Pod Save America
Pod Save America

Nov 22, 2026 · 1h 7m

Former Trump voters give Democrats a blueprint for 2028

Trump Voters Explain Why They Like Democrats Now

The episode tests whether Democratic gains among disaffected Republicans can become a durable coalition built around affordability, decency, and local trust.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Former Trump voters cite economic pain, broken promises, corruption, and cruelty as reasons to support Democratic candidates.
  2. 2Authentic, locally rooted candidates who listen directly to voters can overcome partisan distrust and Republican attacks.
  3. 3Democrats must pair visible action on costs and healthcare with clear communication before 2028.

Don't miss

David Plouffe argues that Democrats should begin with an expansive 2028 map, including Texas and Iowa, while protecting the blue-wall states.

The brief

Former Trump voters in Texas and Iowa describe a break with Donald Trump driven by economic frustration, broken promises, corruption, family separation, and a rejection of cruelty.

Pollsters David Binder and Will Gudelunas say candidates such as James Talarico, Gina Hinojosa, Rob Sand, and Josh Turek benefited by seeming sincere, locally rooted, independent, and willing to listen.

Republican attack ads often backfired, while voters responded to candidates who offered a less hostile political tone and emphasized healthcare, education, housing, and lower prices.

David Plouffe sees a broader map for Democrats in 2028, but argues that the party must enter hostile settings, communicate relentlessly, and make its economic agenda visible.

The central tension is whether Democrats can turn a wave of anti-Trump sentiment into lasting support by delivering practical results without losing authenticity.

What was said on this episode

43 statements · 29 positive · 9 negative · 5 neutral

  1. David Binderon Post-election focus groupsPositive3:00

    Post-election focus groups provide immediate guidance about voters’ future expectations.

    “you can get immediate guidance on what voters are thinking, looking forward”

    Listen at 3:00

  2. Will Gudelunason Former Trump votersPositive4:17

    Former Trump voters reported genuine enthusiasm rather than lesser-of-two-evils voting.

    “we heard that it was a little bit different, that, you know, we have quotes here. We're going to read that, you know, from voters who are saying this is the first time that I could remember that I didn't have to vote for the lesser of two evils”

    Listen at 4:17

  3. Will Gudelunason Former Trump votersPositive4:17

    Former Trump voters expressed enthusiasm rather than merely choosing the lesser evil.

    “we heard that it was a little bit different”

    Listen at 4:17

  4. Will Gudelunason Donald TrumpNegative7:08

    Former Trump voters felt Trump had abandoned them economically and personally.

    “Trump has totally left them behind”

    Listen at 7:08

  5. Will Gudelunason Republican candidatesNegative10:28

    Swing voters viewed Republican candidates as inseparable from Trump.

    “there was no separation between the Republican candidates and Trump”

    Listen at 10:28

  6. Will Gudelunason Democratic candidates’ voter-first messagePositive11:06

    Democratic candidates’ voter-first message resonated with swing voters.

    “these Democrats were saying some things out there on the campaign trail saying that, you know, I am going to put you ahead of my party. And that did break through.”

    Listen at 11:06

  7. Will Gudelunason Democratic candidatesPositive11:12

    Democratic candidates’ promises to prioritize voters over party leaders resonated with swing voters.

    “I am going to put you ahead of my party. And that did break through.”

    Listen at 11:12

  8. David Binderon Rob Sand’s campaign travelPositive15:39

    Rob Sand reportedly visited every Iowa county at least twice.

    “I heard that Rob Sand visited each one of the Iowa counties twice, at least, and there were 99 counties.”

    Listen at 15:39

  9. Will Gudelunason James Tallarico and Gina Hinojosa campaign synergyPositive19:19

    Tallarico’s campaign increased swing-voter interest in Hinojosa.

    “the synergy between him and Hossa that really brought some of these swing voters to say, well, now I want to check her out too”

    Listen at 19:19

  10. David Binderon James Tallarico and Gina HinojosaPositive20:32

    Tallarico and Hinojosa represented the newer qualities voters wanted.

    “they reflect kind of new energy, youthfulness, new ideas”

    Listen at 20:32

  11. Will Gudelunason Republican attack adsNegative21:34

    Republican attack ads prompted voters to investigate Democratic candidates further.

