Oct 17, 2026 · 1h 5m
Narrow leadership tests the case for beaten-down stocks
Value Play or Value Trap?; 134 Stocks in the S&P 500 are in a 40% Drawdown; $TSMC Earnings
The episode examines whether weak market breadth and high interest rates are creating genuine value opportunities or exposing businesses in prolonged decline.
- 1Market concentration raises questions about AI spending, mega-cap valuations, and the durability of narrow leadership.
- 2Homebuilder declines may reflect cyclical opportunity or extended earnings pressure from affordability constraints and elevated mortgage rates.
- 3Wise, TSMC, and legacy technology companies show how pricing, manufacturing scale, and entrenched workflows shape growth economics.
Don't miss
The rapid-fire closing review sorts decade-low valuation multiples into potential value plays, value traps, and businesses too difficult to analyze confidently.
The brief
Ryan Henderson and substitute co-host Jason Hall begin with a market split: AI and mega-cap technology drive indexes while 134 S&P 500 stocks sit at least 40% below their highs.
The hosts separate valuation resets from business deterioration across legacy technology, Nike, PayPal, Lululemon, and FICO, asking which companies still possess durable competitive advantages.
Homebuilders near 52-week lows create a sharper test of value investing: incentives and mortgage-rate buydowns may support demand, but high rates could prolong earnings pressure.
Berkshire Hathaway’s investment in Bending Spoons opens a discussion about distressed digital assets, pandemic-era valuations, and why private companies may need restructuring.
TSMC’s manufacturing scale and Wise’s pricing strategy offer contrasting growth stories, while the closing stock review favors Booking Holdings, FICO, and CoStar over several apparent bargains.
The episode’s central takeaway is that a low multiple alone says little: investors must distinguish temporary pressure from weakening economics, balance sheets, and competitive position.
What was said on this episode
51 statements · 32 positive · 12 negative · 2 mixed · 5 neutral
Oracle may offer an interesting risk-reward opportunity.
“Oracle could be something interesting”
Listen at 5:28
Oracle could experience a substantial decline.
“Oracle could fall a ton”
Listen at 5:47
Oracle could perform extremely well over five years.
“we could also look back five years from now and it could do extremely well”
Listen at 5:51
Oracle is the most leveraged major infrastructure spender.
“It's the most leveraged of the large spenders on infrastructure.”
Listen at 5:55
Adobe will continue substantial business with existing customers.
“Adobe is going to continue to do a ton of business with its existing customers.”
Listen at 9:10
The S&P 500’s top ten holdings should outperform its 134 bottom performers.
“I would probably take the top 10 before I took this 134 bottom performers.”
Listen at 9:53
FICO is an extraordinary business.
“It is an extraordinary business.”
Listen at 11:51
FICO can remain a market-crushing moneymaker despite competition.
“FICO still be a market crushing moneymaker.”
Listen at 12:07
Tractor Supply can continue growing and gaining market share.
“Tractor supply, I think, has a good opportunity to continue to grow, take market share.”
Listen at 12:54
Nike is among the world’s roughly thirty best businesses.
“this is one of the... I would say one of the probably 30 best businesses in the world.”
Listen at 13:05
Nike is unattractive to own unless purchased near twelve times cash flow.
“unless I can buy it for like 12 times cash flows, I don't really find that a compelling business to want to own.”
Listen at 13:40
The food business is mature.
“Food is a mature business.”
Listen at 13:58
Cybersecurity has an effectively endless growth runway.
“the cybersecurity runway is endless.”
Listen at 17:28
Frontier AI companies need to help identify harms from their products.
“the frontier AI companies need to play some role in figuring out how their products can cause harm”
Listen at 18:46
Companies will pay to use economically viable AI that improves their businesses.
“The companies are going to pay money to use because it makes their businesses better.”
Listen at 19:21
Companies will also pay to secure AI-enabled business systems.
“They're going to also pay money to secure the foundations and the back doors of their businesses as well.”
Listen at 19:26
Palo Alto Networks trades at roughly one hundred times earnings because investors see long-term opportunity.
“that's why a company like Palo Alto Networks trades for 100 times earnings”
Listen at 19:35
Acquiring a product can eliminate its standalone operational expense layer.
“when you bring it in and make it part of an organization, that layer of expense can go away.”
Listen at 24:26
Bending Spoons finds undervalued digital assets and builds useful businesses from them.
“they find the ones, and it's the same way with AOL. and you build something useful out of it.”
Listen at 25:34
Berkshire Hathaway’s Bending Spoons investment strengthens its balance sheet and liquidity.
“This definitely bolsters the balance sheet and gives them some more dry powder.”
Listen at 26:09
Many new-home construction markets will remain weak for years.
“there's a lot of real estate markets for new home construction that are going to suck for years.”
Listen at 29:43
Smaller regional homebuilders are preferable to the largest builders.
“The ones that I like, the ones that I own are the ones that are smaller.”
