Slightly Above Average Podcast
Slightly Above Average Podcast

Nov 12, 2026 · 1h 8m

Marketplace weirdness reveals the internet’s strangest local economy

We Found The Weirdest Facebook Marketplace Posts

The episode turns bizarre listings into a revealing look at online trust, regional identity, scams, and the things people refuse to throw away.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Facebook Marketplace’s algorithm surfaces a strange blend of collectibles, homemade machines, memorabilia, and questionable food.
  2. 2The platform’s usefulness depends on navigating scams, awkward meetups, misleading listings, and inconsistent seller etiquette.
  3. 3Regional artifacts from Pittsburgh and Ohio give the listings a distinct personality before a cold Thanksgiving flatbread taste test ends the tour.

Don't miss

The hosts move from a bizarre Marketplace catalog to a cold Thanksgiving flatbread, then debate whether turkey or ham better represents holiday food.

The brief

The hosts begin with more than 30 bizarre Facebook Marketplace listings, where mannequins, coffins, a Nixon shower head, and a horse-riding machine turn local commerce into surreal browsing.

Before the catalog of oddities, they examine why Marketplace remains useful despite scams, canned replies, misleading descriptions, ratings anxiety, and tense meetups with strangers.

The listings become a regional archive: Pittsburgh Dad memorabilia, cigarette advertising, clown collectibles, vintage NFL cups, unusual vehicles, and household objects preserve a peculiar local taste.

The strangest finds include a five-wheel BMB dragster, a structurally troubled truck, an army of mannequins, a metal urinal, and homemade food whose safety is impossible to verify.

The episode ends with a cold Thanksgiving flatbread combining turkey, mozzarella, cranberry, and onions, prompting a broader turkey-versus-ham argument about preserved meat and holiday food.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.