    “that caused them to even look further into Tallarico and the other Democratic candidates”

    Listen at 21:34

  12. David Binderon Republican attack adsNegative22:30

    Voters interpreted Republican attack ads as evidence Republicans lacked positive offerings.

    “The voters in our focus group said, That just told me that they had nothing positive to say about themselves.”

    Listen at 22:30

  13. David Binderon James Tallarico’s faith messagePositive24:53

    Tallarico’s compassionate religious message resonated with voters.

    “Hearing Tallarico talk about faith in a way that is about helping thy neighbor, providing empathy and compassion for your fellow human being. you know, seem to strike a chord with these people”

    Listen at 24:53

  14. David Binderon Democratic congressional legislationPositive28:19

    Voters want Democrats to pass legislation improving their families’ economic circumstances.

    “Democrats need to go to Congress and pass legislation, put it on Trump's desk. That is going to help me and my family economically.”

    Listen at 28:19

  15. Will Gudelunason Democratic congressional billsPositive29:40

    Voters favor clear, simple Democratic bills addressing their concerns.

    “if the Democrats could go there and just get some bills moving. that aren't larded up with 200 pages of stuff and that are just very clear and simple that voters could understand”

    Listen at 29:40

  16. David Binderon Democratic ethics measuresPositive30:31

    Voters support Democratic ethics measures even while opposing impeachment-focused agendas.

    “Ethics is not.”

    Listen at 30:31

  17. Will Gudelunason Former Trump voters’ 2028 supportPositive31:26

    Most surveyed former Trump voters currently lean toward supporting Democrats in 2028.

    “most of the voters that we talked to said that they would lean that way based on what they heard in this election”

    Listen at 31:26

  18. David Binderon Republican presidential candidatesNegative33:52

    Republican presidential candidates lacking independence from Trump will struggle in 2028.

    “if they don't show any degree of independence at all from the president, I think they're going to have a hard time in 2028.”

    Listen at 33:52

  19. David Binderon Ron DeSantisNeutral34:49

    Ron DeSantis would need to distinguish himself from Trump on at least one issue.

    “even someone like him would have to indicate where he differs from the president, at least on one issue.”

    Listen at 34:49

  20. David Binderon Alexandria Ocasio-CortezNeutral35:31

    AOC retains name recognition among these former Trump voters.

    “AOC is still someone who is out there”

    Listen at 35:31

  21. David Plouffeon Potential Democratic votersPositive40:19

    A large national majority is currently open to voting for Democrats.

    “there's a large majority of the country, including in some states we're surprised by, who are open to voting for Democrats”

    Listen at 40:19

  22. David Plouffeon Democratic coalitionPositive41:55

    Democrats may retain and expand support among former Trump voters.

    “we have maybe a bigger opportunity than I would have thought to retain some of these voters and grow”

    Listen at 41:55

  23. David Plouffeon Republican attacks on James TallaricoPositive43:26

    Republican attacks strengthened former Trump voters’ support for Tallarico.

    “the Tala Frico attack actually hardened their support for Tala Rico”

    Listen at 43:26

  24. David Plouffeon Political candidatesNegative44:08

    Voters prefer new candidates over politicians perceived as overstaying their welcome.

    “voters want new and they want different and they don't want people who overstay their welcome.”

    Listen at 44:08

  25. David Plouffeon Democratic 2028 electoral mapPositive44:45

    Democrats should begin 2028 with a broader electoral map than in recent cycles.

    “yes, I think you would start with a much more expansive view than we've had really since 2012 or maybe even 08.”

    Listen at 44:45

  26. David Plouffeon Democratic 2028 electoral mapPositive44:47

    Democrats should begin 2028 with a broader electoral map than in recent cycles.

    “you would start with a much more expansive view than we've had really since 2012 or maybe even 08.”

    Listen at 44:47

  27. David Plouffeon Political campaign outreachPositive46:49

    Candidates benefit from combining extensive personal outreach with media presence.

    “work really hard, be everywhere you can, whether that be content or in person. And the blend of that is the most powerful thing.”

