
Nov 13, 2026 · 53 min
Mississippi State bets on loyalty as coaching rankings shift
Reranking the Best Coaching Hires + Week 11 Preview | The BFW Show 11.12.26
The episode weighs whether player loyalty, coaching decisions, and late-season results are reshaping the college football playoff and hiring picture.
- 1Kamario Taylor’s Mississippi State commitment becomes a referendum on loyalty, rebuilding, and the value of staying through a lost season.
- 2Indiana remains in playoff contention, but its schedule and narrow wins leave little margin against USC and the Big Ten.
- 3Bob Chesney and Morgan Scali rise in the first-year coaching rankings as Utah and Cal expose costly decisions.
Don't miss
Brandon Walker passionately celebrates Kamario Taylor’s decision to remain at Mississippi State despite lucrative opportunities elsewhere.
The brief
Brandon Walker and Jack reopen their first-year coaching rankings, using the season’s evidence to elevate Bob Chesney and Morgan Scali while questioning Utah and Cal.
Kamario Taylor’s decision to remain at Mississippi State anchors the episode: the hosts frame loyalty as a rebuilding choice and argue his injury altered the Bulldogs’ season.
Indiana’s playoff case gets a skeptical hearing. Kurt Cignetti’s complaints meet questions about the Hoosiers’ schedule and narrow wins, though USC and the Big Ten keep the path open.
The hosts debate Drew Mestemaker’s Heisman case and NFL outlook, then turn to Week 11 tests including Miami–Duke, Ole Miss–Oklahoma, Texas–LSU, and Georgia–Missouri.
The episode’s larger verdict is that coaching evaluations remain fluid: strong hires can rise quickly, while quarterback, staff, and roster decisions can sink a promising season.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.