Modern Wisdom
Modern Wisdom

Sep 24, 2026 · 1h 44m

Pape warns America is entering a cycle of political violence

Democrats vs Republicans: Who Is Actually More Violent? - Robert Pape #1154

The episode argues that political violence is no longer confined to fringe groups and could intensify as demographic, economic, and partisan tensions converge.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Support for political violence spans both pro-Trump and anti-Trump constituencies, challenging simple claims about which side is more violent.
  2. 2Ordinary, socially established Americans can radicalize when status fears, group approval, and a triggering political focal point converge.
  3. 3Trump and social media matter, but deeper demographic and wealth changes help drive the escalation cycle threatening American stability.

Don't miss

Pape uses a wildfire analogy to explain how widespread support for political violence can ignite into concrete action when a triggering focal point appears.

The brief

Robert Pape argues that America’s central danger is mass support for political violence among ordinary citizens, a condition he calls violent populism rather than fringe extremism.

His comparison of January 6, George Floyd protests, assassination attempts, and partisan narratives challenges the idea that one political side holds a monopoly on violence.

Pape says many January 6 participants did not fit the stereotype of isolated militia members; status anxiety and fears of losing security helped drive radicalization.

Social media acts as an accelerant, turning existing demographic and economic tensions into group reinforcement, publicity, and approval for potential attackers.

The standout warning is a wildfire analogy: widespread support can remain latent until a focal point ignites action and pushes America into an escalation trap.

Pape assigns responsibility across the crisis, arguing that social changes outweigh Trump alone while Russia and China benefit from America’s deepening division.

What was said on this episode

48 statements · 5 positive · 37 negative · 1 mixed · 5 neutral

  1. Robert Papeon American support for political violenceNegative0:37

    Tens of millions of Americans supporting political violence are America’s greatest threat.

    “The number one threat to America is not from a foreign government, even Iran. It's not from a fringe militia group. It's from tens of millions of Americans who support political violence.”

    Listen at 0:37

  2. Robert Papeon American political violenceNegative1:49

    America is experiencing historically high political violence and support that will alter the upcoming election.

    “we are in an era of historically high political violence and historically high support for political violence that will change the election that we are about to go through in ways we may not really be prepared for.”

    Listen at 1:49

  3. Robert Papeon American political violenceNegative3:38

    The current era of American political violence is historically anomalous.

    “it is actually a historical anomaly in our country.”

    Listen at 3:38

  4. Robert Papeon Mainstream support for political violenceNegative6:55

    Mainstream support for political violence encourages actual political violence.

    “Violent populism is taking a lot of that anger in the mainstream, extreme, and it is transforming into political violent anger where there's support for political violence, which is going to then encourage actual political violence.”

    Listen at 6:55

  5. The midterm loser will likely face violent protests potentially larger than January 6th.

    “whoever loses in the midterms, we are likely to see not just simply passive acceptance, or even peaceful protests. We are likely to see violent protests, whoever loses, that may be larger than January 6th.”

    Listen at 8:18

  6. The losing side in the midterms may produce protests larger than January 6th.

    “We are likely to see violent protests, whoever loses, that may be larger than January 6th.”

    Listen at 8:30

  7. Robert Papeon Anti-Trump political violenceNegative10:07

    Twenty-five percent of adults support force to prevent Trump’s presidency.

    “25% of American adults support the use of force to prevent President Trump from being president. That equates to 65 million American adults. That's 44% of all Democrats, self-identified as Democrats in our survey.”

    Listen at 10:07

  8. Robert Papeon Support for force against Donald TrumpNegative11:28

    Respondents supporting force against Trump often mean rifle assassination.

    “what we found is 55% of the time they mean assassinating President Trump with rifles as the attempt that failed at Butler.”

    Listen at 11:28

  9. Robert Papeon Support for force against Donald TrumpNegative11:29

    Most respondents endorsing force against Trump mean assassination with rifles.

    “55% of the time they mean assassinating President Trump with rifles as the attempt that failed at Butler.”

    Listen at 11:29

  10. The upcoming midterms will be the most dangerous elections in Americans’ lifetimes.

    “This portends that the midterms will be the most dangerous elections in our lifetimes.”

    Listen at 13:59

  11. Robert Papeon American political violenceNegative17:24

    America’s political violence has changed substantially over the past decade.

    “The truth is that it's a matter of the timeframe. And what does that mean? That means the nature of political violence in our country has changed over the last 10 years.”

    Listen at 17:24

  12. Robert Papeon Social changes in the United StatesNegative19:17

    Social changes are driving America’s current violent-populism era.

    “why we're in the era of violent populism now, as opposed to 20 years ago or 20 years from now, is that we're in the tipping point of certain social changes that are happening to our country.”

