Sep 9, 2026 · 1h 41m
Listen from 1:18:23
Listen at 1:18:23
Jurors debate insanity as Turek defends objective reality
ALARMING Comments From Female Lindsay Clancy Jurors, Shock Elizabeth Holmes Doc, and Frank Turek on One Year Since Charlie Kirk | Ep. 1394
The episode links a contested criminal-responsibility case with a broader argument about evidence, grief, faith, and the meaning of truth.
- 1Juror accounts expose sharp disagreement over psychosis, reasonable doubt, and criminal responsibility in the Lindsay Clancy case.
- 2Megyn Kelly rejects conspiracy theories surrounding the case and Charlie Kirk’s death, insisting public claims remain tied to evidence.
- 3Frank Turek argues that objective reality and religious faith offer an answer to ideological narratives and contemporary moral confusion.
Don't miss
Kelly rejects speculative conspiracy theories about Charlie Kirk’s death and redirects the conversation toward admissible evidence and provable facts.
The brief
Megyn Kelly opens with juror accounts from the Lindsay Clancy insanity case, focusing on a holdout’s change of position and the limits of amateur psychological reasoning.
The discussion turns to the emotional force of Patrick Clancy’s 911 call and competing explanations involving psychosis, medication, alcohol, and responsibility.
After brief detours into a documentary and tennis sportsmanship, Frank Turek joins Kelly to discuss Charlie Kirk’s death, Erica’s grief, and the pressure of leadership.
Turek presents The War on Reality as a defense of objective truth against ideological narratives, while Kelly emphasizes provable facts over conspiracy theories.
The episode’s central tension is whether grief, faith, and public controversy can be discussed honestly without surrendering evidence or reason.
What was said on this episode
34 statements · 11 positive · 19 negative · 4 neutral
Jurors improperly acted as experts when interpreting Clancy’s toxicology report.
“acting as a little mini expert to interpret the toxicology report for the lone holdout juror”
Listen at 7:08
The holdout juror appropriately rejected jurors’ informal medical expertise.
“This holdout jurors decision to reject that as not the expertise he was going to base a life or death decision on was entirely appropriate.”
Listen at 7:32
The prosecution’s jury-instruction performance caused the case to be lost.
“The prosecution failed so terribly on jury instruction. That's where this case was clearly lost.”
Listen at 12:32
Criminal conviction does not require eliminating every conceivable doubt.
“The standard is not, must be found guilty beyond any doubt on earth.”
Listen at 18:17
The holdout juror was entitled to maintain his view of the evidence.
“He's entitled to that POV.”
Listen at 19:00
Jurors should not be pressured to change a verdict against their conscience.
“You shouldn't be bullied into changing your verdict when you actually don't believe a change of verdict is necessary.”
Listen at 22:03
Any plea deal for Lindsay Clancy should guarantee substantial incarceration.
“If they cut a deal, it needs to be for a significant, like a guaranteed amount of time behind bars.”
Listen at 27:33
Prosecutors should demand incarceration or proceed to another trial.
“That's the only deal we strike or we go back to trial.”
Listen at 28:03
The Corey Walsh case is an obvious copycat of the Lindsay Clancy case.
“And it's an obvious copycat.”
Listen at 29:39
Walsh’s interest in the Clancy case likely influenced her alleged crime.
“I, for one, am persuaded by her. extreme interest in the case as expressed within hours of her doing this, that it did play a role.”
Listen at 31:27
Mental-health defenses are increasingly used to avoid imprisoning mothers who kill children.
“How many ways can we find to get mothers out of jail for murdering their children?”
Listen at 36:21
The Theranos fraud was extraordinarily shocking and compelling.
“the fraud that was committed is jaw dropping and riveting”
Listen at 45:28
Parents should never leave minor children alone with strangers.
“Do not leave your minor child alone with any stranger. Ever.”
Listen at 58:49
Athlete media access drives fan interest, ticket sales, and prize money.
“The access by the fans to the players generates interest and puts butts in the seats at the stadiums, which generates ticket sales, which is what pays you the big prize money when you win.”
Listen at 1:04:39
Naomi Osaka uses press access to build her brand.
“you work with the press and you use the press to build your brand”
Listen at 1:05:23
Naomi Osaka was decisively defeated at the U.S. Open.
“she was beaten roundly. It was it was a decisive victory.”
Listen at 1:10:27
Grand Slam players should prioritize tennis and professional attire over spectacle.
“the best thing to do when performing at a Grand Slam tournament is to focus on the tennis, to dress like a professional tennis player, and to focus on one's game”
Listen at 1:11:12
Turek believes his post-assassination symptoms are normal rather than PTSD.
“people call this PTSD, but I think that's a misnomer. There's no disorder. I mean, that's normal.”
Listen at 1:16:33
Frank Turek considers his post-traumatic reactions normal rather than disordered.
“There's no disorder. I mean, that's normal.”
Listen at 1:16:37
Erica Kirk has responded to attacks with restraint and grace.
“She has never lashed out. She's always been full of grace and truth.”
Listen at 1:18:23
Turek believes Erica Kirk is guided by God and receptive to that guidance.
“she really has the Holy Spirit. She is directed by God, and she's yielded to that.”
Listen at 1:18:40
Charlie Kirk’s humility exceeded his considerable intellect.
“the only thing that exceeded his intellect was his humility”
Listen at 1:26:54
Attempts to deny or resist reality will ultimately fail.
“reality is undefeated. I mean, you can deny reality. You can fight against it. But ultimately, reality is going to win.”
Listen at 1:29:21
Charlie Kirk defended objective reality against people who denied it.
“Charlie was fighting for reality while many people were fighting against reality.”
Listen at 1:29:49
Claims that reason is oppressive are self-contradictory.
“reason is a tool of oppression as they try and reason us to that conclusion”
Listen at 1:30:35
Turek characterizes Tyler Robinson, not Charlie Kirk, as fascist.
“the guy that shot him is a fascist. It's not Charlie Kirk.”
Listen at 1:32:22
Charlie Kirk promoted Christianity and accepted personal risk to do so.
“Charlie Kirk was a Christian man who wanted to bring the truth to people, and he was willing to put himself in harm's way to do so.”
Listen at 1:32:26
Turek claims third-trimester abortion is never medically necessary to save the mother.
“There is never a reason in the third trimester to have a baby die in order to save a mother.”
Listen at 1:34:19
Turek attributes several murders and related conduct to demonic activity.
“this is demonic activity. I'm sorry, it just is. It's demonic activity.”
Listen at 1:35:25
Frank Turek says attacks on Erica Kirk rely on speculation rather than evidence.
“They don't have facts. All they have is speculation. They don't have evidence.”
Listen at 1:36:03
Conspiracy theories about Charlie’s murder lack supporting evidence.
“They don't have evidence. I mean, look, anything's possible, Megan. Charlie could have been killed by an alien. That's possible. But do we have any evidence for that? No.”
Listen at 1:36:07
Restricting analysis to provable facts leads to correct conclusions and avoids deception.
“if you just follow those simple rules, you will get to the right result. You will. You will not be misled.”
Listen at 1:36:50
Conspiracy theorists will not abandon their beliefs because of evidence or verdicts.
“they will not be disabused of their beliefs. Not by facts, not by eyewitness testimony, not by a court verdict, not by any of it.”
Listen at 1:38:25
The evidence overwhelmingly implicates Tyler Robinson in Charlie Kirk’s murder.
“the evidence in this case, which is overwhelming against Tyler Robinson”
Listen at 1:38:50
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Books & mentions
Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.