
Nov 18, 2026 · 1h 42m
Hosts challenge Alabama’s playoff ranking and college sports’ direction
The College Football Playoff Committee Bias + Connor's New Game | Mostly Sports EP 778 | 11.18.26
The episode uses Alabama’s ranking as a case study in whether playoff standards are consistent and whether college sports still have a coherent culture.
- 1The hosts argue Alabama’s No. 3 ranking reflects inconsistent standards and possible SEC favoritism more than résumé strength.
- 2Illinois’ upset of Duke anchors a wider discussion of early college basketball, unexpected NBA scoring bursts, and hockey’s emerging storylines.
- 3Transfer-portal movement, player compensation, and committee dysfunction raise questions about college sports’ future and institutional identity.
Don't miss
The hosts turn Thanksgiving traditions into a guessing game about whether Kirk Herbstreit or his dogs have done them.
The brief
Mark Titus and Brandon Walker open with the College Football Playoff rankings, questioning why Alabama remains No. 3 while the committee appears to shift between résumé, head-to-head, and close-loss criteria.
The argument widens from Alabama and Mississippi State to the playoff’s broader design: ranking 25 teams, preserving seeding stakes, and possibly nudging major programs toward a breakaway league.
Illinois’ upset of Duke leads into a fast-moving sports roundtable covering Tennessee’s defense, Michigan State’s shooting, Quentin Grimes’ 47-point game, and Connor Bedard’s shoulder problems.
The hosts test whether transfer-portal culture and player compensation are eroding school attachment, using Sam Leavitt’s apparent detachment from LSU traditions as the prompt.
The standout comic detour is a Thanksgiving guessing game built around whether each tradition belongs to the holiday or to Kirk Herbstreit and his dogs.
Games, playoff-hat jokes, hockey reactions, baseball trivia, and Connor’s teased announcement keep the episode loose while returning to the question of what sports culture is becoming.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.