Dwarkesh Podcast
Dwarkesh Podcast

Jun 16, 2026 · 2h 8m

Historian Ada Palmer dismantles the myth of Machiavelli as a teacher of evil

Ada Palmer – Machiavelli is the most misunderstood thinker of all time

Understanding the true context behind Machiavelli's writings reveals how Renaissance geopolitics, book scarcity, and early printing shaped modern political philosophy.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Machiavelli wrote his famous treatise as a highly specific, private manuscript for a single ruler while living in forced exile.
  2. 2The brutal tactics of Cesare Borgia and Italian political instability convinced Machiavelli that survival required radical pragmatism.
  3. 3Early print culture and censorship by the Inquisition distorted his reputation, turning a patriot into a caricature of deviousness.

Don't miss

Ada Palmer describes how extreme book scarcity forced scholars like Machiavelli to hand-copy entire classical manuscripts, leading to a deep internalization of texts.

The brief

Historian Ada Palmer reframes Niccolo Machiavelli not as a cynical teacher of evil, but as a deeply patriotic Florentine diplomat whose pragmatic theories were forged in the brutal crucible of Renaissance geopolitics and personal exile.

Machiavelli observed ruthless figures like Cesare Borgia firsthand, realizing that the fragmented Italian city-states required extreme pragmatism to survive constant external threats and the destabilizing influence of the Papacy.

The Prince was never meant as a public handbook for tyranny; it was written as a bespoke, private manuscript for a single ruler, born out of Machiavelli's desperate isolation during his political exile from Florence.

Before the printing press, book scarcity forced scholars to deeply internalize texts. Machiavelli even hand-copied a manuscript of Lucretius, illustrating how limited access to literature fostered profound intellectual scholarship.

Ultimately, Machiavelli's legacy was distorted by early print culture, censorship from the Inquisition, and the rise of copyright monopolies, turning a dedicated civil servant into a synonym for deviousness.

What was said on this episode

58 statements · 24 positive · 10 negative · 7 mixed · 17 neutral

  1. Ada Palmeron government regime changeNegative0:54

    Overthrowing established governments reduces institutional legitimacy and staying power.

    “when you break that, when you overthrow the ruler, when you dissolve the republic, when you put in a new thing, it doesn't have that same staying power.”

    Listen at 0:54

  2. Ada Palmeron Italian city-state governmentsNegative1:36

    Broken institutional continuity causes repeated government overthrows in Italian cities.

    “that thread of continuity is cut for the majority of cities in Italy. And that guarantees from his perspective, that there's going to be more and more and more and more overthrows in those governments.”

    Listen at 1:36

  3. Ada Palmeron papacyNegative3:28

    Papacy precedent normalized arbitrary overthrow of local governments.

    “every new pope feels he has the authority to knock down every pawn upon the chessboard, if he feels like it.”

    Listen at 3:28

  4. Ada Palmeron papal successionNegative3:53

    Elective papal succession made Italian politics unpredictable.

    “there is no predictability to who's going to be pope next. It isn't hereditary. You can't plan for it. The next Pope is elected.”

    Listen at 3:53

  5. Ada Palmeron hereditary regional powerPositive5:04

    A durable hereditary regional power could stabilize papal succession effects.

    “The only Thing that could stop the turnover of popes would be one person gaining enough power and ascendancy near this region who has staying power, who has sons at heredity”

    Listen at 5:04

  6. Ada Palmeron MediciPositive5:38

    A sufficiently powerful Medici presence would force papal negotiation.

    “the papacy fears them and must negotiate with them”

    Listen at 5:38

  7. Ada Palmeron Florence’s strategy toward Cesare BorgiaMixed9:09

    Florence’s survival strategy was temporary submission and support for Borgia.

    “we can buy time and we can absolutely and abjectly swear to do anything he wants.”

    Listen at 9:09

  8. Ada Palmeron buying time through concessionsPositive10:56

    Temporary concessions can sometimes preserve a polity’s survival.

    “buying time is sometimes the survival mechanism.”

    Listen at 10:56

  9. Ada Palmeron Cesare Borgia’s kingdomPositive13:41

    Without several adverse events, Borgia’s kingdom would have survived and conquered Florence.

