Pod Save America
Pod Save America

Aug 6, 2026 · 1h 15m

El-Sayed’s Michigan win tests Democrats’ coalition strategy

Bonus: Abdul El-Sayed Wins in Michigan feat. Bernie Sanders

The primary exposes Democrats’ tensions over outside money, working-class voters, progressive policy, and the path to defeating Mike Rogers.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Abdul El-Sayed’s narrow Michigan victory revealed polling failures, regional divides, and the importance of Muslim and young voters.
  2. 2The hosts debate whether Democrats can unite behind El-Sayed while defining Mike Rogers beyond familiar MAGA attacks.
  3. 3Bernie Sanders argues that grassroots organizing, economic justice, and serious preparation for artificial intelligence should shape Democratic politics.

Don't miss

Bernie Sanders connects El-Sayed’s grassroots victory to the need for Democrats to organize working-class and diverse voters while preparing for AI’s disruptions.

The brief

Abdul El-Sayed’s narrow Michigan Democratic Senate primary victory over Haley Stevens exposed polling misses, regional divides, turnout differences, and the importance of Muslim voters.

Jon Favreau and Dan Pfeiffer weigh AIPAC and establishment spending against local concerns, then ask whether El-Sayed can unite Democrats for a general election against Mike Rogers.

The hosts examine El-Sayed’s coalition: strong support among young and college-educated voters, but weaker performance with rural and working-class voters, raising questions about progressive strategy.

Bernie Sanders calls the result an extraordinary grassroots victory and argues that Democrats must reach working-class, African American, and women voters through organizing and economic justice.

Sanders closes with a warning about artificial intelligence, including job displacement, misinformation, deepfakes, and children’s dependence on screens, framing AI as a democratic political challenge.

What was said on this episode

62 statements · 25 positive · 26 negative · 4 mixed · 7 neutral

  1. Jon Favreauon Abdul El-Sayed’s Michigan Senate primary victoryPositive3:15

    Abdul El-Sayed won Michigan’s Democratic Senate primary by one point.

    “Abdul El-Sayed is now the Democratic nominee for the US Senate race in Michigan with more than 95% of the vote in. He defeated Haley Stevens by 1 point. 48.5% to 47.5%”

    Listen at 3:15

  2. Jon Favreauon Abdul El-Sayed’s Michigan Senate primary campaignPositive3:55

    Abdul El-Sayed won despite being outspent eleven to one by outside spending.

    “was outspent 11 to 1 by $60 million in outside spending, including a $32 million AIPAC spend. That's more than any group has spent in any Democratic primary this cycle. And Abdul still won.”

    Listen at 3:55

  3. Dan Pfeifferon Michigan Senate primary pollingNegative6:25

    Polls likely overstated Abdul’s margin by oversampling highly engaged college-educated voters.

    “Best guess is people oversampled highly engaged college-educated voters who overwhelmingly voted for Abdul, hence the margin.”

    Listen at 6:25

  4. Dan Pfeifferon Abdul El-Sayed’s primary coalitionMixed7:54

    Abdul’s primary coalition was young and college-educated voters, while he struggled elsewhere.

    “Abdul had the typical coalition of a very progressive candidate in Michigan and nationally, which is a lot of young voters and a lot of college-educated voters, and struggled with the rest of the coalition.”

    Listen at 7:54

  5. Dan Pfeifferon Muslim voters in DearbornPositive9:19

    Muslim voters, especially in Dearborn, were important to Abdul’s victory.

    “you can't understate the importance of the Muslim population, particularly in Dearborn, which Abdul won essentially 80-20.”

    Listen at 9:19

  6. Haley Stevens won her own district by only four points.

    “Haley Stevens only won her own district by 4 points.”

    Listen at 9:35

  7. Association with AIPAC harmed Haley Stevens politically.

    “being associated with AIPAC, being the AIPAC candidate was bad for Haley Stevens.”

    Listen at 10:41

  8. Dan Pfeifferon AIPACNegative10:47

    AIPAC had 37% negative favorability among Michigan Democrats.

    “AIPAC has a negative 37% favorability rating among Democrats in Michigan.”

