
Nov 14, 2026 · 1h 11m
CTA allocations should follow the protection investors actually need
SI426: The Hard Part Isn't Buying Trend Following ft. Yoav Git
Trend following can serve very different purposes, and confusing alpha, diversification, and crisis protection can produce the wrong portfolio design.
- 1CTAs may target standalone alpha, equity-crisis protection, or hedging for bond portfolios.
- 2Exposure convexity depends on how quickly a strategy changes positions, while return convexity depends on asset behavior across regimes.
- 3Fast trend can react to sharp shocks, but slower trend may offer stronger protection through prolonged drawdowns.
Don't miss
Yoav’s distinction between fast and slow trend clarifies why quicker crisis response can come with less sustained convexity.
The brief
Yoav Git opens with the practical problem investors face: CTAs can be difficult to hold through long stretches of weak performance, even when their intended role remains intact.
The discussion separates three objectives for CTA allocations: standalone hedge-fund alpha, convexity during equity crises, and protection when bond portfolios are under pressure.
A key distinction is between return convexity and exposure convexity. Bonds may rise as equities fall, while a CTA can mechanically reduce or reverse exposure as trends change.
Asset classes contribute differently: bond trend can offer broad regime protection, commodity and FX trend add diversification, and equity trend is most useful in prolonged drawdowns but can react late.
Fast trend may respond better to one-month shocks, while slower trend can provide more sustained convexity over quarterly drawdowns because it maintains larger average positions.
The episode’s conclusion is behavioral as much as quantitative: build CTA portfolios around a defined objective, rather than chasing whichever strategy performed best recently.
What was said on this episode
56 statements · 29 positive · 13 negative · 4 mixed · 10 neutral
CTAs can experience prolonged periods without performance.
“CTAs are difficult to live with. You go down the stairs, come up the elevators, you might have three years with no performance.”
Listen at 0:01
Youth unemployment in the UK is very high.
“youth unemployment in this country is enormous.”
Listen at 3:58
Investors may use CTA baskets for standalone hedge-fund alpha.
“The first one is that you might want to think of it as like a standalone. It's a hedge fund. It's part of a hedge fund book. I just want it to have a highest standalone alpha.”
Listen at 10:31
Investors may use CTAs to provide equity crisis convexity.
“The second view is people want to say equity convexity. We want crisis alpha. We want to support the 60% allocation to equity that we want.”
Listen at 10:46
Investors may use CTAs to protect bond exposure.
“How do I protect my bond exposure? Because I've got 40% in my portfolio in bonds. How do I get bond convexity and bond crisis alpha?”
Listen at 11:04
Positive convexity can generate gains in both rising and falling markets.
“positive convexity is something nicer. It's a little bit like buying an option. It makes money both on the upside and on the downside.”
Listen at 12:07
CTAs tend to rise when equities decline.
“CTAs have the beautiful behavior that it actually tends to go up when equity goes down.”
Listen at 13:44
A 15% CTA convexity implies 75 basis points for a 5% equity drawdown.
“If it has a convexity of, say, 15%, then for 5% drawdown in equities, we expect to make an extra 75 basis points in the CTA space for that quarter.”
Listen at 13:58
CTAs reduce equity exposure by shorting equities after declines.
“When equity goes down, we will short equity.”
Listen at 16:07
CTA equity exposure can turn short after one or two months.
“But after a month or maybe a month or two, depending on the speed of the position, it will turn negative.”
Listen at 18:04
Bond-based convexity can provide immediate protection.
“the convexity we get from bonds, for example, it's immediate”
Listen at 18:26
Bond-based protection is immediate but depends on macro conditions.
“it's immediate, but it's not 100%. It really depends on the macro environment and on the nature of the crisis as it plays out.”
Listen at 19:05
CTAs generally target equal risk across asset classes.
“CTAs basically try to get equal risk in each asset class.”
Listen at 20:59
CTAs delever equities and lever bonds toward 15% volatility.
“they will actually delever their position in equity and lever up their exposure in bonds so that both asset classes internally within the CTA are running at 15%.”
Listen at 21:09
A 10% CTA allocation provides roughly 3.5% equity exposure.
“if you have a 10% CTA, you're basically getting plus-minor 3.5% exposure in equity.”
Listen at 22:07
A 10% CTA allocation provides roughly 10% bond exposure.
“if I've got a 10% exposure to a CTA, It's almost equivalent to being plus minus 10%, depending on how bonds are going.”
Listen at 22:27
Slow equity trend may provide about 60% average equity exposure.
“on average, in a positive trend in equity, if you're a slow trend over a year, say, you might get 60% exposure to equity.”
Listen at 24:12
Fast CTAs may have roughly 2% equity exposure.
“A fast CTA will only have maybe plus minus two percent exposure.”
Listen at 25:11
Bond trend generally has positive convexity across inflation regimes.
“bond trend generally have positive convexity over all inflation environments.”
Listen at 26:55
Historical equity convexity is about 35%, versus 20% for bonds.
“equity convexity is like 35%. Bond convexity is around 20%.”
Listen at 28:48
Commodity trend is likely to generate returns across crises.
“commodity trend is likely to work because it works all the time.”
Listen at 29:18
Equity trend helps during prolonged equity drawdowns.
“equity trend is very helpful in protracted long drawdowns”
Listen at 30:18
Equity trend is often too slow for sharp crises.
