Oct 29, 2026 · 1h 28m
DWTS judges clash over scores as Horror Night peaks
Danielle with… Kym Johnson Herjavec (Ballroom Breakdown DWTS 3508)
The recap tests whether judging should reward weekly performance honestly or follow a steadily rising season-long curve.
- 1Harry and Jenna’s contemporary, Connor and Riley’s Annabelle routine, and Jenna and Val’s tango set the night’s highest standard.
- 2The hosts question Shirley Ballas’s unusually harsh scoring while defending score changes that reflect each week’s actual performance.
- 3Tyler Cameron and Jackson Olsen exit after a double elimination, leaving the finale field and its scoring pressure unresolved.
Don't miss
Connor Wood and Riley Arnold’s Annabelle contemporary earns the hosts’ designation as the night’s favorite, combining cinematic storytelling with seamless lifts.
The brief
Danielle Fishel and Kym Herjavec open Ballroom Breakdown by assessing Horror Night’s elaborate production and Shirley Ballas’s demanding guest-judge approach.
Harry and Jenna’s contemporary earns the hosts’ strongest praise for its choreography, acting, storytelling, and horror imagery, while Connor and Riley’s Annabelle routine becomes their favorite dance.
Jenna and Val’s Argentine tango also stands out, with Jenna recovering from a back condition and a costume mishap without losing footwork or emotional intensity.
Across the remaining routines, the hosts balance ambitious concepts against technical flaws, including awkward lifts, weak frame, injuries, and uneven confidence.
The central dispute is scoring consistency: Danielle and Kym argue marks should rise or fall with the performance, then accept Tyler Cameron and Jackson Olsen’s double elimination.
Books & mentions
Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.