza as draft day’s polished quarterback
THE HERD - Hour 1 - NFL Draft day, thoughts on Fernando Mendoza
The episode tests how teams should balance scarce elite talent, positional need, coaching fit, and quarterback uncertainty in the first round.
- 1Colin Cowherd projects a top-15 draft shaped by limited elite talent, team needs, positional value, and coaching influence.
- 2Fernando Mendoza’s size, accuracy, maturity, and athletic plays form the case for viewing him as an unusually polished quarterback prospect.
- 3The debate over Ty Simpson, Jeremiah Love, and Caleb Downs exposes the tension between drafting for need and taking the best player available.
Don't miss
Cowherd argues that Fernando Mendoza deserves a more favorable evaluation than comparisons with established NFL quarterbacks allow.
The brief
Colin Cowherd’s final top-15 mock draft treats this class as unusually thin at the top, making positional value, team needs, and coaching fit especially important.
J. Mac challenges several projections, including the Rams’ direction and Jeremiah Love’s landing spot, turning the mock into a debate over how teams should build.
Cowherd makes Fernando Mendoza the episode’s central quarterback case, emphasizing his size, ball placement, maturity, and athletic plays against elite college defenses.
The discussion widens to Detroit’s playoff outlook, Victor Wembanyama’s concussion status, and LeBron James’ enduring postseason impact at age 41.
Cowherd expects Ty Simpson to go in the first round, with Minnesota or the Rams potentially viewing him as the missing piece for a contender.
The closing draft argument pits best player against positional need, applying the choice to the Giants, Titans, Rams, and prospects including Caleb Downs.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.