
Aug 20, 2026 · 16 min
Falling crime rates complicate Trump’s political advantage
Crime in the U.S. is down. Why?
The episode explains why a genuine national decline in violent crime may still be shaped politically by local fears, selective claims, and campaign messaging.
- 1Murder has reached its lowest level in two decades after a sharp spike between 2020 and 2022.
- 2National crime trends reflect local conditions, making it difficult to credit any single presidential policy.
- 3Crime remains a potent campaign issue because visceral safety concerns can outweigh broader statistical evidence.
Don't miss
The hosts explain why crime can remain a powerful Republican campaign issue even as national rates fall and broader approval is weak.
The brief
The episode opens with Donald Trump claiming credit for falling violent-crime and murder rates, then examines the FBI’s 2025 statistics behind the broader trend.
Ryan Lucas places the numbers in a 20-year context: murder is at its lowest level in two decades after a spike around 2020–2022, but local factors complicate presidential credit.
The hosts argue that voters’ perceptions can matter more than national comparisons, especially when emotionally powerful crime stories shape judgments about safety and leadership.
Tamara Keith turns to the 2026 midterms, where crime ads are already central to the North Carolina Senate race involving Roy Cooper.
The closing tension is whether falling crime will blunt Republicans’ strongest wedge issue as Democrats move away from defund-the-police rhetoric and seek a credible safety message.
What was said on this episode
10 statements · 5 positive · 2 negative · 3 neutral
The crime decline in 2025 continued a trend that began around 2023.
“the numbers that we're seeing drop last year is a continuation of a trend that we've seen since about 2023.”
Listen at 2:47
Local factors largely drive crime levels.
“crime is largely driven by local factors.”
Listen at 5:50
Murder and violent-crime rates dropped in Washington, D.C., and Memphis.
“Did the murder rate and the violent crime rate drop in those two cities? Yes.”
Listen at 6:55
Trump’s crime approval rating is in the 40s.
“when it comes to crime, his approval rating is in the 40s”
Listen at 8:01
“The crime rates were still way below the crime rates of the 1990s.”
Listen at 8:49
Crime and safety messages affect everyone more viscerally than agricultural or drug-price policy ads.
“everybody is affected by basic security questions in a way that they don't think about kind of dry agricultural policy or drug prices or something like that.”
Listen at 11:12
Working-class voters rank personal safety alongside economic issues.
“working class voters rank economic issues very high, like everyone does. But they also rank personal safety.”
Listen at 12:50
Local crime coverage can make safety feel worse despite favorable crime statistics.
“even if the numbers are great, it may not feel that way based on what you're seeing, what is leading the news.”
Listen at 14:10
Most Democrats no longer want association with defund-the-police messaging.
“The defund the police messaging. It turns out it is not a message that most Democrats want to have any association with anymore.”
Listen at 14:41
Democratic messaging will focus primarily on the economy for years.
“most messaging that we are going to hear from Democrats for the next several months and several years is economy, economy, economy.”
Listen at 15:21
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.