Equity Mates Investing Podcast
Equity Mates Investing Podcast

Nov 16, 2026 · 43 min

Luke Laretive challenges small-cap certainty

“Everyone is always wrong” - What Luke Laretive learned from a tough year in small caps

The episode examines how investors can manage uncertainty, losses and valuation gaps without relying on market forecasts or recent performance.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Flexibility, active trading and diversified return drivers helped Seneca navigate a difficult small-cap market.
  2. 2Laretive treats losses as inevitable, arguing that disciplined valuation and favorable payoff ratios matter more than avoiding every mistake.
  3. 3Potential opportunities span resource-sector M&A, underpriced fund managers and wealth platforms whose valuations may assume too much growth.

Don't miss

Luke explains why “everyone is always wrong” means investors should resist recency bias and avoid extrapolating current market conditions indefinitely.

The brief

Luke Laretive returns to discuss Seneca’s Australian Small Companies Fund and the lessons of a difficult period: stay agnostic, follow value and remain willing to trade.

His account of the fund’s troubled Matsa investment turns losses into a broader lesson: paper analysis can fail, so outcomes depend on payoff size as well as win rate.

Laretive rejects the easy call that small caps must outperform next year, while acknowledging valuation gaps and performance differences make selective opportunities more compelling.

“Everyone is always wrong” is his warning against recency bias: current conditions can inform decisions, but they should not become permanent assumptions about markets.

The conversation then tests that discipline against possible resource M&A involving Antipa and Greatland, plus value in fund managers and wealth platforms such as Hub24.

What was said on this episode

37 statements · 21 positive · 11 negative · 5 neutral

  1. Luke Laretiveon Seneca Australian Small Companies FundPositive1:01

    Seneca is currently at the top of its peer group.

    “we're top of the peer groups. I don't know how much better we can be going, to be honest.”

    Listen at 1:01

  2. Luke Laretiveon Active management in Australian small capsPositive4:06

    Active management is sensible in Australian small-cap equities.

    “I think active in Aussie smalls is pretty sensible.”

    Listen at 4:06

  3. Investors should flexibly pursue value across sectors and strategies.

    “you've kind of got to have the ability to go where value is and not be sort of too religious about how you make money or too precious about it.”

    Listen at 5:34

  4. Luke Laretiveon Seneca Australian Small Companies FundNegative8:05

    Seneca may not produce positive 5% returns in the next small-cap bear market.

    “I'm not sure in the next 15 or 20% small cap bear market, we're going to spit out positive 5% returns again.”

    Listen at 8:05

  5. Luke Laretiveon Seneca Australian Small Companies FundPositive8:46

    Seneca often outperforms the index during strong market months.

    “when the market does like threes and fours in a month, we often do eight, nine, 10, 11, 12, you know, like we're often multiples of the index.”

    Listen at 8:46

  6. Luke Laretiveon Investment total returnsNeutral10:01

    Investment returns can come from distributions and asset sales, not only price appreciation.

    “total return comes from not just share price go from $1 to $2.”

    Listen at 10:01

  7. Luke Laretiveon MatsaNegative11:59

    Diesel-related problems materially harmed Matsa's business.

    “The diesel issues that popped up during the year really hurt a business that trucks all of its oil quite a long way.”

    Listen at 11:59

  8. Luke Laretiveon Seneca investment ideasPositive13:11

    Seneca's average winning idea adds 2.5%, while its average loss subtracts 1%.

    “Our average win adds 2.5% roughly to the portfolio. Our average loss takes 1% off the portfolio.”

    Listen at 13:11

  9. Luke Laretiveon Seneca investment ideasPositive13:18

    Seneca reports a 59% winning-idea rate and 41% losing-idea rate.

    “we've had 59% of our ideas be winning ideas and 41% be losing ideas.”

    Listen at 13:18

  10. Luke Laretiveon Australian small caps versus large capsNeutral14:46
    “I don't.”

    Listen at 14:46

  11. Luke Laretiveon Australian small capsPositive15:38

    Relative small-cap underperformance generally creates an attractive buying opportunity.

    “if smalls have been struggling relative to large, it's usually a pretty good time to buy smalls.”

    Listen at 15:38

  12. Investors should set asset allocation according to their objectives.

    “I think the game is to like set your asset allocation to meet your objectives and how you want to invest your money.”

    Listen at 15:53

  13. Luke Laretiveon ETF selection differencesNeutral16:34

    Small ETF-selection differences are generally immaterial to investment outcomes.

    “None of that shit matters. Like, it's not material.”

    Listen at 16:34

  14. Luke Laretiveon Investor concernsNeutral20:54

    Current investor concerns will likely differ from concerns in twelve months.

    “what people are panicking about today will not be the thing they're panicking about in 12 months' time.”

    Listen at 20:54

  15. Luke Laretiveon Gold companiesPositive21:56

    Gold companies currently have substantial cash available for acquisitions.