    “If all those things hadn't gone wrong in a row, the kingdom would have stood and indeed he would have conquered Florence.”

    Listen at 13:41

  10. Ada Palmeron human agency and fortuneNeutral13:57

    Human agency controls at most half of the causes of outcomes.

    “We have power over maximum half of what causes outcomes. The other half is always going to be fortune”

    Listen at 13:57

  11. Ada Palmeron Cesare BorgiaPositive15:05

    Machiavelli’s analysis implies that leaders should imitate the Borgias’ methods despite their eventual failure.

    “And therefore we should imitate them, because everything they did was right.”

    Listen at 15:05

  12. Ada Palmeron Cesare BorgiaPositive15:06

    Machiavelli’s analysis implies rulers should imitate the Borgias’ methods.

    “we should imitate them, because everything they did was right.”

    Listen at 15:06

  13. Ada Palmeron Savonarola’s manipulation and untruthsNegative16:43

    Savonarola’s poorly managed deception caused loss of support and power.

    “he handled his manipulation and untruths badly, in Machiavelli's analysis, in a way that did turn people against him and make him lose power.”

    Listen at 16:43

  14. Ada Palmeron Cesare Borgia’s reputationPositive17:34

    Borgia’s fearsome reputation made allies more loyal after betrayals.

    “even when he would betray an ally, his other allies would say, I gotta be more faithful to him so that the next person to be betrayed isn't me.”

    Listen at 17:34

  15. Ada Palmeron political deceptionMixed18:34

    Political deception succeeds only under particular power-base conditions.

    “it's not just that lying is okay, it's that lying is sometimes okay if you check these other boxes and it's not if you don't.”

    Listen at 18:34

  16. Machiavelli proposed that multiple competing parties could stabilize a state.

    “Machiavelli is the first person that we have ever, in the European tradition to suggest that it could be viable for there to be more than one political party in a state at the same time”

    Listen at 20:02

  17. Ada Palmeron bribery as defensePositive22:24

    Bribing a potential attacker is more reliable than preparing to fight.

    “paying somebody to not attack you is A much more surefire thing than preparing to actually fight against them.”

    Listen at 22:24

  18. Ada Palmeron Geographic distance from RomeMixed24:20

    Geographic distance makes the pope seem more abstract and respectable to political communities.

    “from the perspective of if you're far from Rome, right, when you're Denmark or Iceland, and the Pope is all the way over there”

    Listen at 24:20

  19. Ada Palmeron PapacyNegative32:13

    The papacy became progressively more corrupt over successive generations.

    “the papacy becomes gradually more corrupted over time”

    Listen at 32:13

  20. Ada Palmeron papacyNegative32:13

    The papacy became progressively more corrupt over time.

    “the papacy becomes gradually more corrupted over time.”

    Listen at 32:13

  21. Ada Palmeron Renaissance popesNegative35:08

    Popes became increasingly secular, militarized, and corrupt over time.

    “the popes are getting more secular, more military and more corrupt over time.”

    Listen at 35:08

  22. Ada Palmeron Renaissance patronageNeutral36:35

    Familial patronage and nepotism were fundamental mechanisms holding Renaissance society together.

    “patronage, which was also familial and therefore entangled with nepotism, was so fundamental that”

    Listen at 36:35

  23. Ada Palmeron Pope Paul III’s military appointmentNegative36:56

    Replacing nepotism with a competent outsider provoked riots in Rome.

    “he instead appointed a really competent, experienced general instead of his own, not very competent, illegitimate son. And there were riots in Rome.”

    Listen at 36:56

  24. Ada Palmeron medieval criminal justiceNeutral39:21

    Medieval capital convictions were rare despite severe statutory penalties.

    “maybe one in a hundred convictions for that crime actually ends in a capital sentence.”

    Listen at 39:21

  25. Ada Palmeron Medieval justiceMixed39:36

    Patronage explains why medieval severe legal penalties usually produced lighter actual sentences.

    “Patronage is the answer.”

    Listen at 39:36

  26. Ada Palmeron patronage in Renaissance justiceMixed43:03

    Patronage largely determined whether defendants received lenient or capital sentences.