“When we see a sharp crisis, the equity part of the convexity actually is just too late to the party.”
Listen at 31:03
Equity convexity requires a large dedicated CTA allocation.
“if you want an equity CTA, you actually need to give it a very large allocation if you want an equity CTA in order to help with your exposure convexity.”
Listen at 32:39
Bonds can provide first-response equity convexity, but not consistently.
“if you want to think about it in terms of the cross-asset convexity, then you basically want to understand that bonds give you equity. first response uh responsive convexity but not always”
Listen at 33:42
Equity trend historically provides little bond convexity.
“equities offer very little bond convexity.”
Listen at 34:46
Historically, equity trend performed poorly while bond trend performed well.
“historically, equities has been disastrous and bond has been very good.”
Listen at 35:28
Fast equity trend is difficult, while slow trend has worked reasonably.
“fast trend is actually very difficult um slow trend has worked reasonably”
Listen at 36:32
Bond trend historically has had a higher Sharpe ratio than equity trend.
“In bonds, it's sort of sitting actually quite a bit higher historically.”
Listen at 36:49
Bond trend had a negative Sharpe over the last four years.
“in the last four years, bonds have been trading sideways and bond trend has been a disaster, like a negative one shop.”
Listen at 37:13
Debt in many developed markets is about 120% of GDP.
“debt is now sitting at 120% of GDP, 120% of GDP is there about.”
Listen at 38:45
Inflation is the most important variable affecting trend performance.
“the most important variable that affects trend performance is actually inflation.”
Listen at 39:35
Sustained yield increases can eventually make bonds provide strong convexity.
“if we see sustained rise in yields, eventually bonds will offer a great convexity.”
Listen at 40:09
Commodity trend performs especially well when inflation is high.
“commodity trend is exactly the time when commodity trend really shines.”
Listen at 41:27
Combining bonds and commodity trend can target inflation plus 4%.
“the combination of commodities and bonds actually creates almost like an inflation plus 4% portfolio.”
Listen at 41:57
Equities can return roughly 10–12% during benign conditions.
“during benign economic conditions equity seems to be able to give you not just inflation but also a great amount of growth and it goes like you know 10 12 percent”
Listen at 42:50
Bond and commodity trend can provide inflation-plus returns more consistently.
“a bond plus commodity trend give you essentially inflation plus a constant number.”
Listen at 43:24
Yoav is bullish on AI infrastructure development.
“I'm personally quite bullish on the i think what we've seen so far is infrastructure”
Listen at 44:17
AI benefits for software and low-capex adopters have not yet emerged fully.
“we haven't even started to see the benefit in the sort of the people, the software, the low capex companies, which are just consuming AI and really improving.”
Listen at 45:35
AI markets may undergo a valuation collapse before applications mature.
“we might need to go through an adjustment where we see a collapse in valuation”
Listen at 46:10
Trend-following performance appears largely unaffected by industrial production.
“trend doesn't seem to be, in my mind, trend didn't seem to be particularly affected by industrial production.”
Listen at 46:41
Higher industrial production supports commodity performance.
“industrial production is up, is very supportive of commodities”
Listen at 47:14
Yoav disputes the cited study’s data and conclusions.
“i don't think i agree with the data i'm not sure i agree with their conclusions”
Listen at 49:22
Commodity trend performs well in both stagflation and overheating.
“commodity trend does very well either in stagflation or in overheating.”
Listen at 51:27
Backfilled historical data limits conclusions from long-run regime studies.
“the amount of the conclusions that you can make are kind of reduced because although you might be thinking I'm doing 115 years of data, you don't actually have that.”
Listen at 53:37
Strong industrial production and AI adoption could boost copper and energy futures.
“if we're actually going to see good industrial production and we're going to see AI playing out, then a portfolio of copper, other industrial productions, particularly in AI, energy futures are going to do wonderfully.”
Listen at 55:25
Commodity trend could perform well even if AI fails and stagflation occurs.
“Even if the AI isn't going to play out and we're going to see stagflation, then commodity trend is going to do very well.”
Listen at 55:44
Investors seeking standalone alpha may prefer a high-alpha CTA book.
“you might want to say, just I want a high alpha CTA book.”
Listen at 56:45
Fast trend has historically struggled to generate standalone alpha.
“from an alpha perspective, it's actually not very conducive because historically they've really struggled because of that negative autocorrelation at the short term.”
Listen at 58:23
Commodity trend has distinct risk factors from broad CTA portfolios.
“The one asset class that is very distinct, because these are very distinct risk factors, is exactly commodity trend.”
Listen at 59:56
Commodity trend historically correlates 20–30% with liquid trend.
“commodity trend, if you look historically, has only maybe 20% or 30% correlation to liquid trend.”
Listen at 1:00:04
After adding commodity trend, alternative trend adds no further value historically.
“once you add commodity trend it adds no value whatsoever to add alternative trend”
Listen at 1:00:32
Commodity trend provides essentially no equity convexity.
“commodity trend doesn't really add you any equity convexity whatsoever.”
Listen at 1:01:23
Commodity trend contributes to bond convexity.
“commodity trend will add to bond convexity”
Listen at 1:01:30
Trend-following based on recent performance can harm investors.
“I think it's very destructive from an investor's perspective.”
Listen at 1:07:31
Investors should seek greater stability across multiple trend managers.
“let's try and create something which is more stable across managers.”
Listen at 1:08:09
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.