    “in gold, there's lots of cash around”

    Listen at 21:56

  16. Cash-rich companies can use mergers to pursue growth without issuing cash-funded equity.

    “what you can do is you can go and offer shares to a competitor and say, hey, put your stock with my stock and then we'll grow together.”

    Listen at 22:16

  17. Index inclusion is the top M&A objective for ASX companies below $10 billion market capitalization.

    “I reckon point number one on every M&A deck for every ASX listed company under $10 billion market cap is number one, index inclusion.”

    Listen at 22:39

  18. Luke Laretiveon Index inclusion-driven investingNegative23:17

    Index-inclusion-driven flows can produce overvalued businesses that later disappoint and are shorted.

    “that's how you end up with, you know. lunacy overvalued businesses that then disappoint and get shorted”

    Listen at 23:17

  19. Luke Laretiveon Index investing advice from LukeNegative24:06

    Luke will not offer clients index investing as a suboptimal paid option.

    “I think that if you want to come to me and you want me to help you with your money, I'm not going to offer you a suboptimal option.”

    Listen at 24:06

  20. Greatland could acquire a nearby high-grade asset and bring it into production quickly.

    “you can go and buy a pretty high-grade neighbor. get it into production pretty quickly”

    Listen at 26:29

  21. Luke wants Sean Day to complete the proposed Antipa deal.

    “I wish Sean would go out and do this deal.”

    Listen at 27:07

  22. Luke Laretiveon AntipaPositive27:39

    Antipa is among roughly six or seven near-term resource takeovers that could occur.

    “it's one of probably six, seven sort of near-ish term takeovers we think can happen”

    Listen at 27:39

  23. A four-person fund-management team can potentially manage one billion dollars.

    “once you've got a fund manager set up, you know, we have a four person team, you know, like we can run a billion dollars if we wanted to.”

    Listen at 30:13

  24. Luke Laretiveon Fund-manager share pricesNegative32:33

    Fund-manager share prices can be driven by headlines about portfolio holdings.

    “we think that a lot of, in the same way the stock market works, we think a lot of the fund manager share prices get caught up in headlines about specific stocks that they own.”

    Listen at 32:33

  25. Luke Laretiveon GQG PartnersPositive33:13

    GQG is currently trading at approximately a 16% dividend yield.

    “GQG's on a 16% dividend yield.”

    Listen at 33:13

  26. Luke Laretiveon Regal PartnersPositive33:24

    Regal would trade at approximately 4.5 times forward earnings.

    “Even on forward basis, it'd be on four and a half times earnings.”

    Listen at 33:24

  27. Luke Laretiveon Good fund managersPositive34:23

    Good fund managers' periods of underperformance eventually end.

    “underperformance for good managers does not last forever.”

    Listen at 34:23

  28. Luke Laretiveon Rajiv JainPositive34:40

    Rajiv Jain will eventually recover from his current underperformance.

    “Rajiv will be the same. He will have a similar comeuppance at some point because he's good.”

    Listen at 34:40

  29. Luke Laretiveon Regal PartnersPositive35:31

    Phil King's departure would benefit Regal's business.

    “I actually think him going is great for that business.”

    Listen at 35:31

  30. Luke Laretiveon Pinnacle Investment ManagementNegative35:48

    Pinnacle Investment Management remains overvalued and flow-dependent.

    “I always think it's overvalued and I think it's still subject to flows”

    Listen at 35:48

  31. Luke Laretiveon GQG Partners and Regal PartnersPositive36:28

    GQG and Regal offer approximately 16% and 8% dividend yields, respectively.

    “when you've got GQG on a 16% dividend yield, you've got Regal on a like 8% dividend yield”

    Listen at 36:28

  32. Luke Laretiveon Netwealth and Hub24Negative38:07

    Luke does not like Netwealth or Hub24 as stocks.

    “I don't like, from a stock perspective, NetWealth, Hub.”

    Listen at 38:07

  33. Luke Laretiveon Netwealth and Hub24Negative38:15

    Netwealth and Hub24 are heavily overrated businesses.

    “I think the businesses are overrated, heavily overrated.”

    Listen at 38:15

  34. Luke Laretiveon Netwealth and Hub24Negative38:29

    Netwealth and Hub24 are valued like technology businesses despite not being pure software companies.

    “Are they really a software business? Are they really, you know, like they're priced like they're a tech business.”

    Listen at 38:29

  35. Luke Laretiveon Netwealth and Hub24Negative39:41

    Netwealth and Hub24 will face difficulty from regulatory responsibilities.

    “I think they're going to have a hard time there.”

    Listen at 39:41

  36. Luke Laretiveon NetwealthPositive39:43

    Hub24 and Netwealth will ultimately win their market.

    “I still think Harvard Net Wealth win. They win this business.”

    Listen at 39:43

  37. Luke Laretiveon NetwealthNegative39:48

    Hub24 and Netwealth are not clearly great-value trades at current prices.

    “I can't necessarily say that they're great value trades at the current share price.”

    Listen at 39:48

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.