    “99, their patron stepped in and somebody persuaded somebody who put in a good word, who got the light sentence. And one, that person had fallen out of the patronage network.”

    Listen at 43:03

  27. Ada Palmeron Cesare Borgia’s justice systemPositive50:30

    Borgia’s lack of local factional ties enabled neutral justice.

    “he implements neutral justice because he and his cronies have no side in that city.”

    Listen at 50:30

  28. Ada Palmeron Cesare Borgia’s authoritarian regimePositive50:53

    Borgia’s authoritarian conquest became popular after neutral justice replaced factional rule.

    “he moves into a city, he massacres the rulers, he implements an authoritarian regime, and he's incredibly popular and beloved by the people.”

    Listen at 50:53

  29. Ada Palmeron Cesare BorgiaPositive52:27

    Neutral justice made Cesare Borgia’s violent conquering regime popular among ordinary residents.

    “this makes Valentino's conquering and violent regime incredibly popular with the everyday people of these cities”

    Listen at 52:27

  30. Ada Palmeron authoritarian conquestMixed52:55

    A conqueror can retain power by combining fear with fair treatment.

    “if the conqueror is feared and not hated because he wiped them out, but then was fair toward the people, then it works.”

    Listen at 52:55

  31. Ada Palmeron arbitrary execution powerNegative53:54

    Arbitrary executive power to execute citizens constitutes political slavery.

    “If you live in a state of where there is an arbitrary power who can have you put to death, you are a slave.”

    Listen at 53:54

  32. Ada Palmeron legal processPositive54:10

    A public legal process constitutes liberty even if the system is biased.

    “if there is a system, then you have liberty.”

    Listen at 54:10

  33. Ada Palmeron Internal versus external conquestMixed56:21

    Internal conquerors are more likely than outsiders to preserve a city’s institutions and cultural assets.

    “there is a huge difference between when the conqueror is from your city, loves your city and wants to take care of your city, and when the conqueror is from the outside”

    Listen at 56:21

  34. Medici rule preserved Florence’s cultural identity and physical heritage.

    “when the Medici take over Florence, they want Florence, and they want Florence to be Florence.”

    Listen at 56:35

  35. Ada Palmeron Diplomacy versus warPositive59:47

    Diplomacy produces more conflict avoidance per dollar than military spending.

    “that dollar for dollar diplomacy is cheaper than war”

    Listen at 59:47

  36. Ada Palmeron diplomacy versus warPositive59:47

    Diplomatic spending can achieve more cheaply than equivalent military spending.

    “that dollar for dollar diplomacy is cheaper than war.”

    Listen at 59:47

  37. Ada Palmeron Renaissance technologyNeutral1:02:49

    Renaissance societies treated imitation of ancient Rome as technological advancement.

    “for them, cutting edge technology is imitating the past”

    Listen at 1:02:49

  38. Ada Palmeron Renaissance technologyPositive1:02:49

    Renaissance elites viewed imitation of antiquity as technological advancement.

    “for them, cutting edge technology is imitating the past.”

    Listen at 1:02:49

  39. Ada Palmeron Renaissance ChristianityNeutral1:11:32

    Renaissance Christianity assumed universal recurring sin rather than moral purity.

    “The assumption is everybody sins all the time. There is no such thing as purity.”

    Listen at 1:11:32

  40. Ada Palmeron The PrinceNeutral1:19:12

    Machiavelli wrote The Prince as a loyal application to return to Florentine service.

    “Machiavelli says, no, I'm going to stay and I'm going to rot and I'm going to write the prince, which is my job application, begging the new regime to bring me back and let me work for them and demonstrating my loyalty”

    Listen at 1:19:12

  41. Machiavelli was exceptionally patriotic and devoted to Florence.

    “Machiavelli, fundamentally, is possibly one of the most patriotic patriots in Earth's history.”

    Listen at 1:19:50

  42. Ada Palmeron The PrinceNeutral1:20:27

    Machiavelli intended The Prince as proprietary political knowledge for Florence, not broad public circulation.

    “The prince's secret proprietary, the secret sauce of how to maintain power. And he will not let any other power have that right.”