    Listen at 46:49

  28. A national majority prefers decent people in political power.

    “I still believe there's a majority in this country that wants good, decent human beings in power.”

    Listen at 47:15

  29. David Plouffeon Republican presidential candidatesNeutral50:40

    Republican presidential candidates need economic distance from Trump to win a general election.

    “for them to have any chance of winning a general election, they're going to have to find some distance from Trump on the economy.”

    Listen at 50:40

  30. David Plouffeon Congressional communicationsNegative51:17

    Congressional floor speeches and Capitol press conferences will not reach target voters.

    “floor speeches and press conferences outside the Capitol will reach no voter we care about ever.”

    Listen at 51:17

  31. David Plouffeon Capitol Hill communicationNegative52:11

    Relying only on Capitol Hill communication will quickly discourage voters.

    “if that is left to Capitol Hill communication, these voters are going to get very discouraged very fast.”

    Listen at 52:11

  32. David Plouffeon Democratic communications strategyPositive52:17

    Democrats must use digital feeds, local television, advertising, and boosted content to communicate achievements.

    “we have to be in their feeds. We have to be on local TV. We have to be actually running ads, boosting content.”

    Listen at 52:17

  33. David Plouffeon Democratic political opportunityNegative52:50

    Democrats’ current political opportunity is fragile.

    “it's very fragile.”

    Listen at 52:50

  34. David Plouffeon Democratic congressional governanceNeutral53:09

    Democratic governing behavior should match campaign advertising and messaging.

    “There could be no distance between the ads and the messaging that these candidates just ran and how we conduct ourselves in Washington.”

    Listen at 53:09

  35. David Plouffeon Democratic policy communicationPositive54:55

    Democrats must substantially increase communication spending on cost and wage policies.

    “you have to overwork then and overspend in this period to communicate on the things you're trying to do to lower cost and increase wages”

    Listen at 54:55

  36. David Plouffeon Democratic advantage on voter prioritiesPositive55:26

    Democrats held a 12-point advantage on focusing on voters’ important problems.

    “we had a 12 point advantage over the Republicans on who's focused on the problems most important to you.”

    Listen at 55:26

  37. David Plouffeon 2028 political candidatesPositive57:09

    Voters will seek younger, newer, less Washington-centered candidates in 2028.

    “people are going to be looking for younger voices, voices out of Washington, new voices.”

    Listen at 57:09

  38. David Plouffeon 2028 presidential candidatesPositive57:43

    Voters will generally seek newer, different presidential candidates in 2028.

    “all things being equal, voters are going to be looking for somebody sort of new and different.”

    Listen at 57:43

  39. David Plouffeon Strongly pro-Trump Republican nomineePositive58:02

    A strongly pro-Trump Republican nominee would give Democrats a major advantage.

    “If there is somebody who is seen as a direct descendant of Donald Trump, a core believer in the MAGA movement and somebody who's involved in it, that gives our side, I think, a big advantage”

    Listen at 58:02

  40. David Plouffeon Presidential candidate communication skillsPositive1:00:43

    Communication, trust-building, and handling tough questions remain essential presidential skills.

    “the ability to communicate, to inspire, to engender trust, to handle tough questions, to go anywhere and everywhere to deliver your message, I still think is the coin of the realm.”

    Listen at 1:00:43

  41. David Plouffeon Presidential candidate performancePositive1:02:05

    Presidential candidate performance matters more to voters than advertising alone.

    “particularly in a presidential campaign, it's going to be the performance of the candidate that I think is what matters most to people.”

    Listen at 1:02:05

  42. David Plouffeon Democratic electoral coalitionPositive1:04:02

    Democratic primary and general-election voter preferences overlap substantially.

    “the route to the nomination and the route to winning 270-plus electoral votes is not as dissimilar as we think”

    Listen at 1:04:02

  43. David Plouffeon Democratic electoral strategyNeutral1:04:04

    Democratic primary and general-election strategies may share more voter priorities than expected.

    “the route to winning 270-plus electoral votes is not as dissimilar as we think”

    Listen at 1:04:04

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.

Former Trump voters give Democrats a blueprint for 2028 · PodLume