The NPR Politics Podcast
The NPR Politics Podcast

Oct 26, 2026 · 20 min

DOJ election cases test federal power and political independence

The DOJ wades into elections with unprecedented cases

The lawsuits could expand federal influence over election administration while testing whether the Justice Department is serving legal principles or the president’s political agenda.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1The DOJ’s California demands rely on an uncertain list of roughly 20,000 names and limited evidence of noncitizen voting.
  2. 2The Alaska lawsuit could delay certification over two candidates sharing the name Dan Sullivan, raising questions about federal authority and voter confusion.
  3. 3The episode contrasts the current DOJ’s White House alignment with the department’s traditional independence and earlier resistance to election-fraud claims.

Don't miss

The hosts examine how a lawsuit over two candidates named Dan Sullivan could delay Alaska’s certification and reflect presidential political pressure.

The brief

The Justice Department is intervening directly in election administration through cases in California and Alaska, prompting questions about federal power ahead of the midterms.

Miles Parks and Ryan Lucas examine the California demand to investigate roughly 20,000 voter-roll names, finding uncertainty around citizenship status and limited evidence behind broader claims.

The Alaska case targets a ballot with two candidates named Dan Sullivan and could delay certification if the Republican incumbent narrowly loses; Donald Trump ordered the suit.

The hosts compare the current Justice Department’s relationship with the White House to its traditional independence, including William Barr’s response to Trump’s 2020 fraud claims.

They assess sharply criticized legal theories and uneasy local reactions to federal election observers, arguing that the cases may advance a political agenda as much as a legal one.

What was said on this episode

13 statements · 1 positive · 8 negative · 4 neutral

  1. Ryan Lucason DOJ non-citizen voting prosecutionsNegative3:28

    The 113 non-citizen voting cases will not sway the election.

    “113 cases is not going to sway the election one way or the other.”

    Listen at 3:28

  2. Ryan Lucason DOJ non-citizen voting casesNeutral3:58
    “56, at least 56 people are lawful permanent residents”

    Listen at 3:58

  3. Ryan Lucason DOJ non-citizen voting casesNeutral4:05

    Only four of 64 reviewed defendants were unlawfully present.

    “only four are here illegally of the 64 that I looked at”

    Listen at 4:05

  4. Ryan Lucason Federal alien-voting statuteNegative4:22

    A Florida federal judge found the federal alien-voting statute unconstitutional.

    “a federal judge in Florida this month found that statute to be unconstitutional”

    Listen at 4:22

  5. Miles Parkson Illegal non-citizen votingNeutral4:59

    Illegal non-citizen voting generally occurs accidentally.

    “when non-citizens do vote illegally, it's generally by accident”

    Listen at 4:59

  6. Miles Parkson U.S. Department of Justice election interventionNegative8:12

    The current DOJ is seeking an unprecedented role in election administration.

    “the DOJ has never intervened in elections in modern history in the way that this DOJ is seeking to”

    Listen at 8:12

  7. Miles Parkson U.S. Constitution election administrationNeutral8:25

    The Constitution assigns election administration to the states.

    “the Constitution very clearly says that states run elections”

    Listen at 8:25

  8. Miles Parkson Non-citizen votingNegative9:46

    Non-citizen voting has not been found to be a major election issue.

    “non-citizen voting has never been found to be a major issue in elections”

    Listen at 9:46

  9. Miles Parkson Federal non-citizen voting investigationsNegative9:50

    Federal efforts to remove non-citizen voters have ensnared U.S. citizens.

    “The other efforts led by this federal government to try to root out non-citizen voting have already been found to entangle U.S. citizens.”

    Listen at 9:50

  10. Miles Parkson Non-citizen voting accusationsNegative12:57

    The president’s and Mark Wayne Mullen’s non-citizen voting accusations lacked good faith.

    “the accusations from the president, from DHS Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen, do not seem to have been in good faith this summer”

    Listen at 12:57

  11. Miles Parkson Pre-election voter-roll cleanupNegative14:05

    Cleaning voter rolls two weeks before an election using uncertain data is inappropriate.

    “is it the right time two weeks before an election to be trying to decide that you're going to be like? Cleaning up your voter rolls based on data that you're not sure is accurate”

    Listen at 14:05

  12. Miles Parkson DOJ election monitorsPositive19:28

    Most DOJ election-monitoring deployments probably will not cause issues.

    “that probably will not present issues in most of those places”

    Listen at 19:28

  13. Miles Parkson DOJ election monitorsNegative19:33

    Isolated problems could occur during DOJ election monitoring.

    “Could there be isolated incidents like the one we've already seen in Wyoming? That's kind of an open question.”

    Listen at 19:33

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.