Oct 21, 2026 · 45 min
Giants choose McCarthy as Bears face their Super Bowl test
Hour 2: Are the Bears good enough to win the Super Bowl?
The panel weighs whether Chicago has the defense and quarterback play to contend while examining a consequential Giants quarterback decision.
- 1Chicago’s matchup with New England becomes a test of whether the Bears belong among the NFC’s Super Bowl contenders.
- 2The Giants choose J.J. McCarthy over Jameis Winston, prioritizing his mobility and upside despite the pressure to improve quickly.
- 3Stephen A. Smith challenges the expanded College Football Playoff while Bill Belichick’s North Carolina turnaround earns a more favorable review.
Don't miss
The panel reacts to breaking news that the Giants have named J.J. McCarthy their starter against Houston.
The brief
The panel opens by asking whether the Bears and Caleb Williams are genuine Super Bowl contenders, with the Patriots matchup serving as a revealing test of Chicago’s defense and place in the NFC North.
The Giants’ quarterback debate turns on upside versus experience: J.J. McCarthy offers mobility and vertical potential, while Jameis Winston brings a longer track record and recent results.
Breaking news settles the debate as the Giants name McCarthy their starter against Houston, raising the stakes for his fit in the offense and John Harbaugh’s team.
Stephen A. Smith argues that an expanded College Football Playoff diminishes the regular season, then vents about defensive celebrations and the Brewers’ refusal to grant him an interview.
Jeff Saturday credits Bill Belichick’s defensive improvement at North Carolina and his offensive adaptation through Bobby Petrino, offering the episode’s clearest case for a turnaround.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.