    Listen at 19:17

  13. Robert Papeon American violent populismNegative19:52

    American violent populism may worsen over the next five to ten years.

    “why it's likely to possibly get quite worse over the next 5 to 10 years.”

    Listen at 19:52

  14. Robert Papeon American violent populismNegative19:52

    Violent populism may worsen substantially over the next five to ten years.

    “it's likely to possibly get quite worse over the next 5 to 10 years.”

    Listen at 19:52

  15. Robert Papeon Right- and left-wing political violenceNeutral22:13

    Right- and left-wing political violence operate symmetrically regarding mass support.

    “in terms of basic operations, how they relate to the mass support of political violence in the country, there's a lot of symmetry. There's a lot of symmetry between the right and the left.”

    Listen at 22:13

  16. Robert Papeon Mass support for political violenceNegative23:29

    Mass support nudges volatile individuals toward political violence through social approval.

    “when there's mass support for political violence, it nudges those volatile individuals over the edge because they have an additional motive for carrying out the political violence, which is, social approval.”

    Listen at 23:29

  17. Robert Papeon Social mediaNegative24:08

    Social media amplifies underlying political-violence tensions.

    “Social media matters, but it's like pouring gasoline on an underlying fire.”

    Listen at 24:08

  18. Robert Papeon Donald Trump’s January 6 responseNegative34:05

    Trump did not call off January 6 rioters until late afternoon.

    “President Trump did nothing to call them off until the very end at 4:15.”

    Listen at 34:05

  19. Robert Papeon Donald Trump’s January 6 pardonsNegative34:24

    Trump glorified and pardoned all January 6 defendants regardless of violence.

    “ever since, President Trump has been glorifying the January Sixers. He has pardoned them all, every single one, regardless of how violent they were”

    Listen at 34:24

  20. Robert Papeon January 6 Capitol attackNegative38:04

    Greater police resistance could have made January 6 substantially worse.

    “had there been actual resistance to that more than there was, I think this could have actually been a lot worse than what we saw on January 6th.”

    Listen at 38:04

  21. Robert Papeon American violent populismNegative40:55

    Current American violent populism occurs on both the political right and left.

    “in this era today, what's special is not just that we're living through it. That's of course what's really impactful, for us here, but also that it's happening on both the right and the left.”

    Listen at 40:55

  22. Robert Papeon Contemporary American insurrectionistsNeutral44:57

    The typical contemporary insurrectionist is educated and middle class.

    “the new stereotype, Chris, before I go into examples, are essentially well-educated, middle-class Americans, nice homes and a 401, and they wear a suit and tie. That is your standard insurrectionist.”

    Listen at 44:57

  23. Robert Papeon January 6 defendantsNeutral46:33

    Forty-five percent of January 6 defendants held professional or business occupations.

    “What was stunning are the 45% who are business owners, who are doctors, who are gynecologists, who are nurse practitioners.”

    Listen at 46:33

  24. Robert Papeon Affluent supporters of both partiesNegative51:17

    Affluent supporters on both sides fear the opposition will destroy their futures.

    “both sides of very well-off people are petrified that when the other side wins, the other side is going to take away their nice life or their future or the future of their kids.”

    Listen at 51:17

  25. Robert Papeon Normalization of political violenceNegative52:09

    Political-violence normalization cascades without political-leader pushback.

    “the normalization of political violence is a cascading phenomenon unless there's actual pushback by political leaders.”

    Listen at 52:09

  26. Robert Papeon American opposition to political violencePositive53:32

    Sixty-five to seventy percent of Americans routinely reject political violence.

    “we have in our surveys, we have routinely 65%, 70% of Americans who abhor political violence.”

    Listen at 53:32

  27. Robert Papeon American opposition to political violencePositive53:35

    Sixty-five to seventy percent of Americans routinely abhor political violence.

    “we have routinely 65%, 70% of Americans who abhor political violence.”

    Listen at 53:35

  28. Robert Papeon Support for political violenceNegative59:04

    Supporters of political violence are more likely to commit it.

    “To the extent we can track that, yes.”

    Listen at 59:04

  29. Robert Papeon Mass support for political violenceNegative1:04:27

    Mass support for political violence translates into actual political violence.

    “when there is mass support for political violence, this translates into actual political violence.”

    Listen at 1:04:27

  30. Growing Catholic support for political violence gave birth to the IRA.

    “as public support for political violence among Catholics in the fall of 1969, we actually have the opinion poll data here, as it actually grows, that's what gives birth to the IRA.”

    Listen at 1:04:51

  31. Robert Papeon German assassination plotPositive1:08:37

    Pape’s 2022 German consultations helped disrupt an assassination plot.

    “that played a powerful role in rolling up the plot to assassinate the chancellor 6 weeks later so that they headed off a big assassination plot that was underway.”

