The Compound and Friends
The Compound and Friends

Nov 13, 2026 · 1h 16m

Nvidia’s selloff tests the AI trade’s staying power

Damn it, Jensen! With JC Parets

The discussion asks whether Nvidia’s decline marks a broken investment story or a broader rotation within a still-strong market.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Nvidia’s scandal, valuation, leadership questions, and drawdown have changed the case without settling the investment debate.
  2. 2Strength in AMD, Apple, housing, banks, and global equities suggests market leadership is rotating rather than disappearing.
  3. 3Extreme pessimism and recurring magazine-cover narratives contrast with persistent breadth, dip buying, and opportunities created by dispersion.

Don't miss

The hosts use Nvidia’s decline alongside AMD, Apple, housing, banks, and global markets to argue that leadership may be rotating rather than collapsing.

The brief

JC Parets joins Josh Brown and Michael Batnick as Nvidia’s sharp decline raises a central question: has the AI trade broken, or is capital moving elsewhere?

The hosts weigh Nvidia’s valuation, earnings growth, China exposure, scandal, and CEO succession against historical drawdowns, while stressing that risk depends on each investor’s horizon.

AMD and Broadcom’s strength, Apple’s appeal, and improving charts in housing, banks, and global markets point to rotation across a broadening bull market.

Magazine covers and recurring market narratives become evidence of investor psychology: sensational pessimism can arrive even as successful companies, sectors, and countries keep advancing.

The episode’s sharpest tension comes in precious metals, where a severe gold and silver selloff looks either like an emerging opportunity or a reason to wait for confirmation.

What was said on this episode

37 statements · 17 positive · 11 negative · 2 mixed · 7 neutral

  1. Josh Brownon Josh Brown’s NVIDIA positionPositive14:15

    Josh Brown believes his low NVIDIA cost basis makes selling irrational.

    “My average cost is so low, it would be idiotic for me to sell almost no matter what happens”

    Listen at 14:15

  2. Michael Batnickon Investment decisionsNeutral15:01

    Investment decisions depend on investors’ circumstances and objectives.

    “everybody's in a different situation”

    Listen at 15:01

  3. Josh Brownon NVIDIA valuationPositive16:42

    NVIDIA trades at roughly ten times forward earnings, below half the market multiple.

    “Now the stock's at a 10 forward PE. It's selling at a multiple of less than half of the market.”

    Listen at 16:42

  4. Singapore accounted for 18% of NVIDIA sales in fiscal 2025, up from 8.5%.

    “18% of sales in fiscal year 2025. are coming from Singapore. That is up from eight and a half percent.”

    Listen at 18:19

  5. Josh Brownon NVIDIA CEO successionNeutral18:53

    NVIDIA’s CEO succession decision will materially affect long-term outcomes.

    “what they do about the CEO role. And I remember both of these stories. I lived through them. I traded through them.”

    Listen at 18:53

  6. Hewlett-Packard’s stock fell 70% after its CEO succession episode.

    “The stock fell 70%.”

    Listen at 19:59

  7. Intel fell to a 50-year low after replacing its CEO.

    “Intel ended up falling to a 50-year low”

    Listen at 20:19

  8. NVIDIA’s stock could rise 12% if investors favor its successor.

    “And the stock could run up 12% on that news.”

    Listen at 21:09

  9. NVIDIA’s business will not collapse solely because Jensen Huang leaves.

    “I don't think the business just falls apart because they lost the guy.”

    Listen at 22:30

  10. Josh Brownon S&P 500Positive24:04

    NVIDIA’s drawdown alongside a stable S&P is extremely bullish.

    “How can this be interpreted as anything other than super duper, duper bullish?”

    Listen at 24:04

  11. Michael Batnickon Semiconductor market supportNegative32:53

    A semiconductor support failure would signal the bull market and AI bubble have ended.

    “If this fails up here and starts to roll over again, bull market canceled, AI bubble pop, it's all over.”

    Listen at 32:53

  12. Josh Brownon NVIDIA and AI tradeNegative33:36

    Investors are rotating away from NVIDIA but retaining AI exposure.

    “People do not want out of the AI trade. They want out of Nvidia.”

    Listen at 33:36

  13. Michael Batnick expects Anthropic’s IPO could be highly successful.

    “I think the Anthropic IPO, I think, could be a rousing success.”

    Listen at 40:09

  14. Sector rotation sustains bull markets.

    “sector rotation is the lifeblood of a bull market”

    Listen at 40:36

  15. Josh Brownon ApplePositive42:36

    Josh Brown prefers Apple as an alternative to semiconductor and data-center risks.

    “I buy Apple because now I don't worry about data center financing.”

    Listen at 42:36

  16. Josh Brownon ApplePositive42:57

    Apple has risen 32% and trades near forty times earnings while investors continue buying.