    Listen at 10:47

  9. Haley Stevens should have adopted a more nuanced, conditional position on aid to Israel.

    “her best move would've been to completely flip-flop or at least have a more nuanced position to put her on aid to Israel with conditions perhaps that put her more in the mainstream of the current Democratic Party.”

    Listen at 12:15

  10. Dan Pfeifferon AIPACNegative14:24

    Candidates in 2028 will likely avoid soliciting or accepting AIPAC support.

    “I think you generally— I cannot see based on these results a 2028 candidate soliciting, accepting, or courting AIPAC to either endorse them or run ads on their behalf.”

    Listen at 14:24

  11. Dan Pfeifferon AIPACNegative14:26

    Candidates in 2028 will likely avoid soliciting or accepting AIPAC support.

    “I cannot see based on these results a 2028 candidate soliciting, accepting, or courting AIPAC to either endorse them or run ads on their behalf.”

    Listen at 14:26

  12. Dan Pfeifferon AIPACNegative14:55

    AIPAC support will hurt candidates politically.

    “it'll hurt you.”

    Listen at 14:55

  13. Dan Pfeifferon Democratic establishment support for Abdul El-SayedPositive18:13

    Democratic political establishments appear likely to unite behind Abdul.

    “It does not appear like it's going to be a challenge to unite the political establishment nationally and in Michigan.”

    Listen at 18:13

  14. Reuniting voters exposed to anti-Abdul advertising is the general-election challenge.

    “can you get the voters who just heard sixty million dollars of arguments against Abdul to come and support him? And that's that. That is the general challenge in the general election.”

    Listen at 19:34

  15. Dan Pfeifferon Republican Senate Committee ad against Abdul El-SayedPositive21:08

    The Republican ad attacking El-Sayed is strategically effective.

    “I think this ad is better than a lot of people online think, and I think the combining of it actually makes sense.”

    Listen at 21:08

  16. Dan Pfeifferon Republican attacks on Abdul El-SayedPositive21:23

    Portraying El-Sayed as radical can make tax-increase attacks credible.

    “You have to prove that they are so radical that they'd be willing to do that.”

    Listen at 21:23

  17. Dan Pfeifferon Republican attacks on Abdul El-SayedNegative21:59

    Republican attacks must convince voters Abdul will not reduce their costs.

    “You have to make them believe that he will not lower your costs.”

    Listen at 21:59

  18. Dan Pfeifferon Mike RogersNegative25:05

    Voting for Mike Rogers would help Donald Trump control the Senate.

    “A vote for Mike Rogers is a vote for Donald Trump and Donald Trump to control the Senate.”

    Listen at 25:05

  19. Jon Favreauon Mike RogersNegative25:54

    Abdul must persuade voters that Mike Rogers has changed politically.

    “I think Abdul has to make people realize before he just says that Mike Rogers is going to be a vote for Donald Trump, that Mike Rogers has changed.”

    Listen at 25:54

  20. Jon Favreauon Mike RogersNeutral26:31

    El-Sayed must persuade voters that Mike Rogers has changed politically.

    “you've got to do some work on their character to persuade people that something has changed about them”

    Listen at 26:31

  21. Mike Rogers is not viewed by voters as a typical MAGA extremist.

    “this is a very hard race because Mike Rogers is not a MAGA buffoon in the eyes of the voters.”

    Listen at 26:55

  22. Abdul’s primary coalition is unfavorable for the general election.

    “when you look at the coalition that he won with, it is a coalition that does not bode great for the general election.”

    Listen at 32:12

  23. Abdul performed poorly among working-class and Black voters.

    “he underperformed with working-class voters, and he really got his clock cleaned with Black voters.”

    Listen at 32:25

  24. Abdul performed very poorly among Black voters in the primary.

    “he really got his clock cleaned with Black voters.”

    Listen at 32:27

  25. Dan Pfeifferon 2024 general-election electorateNeutral33:05

    More than 60% of general-election voters were non-college educated in 2024.

    “In a general election, if you look at 2024 exit poll data, it's more than 60% non-college educated.”

    Listen at 33:05

  26. Voters Abdul struggled with comprise a larger share of the general electorate.

    “all the voters that Abdul struggled most with are disproportionately a larger portion of the electorate in 2020, in the, in the general election.”

