Oct 14, 2026 · 15 min
Other Mommy’s scares collapse under comic relief
Other Mommy
The panel examines how a promising possession premise and Jessica Chastain’s performance fail to overcome thin storytelling and tonal misfires.
- 1Other Mommy builds effective body-horror set pieces but repeatedly punctures them with goofy comic choices.
- 2Jessica Chastain gives the film its most memorable image, even as the surrounding story remains skeletal and formulaic.
- 3The panel finds the movie derivative of stronger horror while admitting its final scares linger after the credits.
Don't miss
The panel laughs at a demon’s glitter-filled exit, then acknowledges that the film still leaves Rihanna checking the house alone.
The brief
Pop Culture Happy Hour opens by questioning the harsh reaction to Other Mommy, a possession horror film about a girl visited by an entity impersonating her mother.
Rihanna Cruz finds strong horror set pieces buried by comic choices, while Aisha and the panel argue that the premise never develops beyond its trailer.
The discussion faults the film’s missing skepticism, sparse characterization, and limited lore, then compares its formula to stronger movies including The Babadook and Hereditary.
Jessica Chastain’s eerie smile and tears become the film’s defining image, while the panel disagrees over the child performance and the movie’s deliberate restraint.
Even after laughing at a deflating body-horror scene, Rihanna admits the film made her check the house alone, revealing the scares that still get through.