The Pat McAfee Show
The Pat McAfee Show

Sep 2, 2026 · 2h 24m

Football returns with analytics, eligibility fights and playoff picks

PMS 2.0 1616 - DK GameDay Wednesday with Peter Schrager, Malika Andrews, and Ryan Paganetti

The episode frames football’s return around unresolved roster rules, evolving strategy and the difficulty of forecasting an expanded postseason.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1College football enters the season amid uncertainty over five-for-five eligibility and the consequences for athletes and the NCAA.
  2. 2Ryan Paganetti argues that analytics work best alongside coaching judgment, especially on fourth downs, sacks and defensive structure.
  3. 3The panel’s football forecasts span Ohio State, the NFC North, Seattle and a projected College Football Playoff field.

Don't miss

Ryan Paganetti argues that quarterback decisions and processing often deserve more blame for sacks than offensive-line play.

The brief

Football’s return arrives with more than predictions: the panel weighs DraftKings promotions, Stan Kroenke’s sports empire and a legal fight over college eligibility.

Peter Schrager discusses his new ESPN daily show, Big Day with Peter Schrager, then surveys the NFL, backing Seattle as a dangerous NFC team while resisting Rams hype.

Malika Andrews shifts the conversation to the U.S. Open and NBA pairings, highlighting Coco Gauff, Ben Shelton, Carlos Alcaraz and LeBron James joining Philadelphia.

Ryan Paganetti makes the episode’s sharpest strategic case: analytics should inform football decisions, but coaching context and feel remain essential to fourth downs and game management.

Paganetti also challenges automatic offensive-line blame for sacks, pointing to quarterback processing and pocket awareness as major parts of pressure prevention.

The show closes by debating a projected college playoff bracket, with Ohio State, Georgia, Notre Dame, Penn State, Miami and Indiana among the contested names.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.