Not Skinny But Not Fat
Not Skinny But Not Fat

Sep 15, 2026 · 1h 16m

Madelaine Petsch turns Riverdale fame into creative control

Madelaine Petsch: From Riverdale to Scream Queen

Petsch connects the pressures of celebrity visibility with the harder-won autonomy of producing, choosing roles, and protecting her private life.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Riverdale’s streaming afterlife amplified fan culture while its increasingly outrageous storylines became part of the show’s appeal.
  2. 2Petsch describes therapy, privacy, and personal alignment as counterweights to Hollywood beauty standards and online attention.
  3. 3Producing The Strangers trilogy gave Petsch a larger role in rewriting, editing, and shaping the work beyond acting.

Don't miss

Petsch recalls the emotional farewell shared by the Riverdale cast and crew after seven years of working together.

The brief

Madelaine Petsch and Amanda V trace Riverdale’s rise from weekly television to Netflix-fueled fandom, including the show’s increasingly absurd storylines and Petsch’s long commitment to Cheryl Blossom.

Petsch recounts moving to Los Angeles, working multiple jobs, and testing first for Betty before landing Cheryl—an audition detour that shaped her career.

The conversation turns inward as Petsch discusses childhood bullying, Hollywood beauty standards, anxiety, somatic therapy, and archiving her YouTube videos to reclaim privacy.

Her Riverdale friendships remain a central source of continuity, culminating in an emotional farewell after seven years with the cast and crew.

Petsch describes expanding into producing on The Strangers trilogy, rewriting scripts and participating in the edit while pursuing horror projects including American Horror Story.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.