The NPR Politics Podcast
The NPR Politics Podcast

Oct 5, 2026 · 23 min

Maine tests Collins’s hold on a pivotal Senate seat

The path to Senate control runs through this state

The race pits Susan Collins’s moderate brand and Senate influence against a late Democratic challenger in a contest that could still shape control of the chamber.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Troy Jackson entered after Graham Plattner’s withdrawal, leaving him little time to inherit an existing progressive campaign movement.
  2. 2Susan Collins is balancing her record delivering federal funds with efforts to present herself as a check on President Trump.
  3. 3Early voting, Republican advertising, outside money, and four debates will determine whether Maine remains a serious Senate pickup opportunity.

Don't miss

The discussion weighs whether Collins can credibly present herself as a check on President Trump while defending her Senate record and seniority.

The brief

Maine’s Senate race remains competitive because Susan Collins’s long-standing popularity collides with the state’s recent support for Democratic presidential candidates and Democrats’ hopes of a pickup.

Troy Jackson entered after Graham Plattner withdrew amid allegations he denied, giving the labor-backed Maine politician limited time to build recognition and transfer the campaign’s progressive energy.

Collins is campaigning on her appropriations power and as a check on President Trump, but federal funding rescissions and her voting record complicate both arguments.

Steve Mistler describes a race where Republican advertising, attacks on Jackson, dark money, and limited transparency could matter as early voting begins.

The contest may no longer top the national Senate map, yet its cost, competitiveness, and four upcoming debates keep Maine consequential for both campaigns.

What was said on this episode

13 statements · 2 positive · 7 negative · 4 neutral

  1. Steve Mistleron Maine Senate raceNeutral1:08

    The Maine Senate race would be close regardless of the Democratic nominee.

    “I think it was going to be a close race.”

    Listen at 1:08

  2. Steve Mistleron Susan Collins reelection campaignPositive1:55

    Collins’s ability to secure federal funding is helping her reelection campaign.

    “her ability to secure federal contracts and earmarks and that sort of thing, how that's really, you know, playing into her reelection bid now.”

    Listen at 1:55

  3. Steve Mistleron Troy JacksonNegative3:57

    Maine voters currently have limited familiarity with Troy Jackson.

    “Voters just don't have a lot of sense of who he is.”

    Listen at 3:57

  4. Steve Mistleron Troy Jackson campaignNegative4:44

    Republican advertising is defining Jackson before he can introduce himself.

    “he's trying to introduce himself to voters while a Republican machine is trying to define him before he has a chance to do that.”

    Listen at 4:44

  5. Tamara Keithon Troy Jackson campaignNegative7:30

    Jackson is struggling to replace Plattner’s campaign appeal.

    “I think that what we're seeing with Jackson is some of that difficulty”

    Listen at 7:30

  6. Steve Mistleron Troy Jackson campaignNegative8:17

    Building Plattner’s movement within two or three months is difficult for Jackson.

    “And it's hard for any kind of candidate to try to pull that off.”

    Listen at 8:17

  7. Steve Mistleron Susan CollinsPositive9:44

    Collins’s campaign primarily emphasizes bringing federal money to Maine.

    “she is campaigning almost exclusively on her ability to bring home federal dollars to the state.”

    Listen at 9:44

  8. Recent White House actions are undermining Collins’s campaign position.

    “that really undermine her campaign or her position.”

    Listen at 12:45

  9. Steve Mistleron CanadaNeutral13:32

    Canada is Maine’s leading trade partner.

    “this is Maine's leading trade partner”

    Listen at 13:32

  10. Steve Mistleron Maine voters’ check on Donald TrumpNegative15:20

    Maine voters seeking a check on Trump are looking beyond Collins.

    “they're looking somewhere else to find that check, not necessarily in Maine.”

    Listen at 15:20

  11. Steve Mistleron Collins reelection allegationsNeutral19:01

    There is no polling showing whether the allegations changed Collins’s reelection support.

    “we haven't seen any polling to get a good measurement of whether or not it's given them second thoughts about reelecting her in November.”

    Listen at 19:01

  12. Steve Mistleron Susan CollinsNeutral19:33

    Collins’s campaign believes the ProPublica story matters politically.

    “Collins's campaign is acting like it does.”

    Listen at 19:33

  13. Steve Mistleron Republican and Democratic campaignsNegative21:54

    Republicans and Democrats are increasingly using dark money to conceal donors.

    “They're both increasingly relying on dark money to obscure their donors”

    Listen at 21:54

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.