    Listen at 33:20

  27. Dan Pfeifferon Progressive Democratic candidatesNegative34:21

    Progressive candidates with Abdul’s profile historically perform poorly with Black voters.

    “historically, candidates with Abdul's profile of this progressive candidate do poorly with Black voters.”

    Listen at 34:21

  28. Abdul should broaden his appeal beyond his primary base.

    “he needs to think really hard about how to make himself more broadly appealing.”

    Listen at 34:44

  29. Dan Pfeifferon Abdul El-Sayed’s support among Jewish DemocratsNegative35:28

    Abdul needs to improve support among Jewish Democrats in Michigan.

    “There's real work to do with Jewish Democrats in Michigan.”

    Listen at 35:28

  30. Jon Favreauon Working-class voters’ Democratic supportNegative38:56

    Working-class voters have moved away from Democrats partly because of cultural concerns.

    “There are cultural social concerns that the working class have, which is why they have moved away from the Democratic Party”

    Listen at 38:56

  31. Dan Pfeifferon Race and Muslim identity in electionsNegative41:38

    Obama’s race and Abdul’s Muslim identity affect their electoral challenges.

    “the fact that Obama was a Black man and Abdul is a Muslim American certainly plays a role.”

    Listen at 41:38

  32. Dan Pfeifferon Independent voters’ views on aid to IsraelPositive42:45

    Independent voters generally agree with Abdul on aid to Israel.

    “independent voters in Michigan and nationally agree with Abdul on aid to Israel.”

    Listen at 42:45

  33. Dan Pfeifferon Aid to IsraelNeutral42:56

    Aid to Israel becomes less salient among economically downscale general-election voters.

    “the salience of the issue goes down.”

    Listen at 42:56

  34. Israel-related messaging can make affordability-focused voters think Abdul has misplaced priorities.

    “these voters who agree with Abdul but care much more, but affordability is a much higher topic for them, can believe that in his mind, priority-wise, that aid to Israel on that basket of issues is higher on his list than affordability. And that hurts you with voters.”

    Listen at 43:17

  35. Dan Pfeifferon Unconditional foreign aidPositive45:12

    Opposing unconditional foreign aid is wise and likely popular.

    “Which is a very good and wise, and I imagine quite popular position.”

    Listen at 45:12

  36. Dan Pfeifferon Progressive anti-establishment Democratic candidatesPositive46:20

    Progressive anti-establishment candidates continue winning many Democratic primaries.

    “this continues a trend we've seen with, with a handful of exceptions here and there of progressive anti-establishment candidates winning in races.”

    Listen at 46:20

  37. Dan Pfeifferon Progressive anti-establishment Democratic candidatesPositive47:29

    Progressive anti-establishment candidates have a primary advantage in favorable conditions.

    “in races with the right candidates in the right situations, progressive anti-establishment candidates have the advantage in the primary against the more traditional candidates you would expect to win.”

    Listen at 47:29

  38. Jon Favreauon Moderate Democratic primary strategyPositive48:00

    Moderate Democrats should consolidate behind one candidate against DSA candidates.

    “if you don't want a DSA candidate to win, like, figure out one candidate to take on that person.”

    Listen at 48:00

  39. Democrats are expected to win Michigan’s 7th District, with Brink or Masden favored.

    “Democrats should win it this time around. Most of the people whose job it is to try to win the House believe pretty strongly that either Bridget Brink or Matt Masden would be favorites in that race.”

    Listen at 48:19

  40. Dan Pfeifferon Democratic Party establishment credibilityNegative49:23

    Democratic leaders lack credibility to direct primary voters.

    “there aren't a lot of people in the Democratic Party with the authority and the experience and the trust to tell Democratic primary voters how to think”

    Listen at 49:23

  41. Dan Pfeifferon Moderate Democratic candidatesPositive51:46

    Moderates should nominate candidates who do not appear controlled by the establishment.

    “the way for moderates to win is to find candidates who do not appear to be just like establishment toadies”

    Listen at 51:46

  42. Sanders characterizes El-Sayed’s victory as unprecedented despite nine-to-one spending disadvantage.

    “Have you ever heard of a candidate in a major race getting outspent 9 to 1, taking on the entire establishment and winning?”