Listen at 29:51
Green Brick Partners and Meritage Homes are Jason’s consistently preferred homebuilders.
“Green Brick Partners, ticker GRBK, Maritosh Homes, ticker MTH. Got a little story about Maritosh I'll share in a minute. Those are really, those are consistently my two favorite.”
Listen at 30:19
Homebuilding businesses should perform well over four to ten years.
“I think the businesses are going to do well.”
Listen at 33:06
Major homebuilder stocks are unlikely to return at least seven percent annually without rate cuts.
“I just don't see a world in which these stocks perform relatively well. Call it 7% annual return plus.”
Listen at 34:55
Ninety percent of homebuilders will earn less three years from now.
“my gut check says three years from now, 90% of the home builders are earning less than they are today.”
Listen at 35:55
Homebuilder earnings may not increase over the next couple of years.
“there's a very good chance that earnings don't go higher for the next couple of years.”
Listen at 37:47
Meritage Homes’ Southeast markets may recover quickly.
“there's a better chance that, for example, Meritage Homes, which builds so much in the Southeast, those markets can get healthy quickly”
Listen at 38:05
Investors might begin positions in smaller, nimble homebuilders.
“might be a time to nibble, maybe start some positions in some of the smaller, more nimble, better operators.”
Listen at 38:42
Jason and his wife increased bond ETF exposure to reduce portfolio risk.
“we've started to de-risk and we had increased bond ETF exposure”
Listen at 40:16
Older investors with near-term goals should reduce stock volatility exposure using bonds.
“it would be good to take the volatility risk downside off the table for at least a portion of their portfolios.”
Listen at 41:18
Higher capital costs require lower expectations for future stock returns.
“you have to lower your expectations for future returns from stocks because the cost of capital has moved higher.”
Listen at 42:46
Alphabet’s secondary issuance was brilliant capital allocation because its stock recovered.
“it was brilliant. It was absolutely brilliant for them because the stock it's, you know, it's recovered”
Listen at 44:13
It remains uncertain whether mega-cap AI capital investments will earn adequate returns in a decade.
“The question is in a decade, is the return on that capital going to work out”
Listen at 44:42
AI has not yet become a fully self-sustaining circular economy.
“we haven't reached like that circular, like we talk about circular deals. We haven't reached like a fully circular economy with AI that's like an endemic part of it.”
Listen at 46:30
Circular AI transactions cannot sustain revenue recognition indefinitely without rising expenses.
“you can only recognize that revenue so long before your expenses sneak up on you and take that dollar and ask for another hundred.”
Listen at 47:52
AI infrastructure spending is roughly four times telecom and twice railroad spending relative to GDP.
“the money that's being spent on AI infrastructure is like double telecom. That's probably like 4X telecom and double railroads.”
Listen at 49:35
TSMC’s 58 percent operating margin is extraordinarily high for manufacturing.
“A manufacturing business at 58% operating margins is outrageous.”
Listen at 51:34
TSMC will continue growing and remain the industry leader.
“I think TSMC still... uh, continues to grow and is still, is still going to be the leader.”
Listen at 53:09
Nearly seventy percent of TSMC revenue comes from five-nanometer nodes or smaller.
“I think it was almost 70% of Taiwan Semiconductor's revenue now comes from five nanometer node and below.”
Listen at 53:54
TSMC remains capacity constrained despite strong growth and margins.
“They still seem to be capacity constrained”
Listen at 54:36
TSMC has worked for decades to stay ahead and is not slowing down.
“they've been at a dead sprint for decades to stay ahead of everybody else. And they're not, they're not slowing down.”
Listen at 55:27
Wise remains attractive if payment volume grows and cross-border revenue rises at least fifteen percent.
“I'm still happy as long as we continue to see payment volume continue to grow and take rate gradually decline to the point where you're still getting cross border revenue rising at call it 15% plus.”
Listen at 57:12
Cutting prices ten percent while growing sales twenty-five percent increases profits.
“if you can cut your prices 10% and grow your sales 25%, you're going to make a lot more money”
Listen at 57:40
Booking Holdings is a value play.
“I like it.”
Listen at 59:21
FICO is a value play.
“Yeah, I like it. I'm going to say value play.”
Listen at 59:30
Pepsi is likely a market-performing stock, not deep value.
“I think it's a market performing stock. This is not deep value.”
Listen at 1:00:04
Lululemon may be undervalued, but consumer trends create uncertainty.
“I lean towards value, but consumer, I just read an article in Bloomberg talking about how like the trend shift is happening.”
Listen at 1:00:58
Intuit is a value trap.
“No. No. I want to like it, but I'm going to say value trap.”
Listen at 1:01:56
Inflation is pressuring McCormick’s costs more than pricing offsets them.
“I think inflation is hitting them harder on the cost side than their ability to outrun it with raising prices.”
Listen at 1:02:34
CoStar Group is definitely a value play.
“Definitely value.”
Listen at 1:02:54
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Books & mentions
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.