Oct 1, 2026 · 44 min
Listener calls test the limits of rock criticism
Bonus: Old Rockstars With No F*cks Left To Give
The episode turns audience reactions into a broader discussion of conspiracy theories, controversial artists, and the ethics of negative criticism.
- 1Jake Brend expands on Quincy Jones’s later-life claims while responding to listener reactions and questions.
- 2A caller raises Vincent Bugliosi’s Case Closed theory about Lee Harvey Oswald and the Kennedy assassination.
- 3Discussion of Drake becomes a test of how directly critics should address music they dislike.
Don't miss
A listener’s Kennedy-assassination discussion gives the bonus episode its sharpest turn from rock commentary into historical argument.
The brief
Jake Brend frames the After Party as Disgraceland’s show after the show, using listener voicemails, texts, DMs, and emails to extend earlier conversations.
The episode returns to controversial claims made by Quincy Jones later in life, treating them as a starting point for audience debate rather than a settled conclusion.
A caller brings up Vincent Bugliosi’s Case Closed theory about Lee Harvey Oswald and the Kennedy assassination, prompting Brend to begin assessing the argument.
A joke about disliking Drake’s work opens a more revealing question: how can critics be honest about musicians without turning every judgment into needless negativity?
Books & mentions
Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.