    Listen at 1:08:37

  32. Robert Papeon Violent populism in mature Western democraciesNegative1:08:54

    Similar social changes are producing violent populism in other Western democracies later.

    “the social changes that are underneath what's occurring in violent populism in the United States are occurring in other mature Western democracies, they're occurring a little bit of a lag, a little bit later.”

    Listen at 1:08:54

  33. Robert Papeon United States demographic transitionNeutral1:09:34

    The United States is transitioning from white-majority to white-minority democracy.

    “For the first time in our country's 250-year history, the United States is transitioning from a white majority democracy to a white minority democracy.”

    Listen at 1:09:34

  34. Robert Papeon United States demographic transitionNeutral1:09:39

    The United States is transitioning from white-majority to white-minority democracy.

    “the United States is transitioning from a white majority democracy to a white minority democracy.”

    Listen at 1:09:39

  35. Robert Papeon Belief in white replacementNegative1:12:30

    Belief in deliberate white replacement predicts much higher pro-Trump violence support.

    “if you are worried America is— whites in America are being deliberately replaced by the Democratic Party, if you worry about that, you're not just more likely to vote for Trump, you're 4 times more likely to support political violence for Trump.”

    Listen at 1:12:30

  36. Robert Papeon Belief in systemic American racismNegative1:12:51

    Belief that America is inherently racist predicts greater anti-Trump violence support.

    “If you believe America is a racist country and always has been, which is kind of the mirror image on that question, you were 2.5 times more likely not just to vote Democrat, but to support political violence against Trump.”

    Listen at 1:12:51

  37. Robert Papeon Top 1% wealth shareNegative1:14:20

    The top one percent controls 26 percent of American wealth.

    “Today, at least it's as of 2 years ago, that's the most in data, it's 26%.”

    Listen at 1:14:20

  38. Robert Papeon January 6, 2027 election certificationNegative1:16:23

    January 6, 2027 may trigger renewed political violence after the midterms.

    “we're already seeing the mass sentiments that I've just laid out for you that are incredibly worried. We already know we have a focal point coming, and it could be literally the day January 6th, 2027”

    Listen at 1:16:23

  39. The midterms have substantially greater than fifty percent odds of serious violence.

    “Oh, easily way more than 50%. This is way too dangerous.”

    Listen at 1:19:34

  40. Robert Papeon Upcoming American electionsNegative1:21:06

    America is approaching its most dangerous elections in living memory.

    “we are really on the brink of the most dangerous elections in our lifetimes.”

    Listen at 1:21:06

  41. Robert Papeon Demographic change and wealth concentrationNegative1:22:14

    Demographic change and wealth concentration drive current political violence.

    “What's occurring is the 2 social changes I just laid out for you.”

    Listen at 1:22:14

  42. Robert Papeon Foreign influence on U.S. political divisionsNegative1:26:55

    Foreign influence can amplify existing U.S. divisions by roughly ten to twenty percent.

    “it appears as if you can take issues of this violent populism, the social change issues, and you can magnify them, say 10 or 20%, but it doesn't look possible to make them up out of whole cloth.”

    Listen at 1:26:55

  43. Robert Papeon Iran WarNegative1:32:04

    The Iran War lacks the usual postwar rally-around-the-flag effect.

    “This is the first war where that's not true. The first war where it's not true.”

    Listen at 1:32:04

  44. Robert Papeon Iranian propaganda targeting MAGANegative1:32:55

    Iranian propaganda has not shifted the MAGA constituency or Trump’s war position.

    “they're literally not moving the key constituency you would have to move to move the war. It's the MAGA constituency that Trump cares about. So if you don't move MAGA, you're not really moving Trump.”

    Listen at 1:32:55

  45. Robert Papeon Russia and ChinaPositive1:33:16

    Russia and China benefit most from American civil unrest.

    “without a doubt, it's going to be Russia and China for sure.”

    Listen at 1:33:16

  46. Robert Papeon Donald TrumpPositive1:34:36

    Trump may be America’s most brilliant politician since Ronald Reagan.

    “he may well be the most brilliant politician we've had since Ronald Reagan.”

    Listen at 1:34:36

  47. Robert Papeon Causes of American political unrestMixed1:37:07

    Social changes explain half of unrest; Trump and other factors explain one quarter each.

    “I would say 50% of this is due to the social changes I laid out, 25% is due to President Trump, and 25% is due to social media and other factors that I would just lump in another group of things.”

    Listen at 1:37:07

  48. Robert Papeon Deplatforming Donald Trump and Tucker CarlsonNegative1:40:33

    Deplatforming Trump and Tucker Carlson did not diminish political anger or its effects.

    “we did deplatform Trump, we did deplatform Tucker Carlson, and guess what happened, Chris? We did not actually diminish any of those fires or any of those impacts.”

    Listen at 1:40:33

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.