    “Now you got a stock trading up 32% at almost 40 earnings multiple and they keep buying it.”

    Listen at 42:57

  17. Michael Batnickon Stock market economic forecastingNeutral48:26

    Stock prices anticipate economic conditions roughly six to twelve months ahead.

    “the stock market is a forward-looking discounting mechanism for the economy six to nine months ahead of time, maybe 12 months ahead of time.”

    Listen at 48:26

  18. Pulte Homes and Toll Brothers are near new all-time highs.

    “Pulte Homes and Toll Brothers are pushing up against new all-time highs, really.”

    Listen at 48:42

  19. Michael Batnickon U.S. housing boomPositive51:46

    A U.S. housing boom could logically begin now.

    “if we are going to get one, now would be a perfectly logical time for it to start.”

    Listen at 51:46

  20. Josh Brownon Housing affordability policyPositive52:12

    A future Democratic Congress could pursue policies making housing more affordable.

    “one scenario is the left decides that they want to make housing more affordable in some way.”

    Listen at 52:12

  21. Michael Batnickon Indian equity indexesPositive56:14

    India’s major equity indexes reached new all-time highs.

    “New all-time highs.”

    Listen at 56:14

  22. Michael Batnickon German stock marketPositive57:00

    Germany’s major stock-market index closed at a new all-time high.

    “Just closed at a new all-time high today.”

    Listen at 57:00

  23. Michael Batnickon Treasury bonds and interest ratesNegative59:30

    If bonds have not bottomed, higher interest rates will cause broad damage.

    “This is at all time lows. So bonds are ever going to bottom. If they don't bottom here, if that magazine cover wasn't it, then interest rates are going to rip higher and ruin everything.”

    Listen at 59:30

  24. Michael Batnickon US dollarNeutral1:00:48
    “That was the bottom for the dollar.”

    Listen at 1:00:48

  25. Josh Brownon CannabisNegative1:02:43

    Cannabis was an exceptionally poor investment during the decade.

    “Cannabis. The most idiotic thing you could have invested in this decade.”

    Listen at 1:02:43

  26. Michael Batnickon BrunswickNegative1:03:33

    Brunswick surged 1,600% before collapsing as bowling enthusiasm faded.

    “Look at Brunswick was up 1,600% and then just completely collapsed when they realized that nobody gave a f*** about bowling.”

    Listen at 1:03:33

  27. Josh Brownon Online gambling stocksNegative1:04:32

    Online gambling stocks are not necessarily good long-term performers.

    “It just doesn't mean the stocks are going to be good long-term performers.”

    Listen at 1:04:32

  28. Josh Brownon Online gambling stocksNegative1:04:40

    Online gambling stocks currently look very poor.

    “And all the online gambling stocks look horrible.”

    Listen at 1:04:40

  29. Josh Brownon Stock-market narrativesNeutral1:08:36

    Historical stock-market narratives could recur unchanged today.

    “All of this stuff could be repeated right now. And you wouldn't know the difference.”

    Listen at 1:08:36

  30. Josh Brownon Nvidia stockMixed1:09:13

    The stock will decline, but the broader world will continue normally.

    “The stock will fall, but like the world will go on.”

    Listen at 1:09:13

  31. Michael Batnickon Dow Theory lettersNeutral1:09:37

    Historical Dow Theory commentary resembles contemporary market commentary.

    “if you just take off the dates and the names of the companies, it's just another day today.”

    Listen at 1:09:37

  32. Michael Batnickon Market dispersionPositive1:10:19

    Current market dispersion may be historically unprecedented.

    “There is more dispersion in today's market than at any point, maybe in our entire lives. And maybe, maybe the most we may ever see.”

    Listen at 1:10:19

  33. Michael Batnickon Market dispersionPositive1:11:37

    High market dispersion creates opportunities on both long and short sides.

    “it is just a spectacular moment for the investor to find opportunities to make money from the long side and the short side.”

    Listen at 1:11:37

  34. Investors may be wrong about housing-market conditions.

    “I think that everybody could potentially be wrong about the, uh, about. housing.”

    Listen at 1:13:02

  35. Precious metals have experienced an epic crash, with gold and silver sharply lower.

    “This is literally an epic crash in precious metals. Gold down almost a third of its value since January. Silver more than cut in half.”

    Listen at 1:13:36

  36. Michael Batnickon GoldNegative1:14:08

    The current period is not an appropriate time to buy gold.

    “This ain't it. This ain't it.”

    Listen at 1:14:08

  37. If a commodities supercycle is underway, precious metals offer a generational buying opportunity.

    “If this is a secular bull market for commodities, secular super cycle, commodity super cycle, precious metals are going, this is the opportunity of a generation to buy precious metals.”

    Listen at 1:14:45

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.