    Listen at 55:13

  43. Bernie Sanders thinks Will Lawrence has a good chance to win in November.

    “I think he stands a good chance to win in November as well.”

    Listen at 55:50

  44. Sanders suggests El-Sayed might have won by 10–20 points without spending disparity.

    “if it was a fair fight financially, and there was no spending difference, how many points would he have won? By 10, 20 points? Maybe, I don't know.”

    Listen at 56:26

  45. Sanders predicts Abdul’s economic-justice message will resonate across Michigan’s electorate.

    “I think it's going to resonate all over Michigan, whether you're Democrat, Republican, or independent.”

    Listen at 58:48

  46. Abdul’s campaign will need extensive grassroots door-knocking.

    “And I think in Abdul's case in Michigan, we're going to have to have thousands and thousands of people knocking on doors”

    Listen at 59:44

  47. Abdul’s campaign will need thousands of volunteers canvassing voters.

    “I think in Abdul's case in Michigan, we're going to have to have thousands and thousands of people knocking on doors”

    Listen at 59:45

  48. Abdul’s campaign needs more support among African American voters and women.

    “we still have more work to, uh, be done within the African American community, uh, maybe the women's community”

    Listen at 1:00:24

  49. Medicare for All is likely Sanders’s main endorsement litmus test.

    “if there's one litmus test, probably Medicare for All would be it.”

    Listen at 1:01:58

  50. Bernie Sanderson Progressive Democratic candidatesNeutral1:04:16

    Sanders says no serious candidate he knows supports defunding the police.

    “No serious person that I know who is running for office believes in quote-unquote defunding the police.”

    Listen at 1:04:16

  51. Bernie Sanderson Police departmentsPositive1:04:26

    Police reform and eliminating racism within police departments are necessary.

    “Do we need police reform? Do we need to get rid of racism within police departments? Absolutely.”

    Listen at 1:04:26

  52. Bernie Sanderson Comprehensive immigration reformPositive1:05:02

    Sanders rejects open borders and supports comprehensive immigration reform.

    “Open borders? No. We all, most of us believe in comprehensive immigration reform, not opening up all the borders.”

    Listen at 1:05:02

  53. Democrats should pass Medicare for All even if Trump vetoes it.

    “In the first 2, 3, 4 months, you're gonna pass Medicare for All, and if Mr. Trump wants to veto it, let him.”

    Listen at 1:08:14

  54. Bernie Sanderson Prescription-drug pricesPositive1:08:27

    Democrats should lower prescription-drug prices to international levels.

    “We're going to lower prescription drug costs to the price that other countries around the world are paying.”

    Listen at 1:08:27

  55. Bernie Sanderson Minimum wage and billionaire taxesPositive1:08:33

    Democrats should raise the minimum wage and taxes on billionaires.

    “We're going to raise the minimum wage. We're going to raise taxes on billionaires.”

    Listen at 1:08:33

  56. Sanders considers artificial intelligence a major personal concern.

    “of all of the issues out there This one, you know how, you know, why you can't sleep at night. This is one of them.”

    Listen at 1:09:15

  57. Artificial intelligence may be humanity’s most transformational technology.

    “You're looking what I think we can agree on as the most transformational technology in the history of humanity”

    Listen at 1:09:36

  58. Sanders considers AI the most transformative technology in human history.

    “the most transformational technology in the history of humanity”

    Listen at 1:09:39

  59. Bernie Sanderson Artificial intelligence and employmentNegative1:09:51

    AI may eliminate millions of jobs, though Sanders cannot quantify the loss.

    “How many millions of jobs will be lost? I don't know.”

    Listen at 1:09:51

  60. Recent instances suggest AI has escaped human control.

    “Recently, we've seen instances of AI escaping human control.”

    Listen at 1:11:31

  61. More capable AI could pose an existential threat to humanity.

    “as AI becomes smarter than human beings, we could face an existential threat.”

    Listen at 1:11:40

  62. AI development should be slowed down.

    “we need to slow it down. That's the first thing we need to do.”

    Listen at 1:11:48

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.