Modern Wisdom
Modern Wisdom

Nov 14, 2026 · 1h 34m

Dan and Shay turn creative doubt into a case for human-made music

“We Won 3 Grammys and Still Felt Like Failures” - Dan + Shay (Live Performance) - #1176

The duo connects Grammy-level success, grief, aging, partnership conflict, and AI anxiety to the harder question of how artists keep making honest work.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Success does not remove creative pressure; it changes the benchmark artists must continually surpass.
  2. 2Dan and Shay found renewed purpose by writing from grief, aging, family, and other experiences they are actually living.
  3. 3Repairing their partnership required apology, mutual respect, and separating personal identity from the expectations attached to the duo.

Don't miss

Dan and Shay perform “Young” acoustically, prompting Shay to explain why its portrait of aging, parenthood, and adult uncertainty moved him to tears.

The brief

Dan Smyers and Shay Mooney trace their path from cheap pizza and Nashville uncertainty to Grammy-winning success, while admitting that achievement never ends the pressure to prove themselves.

The duo explains why following a breakthrough like “Tequila” can feel harder than writing the first hit: every new song is measured against an established benchmark.

A vulnerable story about “Say So,” written after the suicide of their friend and mentor Ben Vaughn, leads to a wider argument for music’s power to reduce shame and loneliness.

Dan and Shay say their new work draws on aging, parenthood, illness, and mortality because audiences can detect the difference between lived experience and manufactured emotion.

Their partnership nearly fractured under distance and poor communication, but apology and shared goals restored it—and offered a model for surviving creative conflict.

The episode’s emotional peak is “Young,” an acoustic performance that turns aging and parenthood into a reflection on how adults are improvising through life.

What was said on this episode

18 statements · 12 positive · 3 negative · 1 mixed · 2 neutral

  1. Dan Smyerson music business volatilityPositive5:08

    Music-business volatility keeps Dan and Shay motivated.

    “I do feel like the music business though is so volatile. So I think that keeps us driven and hungry.”

    Listen at 5:08

  2. Shay Mooneyon songwriting processNeutral16:13

    Songwriters can control their process but never their results.

    “you can't control the results of something ever, but you can control the process”

    Listen at 16:13

  3. Dan Smyerson national anthemNegative30:56

    Performing the national anthem usually has little upside and substantial downside.

    “There's usually no upside. There's big downside.”

    Listen at 30:56

  4. Dan Smyerson Dan + ShayPositive43:27

    “Say So” would be a success if it helped or saved one person.

    “even if this song doesn't go crazy, if it dies at 70 on the radio charts, if it just doesn't take off, if it helps one person, if it saves one life, it was a win.”

    Listen at 43:27

  5. Dan Smyerson human communityPositive46:42

    Humans will continue valuing community despite technological advancement.

    “no matter what happens with the advancement of technology, we're always, humans are always going to value.”

    Listen at 46:42

  6. Shay Mooneyon human craftsmanshipPositive48:19

    Human craftsmanship should be treasured despite AI advances.

    “craftsmanship, like woodworking, like all of these things like need to be treasured for the precious things that they are.”

    Listen at 48:19

  7. Shay Mooneyon sad musicPositive54:57

    Sad music can help listeners process pain and heal.

    “music is a way of doing that, of just like, whatever this pain is, I feel it when I listen to this sad song and it somehow kind of helps you heal in a lot of ways.”

    Listen at 54:57

  8. Dan Smyerson musical duosNegative1:10:31

    Musical duos break up more often than larger bands, according to Dan’s impression.

    “duos break up more than any band just because I think in a trio, there's always a tiebreaker”

    Listen at 1:10:31

  9. Shay Mooneyon partnership conflict resolutionPositive1:16:27

    Mutual love and respect can enable partners to overcome any conflict.

    “if you can do that, like you can literally get through anything.”

    Listen at 1:16:27

  10. Shay Mooneyon Dan + ShayPositive1:16:39

    A shared goal is sufficient to sustain Dan and Shay’s partnership.

    “as long as we have a common goal, as long as he wants, you know, Dan and Shay to be a successful band, like that's kind of all you need.”

    Listen at 1:16:39

  11. Shay Mooneyon creative partnershipPositive1:21:05

    A good partner challenges you and brings out your best qualities.

    “If you can find someone who challenges you and makes you better. like brings out the best parts of you, that is such a win.”

    Listen at 1:21:05

  12. Shay Mooneyon Social mediaNegative1:23:50

    Social media is toxic but necessary for Dan and Shay.

    “I think it's so toxic. And so it's a necessary evil for us, but it's crazy.”

    Listen at 1:23:50

  13. Shay Mooneyon Dan + ShayMixed1:26:56

    Dan and Shay are most successful when their music provokes some offense.

    “we're at our biggest when people are a little bit offended that we exist.”

    Listen at 1:26:56

  14. Dan Smyerson successful artistsNeutral1:27:04

    The biggest artists in history tend to be polarizing.

    “the biggest artists in history are that. You know what I'm saying? They're a bit polarizing.”

    Listen at 1:27:04

  15. Chris Williamsonon tolerance of criticismPositive1:28:09

    Tolerating criticism can greatly increase attention received.

    “If your desire for attention is the same as somebody else's, but you are able to put up with criticism, you can basically 10X the amount of attention that you get.”

    Listen at 1:28:09

  16. Chris Williamsonon presidential debates on independent mediaPositive1:31:40

    A presidential debate may occur on independent media within two years.

    “it wouldn't surprise me if in two years' time we see one of the presidential debates happen on some form of independent media.”

    Listen at 1:31:40

  17. Dan Smyerson Trump campaignPositive1:31:47

    Podcasts substantially drove Trump’s campaign.

    “Trump's campaign, so much of it I think was driven by the pods.”

    Listen at 1:31:47

  18. Dan Smyerson PodcastsPositive1:33:02

    Podcasts are a major driver of political influence.

    “it's such a huge driver.”

    Listen at 1:33:02

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.