    Listen at 1:20:27

  43. Machiavelli intended his political knowledge exclusively for Florence’s government.

    “he will only share that with the government of his country because he wants it to protect his country.”

    Listen at 1:20:53

  44. Ada Palmeron Renaissance political handbooksNeutral1:24:58

    Bespoke political handbooks functioned like proprietary technology.

    “We have to think of these books as proprietary technology.”

    Listen at 1:24:58

  45. Ada Palmeron Reception of radical worksNeutral1:28:29

    Works with radical ideas gain readership when later societies find them relevant to contemporary questions.

    “It is often the case that a work which contains radically unusual ideas will drift along, being not particularly zoomed in on by society and not widely read until it hits a moment that the new questions being asked in that century or that decade are answered by something in that text.”

    Listen at 1:28:29

  46. Ada Palmeron intellectually radical worksPositive1:28:31

    Works gain popularity when later questions make their unusual ideas newly useful.

    “a work which contains radically unusual ideas will drift along, being not particularly zoomed in on by society and not widely read until it hits a moment that the new questions being asked in that century or that decade are answered by something in that text. And then suddenly everyone will start reading it.”

    Listen at 1:28:31

  47. Machiavelli offered an early framework for analyzing government independently of religion.

    “Machiavelli Is this early foundational? What if we think about government in a box without plugging into religion?”

    Listen at 1:34:13

  48. Machiavelli evaluated religion primarily for its psychological effects on citizens and political behavior.

    “Machiavelli is absolutely thinking about the psychological effects of a religion on the people”

    Listen at 1:38:37

  49. Ada Palmeron Roman religion versus ChristianityPositive1:40:10

    Machiavelli judged Roman religion more conducive to patriotism and stability than Christianity.

    “Roman religion was much better for patriotism and political stability than Christianity.”

    Listen at 1:40:10

  50. Ada Palmeron religion in civic educationNeutral1:40:58

    Governments should evaluate religion as a civic capability rather than divine truth.

    “you need to think about it in the same neutral way you think about cultivating literacy skills or math skills in your citizenry.”

    Listen at 1:40:58

  51. Ada Palmeron Renaissance scholarly worksPositive1:45:12

    Renaissance works framed as ancient commentary gained greater popularity and sales.

    “if your book is a comment on an ancient, it is going to be way more popular and sell way better”

    Listen at 1:45:12

  52. Ada Palmeron Renaissance scholarshipNeutral1:49:11

    Renaissance scholars often presented original ideas as commentaries on ancient authorities to gain credibility.

    “if you realize that what it is, is their style guide requires original thought to be presented in the form of a commentary on an ancient”

    Listen at 1:49:11

  53. Ada Palmeron early copyrightNeutral1:53:42

    Early copyright emerged from the Inquisition’s printing-approval system.

    “the very first version of copyright is the Inquisition.”

    Listen at 1:53:42

  54. Ada Palmeron Early copyrightNeutral1:53:42

    Early copyright emerged from the Inquisition’s licensing and monopolization of printed books.

    “the very first version of copyright is the Inquisition”

    Listen at 1:53:42

  55. Ada Palmeron InquisitionNeutral1:56:22

    The Inquisition operated through decentralized local officials with slow Vatican communication.

    “The Inquisition is overseen by a whole bunch of isolated guys who are in isolated towns. And it takes weeks or months to even communicate with the Vatican.”

    Listen at 1:56:22

  56. Ada Palmeron government patronage and Inquisition enforcementPositive1:59:02

    Government patronage could shield heterodox people from Inquisition enforcement.

    “if you're in with the government, you can be as heretical as you like and the Inquisition can't touch you.”

    Listen at 1:59:02

  57. Ada Palmeron The PrinceNeutral2:03:34

    The Prince is a manual for stabilizing and retaining political power.

    “it's a manual not of how to gain power, but of how to keep power.”

    Listen at 2:03:34

  58. Ada Palmeron The PrincePositive2:08:03

    Readers should interpret The Prince through Machiavelli’s patriotic self-sacrifice.

    “read it and remember it was written by somebody who was willing to give up anything to serve his country.”

    Listen at 2:08:03

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Books & mentions

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.