UK Small/Mid Caps with Paul Scott

Paul Scott flags another profit warning at Proservice

Paul's Podcast - Fri 1 May 2026

The episode pairs informal investor-lunch plans with a clear personal warning about a company Scott believes investors should avoid.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Paul Scott records from an improvised bedroom setup while previewing a Mayfair investor lunch.
  2. 2He highlights Proservice’s latest profit warning and says he considers the company problematic and best avoided.
  3. 3The discussion sits within a broader focus on UK smaller and mid-cap companies and personal investment judgment.

Don't miss

Paul Scott delivers his clearest warning of the episode, calling Proservice problematic and best avoided after another profit warning.

The brief

Paul Scott opens from his bedroom after being displaced from his usual office, giving the episode an unusually informal setting before turning to market commentary.

He previews an investor lunch with friends at a Mayfair club, suggesting the gathering could stretch into an all-day event rather than remain a brief meeting.

The central warning concerns Proservice, which has issued another profit warning; Scott says he believes the company is problematic and best avoided.

Scott stresses that the view is personal and not investment advice, framing the Proservice discussion as a judgment call rather than a formal recommendation.

What was said on this episode

37 statements · 22 positive · 9 negative · 2 mixed · 4 neutral

  1. Paul Scotton New River REIT dividend yieldPositive4:47

    New River REIT offers a 9% dividend yield.

    “Best bit though the dividend yield, 9%.”

    Listen at 4:47

  2. Paul Scotton New River REIT versus PHPMixed5:16

    Paul prefers PHP over New River REIT for risk-reward.

    “I think personally I'd probably go PHP in preference, but I like New River REIT as well.”

    Listen at 5:16

  3. Paul Scott prefers Primary Health Properties over New River REIT.

    “I think personally I'd probably go PHP in preference”

    Listen at 5:16

  4. Paul Scotton New River REITPositive5:19

    Paul Scott evaluates New River REIT favorably.

    “I like New River REIT as well.”

    Listen at 5:19

  5. Paul Scotton LondonPositive5:56

    The London market can raise substantial money for quality businesses.

    “the London market can raise substantial money for good quality businesses.”

    Listen at 5:56

  6. Paul Scotton London stock marketPositive6:10

    The London market can fund high-quality companies.

    “there is funding there for the good quality stuff.”

    Listen at 6:10

  7. Mortgage Advice Bureau is attractively valued.

    “Very attractively valued.”

    Listen at 6:31

  8. Mortgage Advice Bureau is attractively valued and inexpensive.

    “It's a very nice value business, um, and it's cheap.”

    Listen at 6:45

  9. Paul Scott strongly favors Mortgage Advice Bureau Holdings.

    “MAB1, I like a lot.”

    Listen at 6:50

  10. Paul Scotton UK housebuilding sectorNegative7:19

    The housebuilding sector is currently performing very poorly.

    “the whole house building sector is absolutely on its arse at the moment.”

    Listen at 7:19

  11. Paul Scotton Housebuilders’ marginsNegative7:53

    Housebuilders’ margins are being squeezed by sector headwinds.

    “the builders' margins are being squeezed, there's no doubt about that”

    Listen at 7:53

  12. Paul Scotton UK housebuilding sectorPositive8:06

    The housebuilding sector is oversold.

    “I think it's oversold now”

    Listen at 8:06

  13. Paul Scotton UK housebuilding sectorPositive8:58

    Paul Scott judges the housebuilding sector to be substantially oversold.

    “I feel the sector is really oversold.”

    Listen at 8:58

  14. Paul Scott identifies Barrett Redrow as his preferred housebuilder.

    “So my sector pick, for what it's worth, is Barrett Redrow.”

    Listen at 9:17

  15. Paul’s preferred housebuilder is Barrett Redrow.

    “my sector pick, for what it's worth, is Barrett Redrow.”

    Listen at 9:17

  16. Paul Scotton GleesonNegative13:49

    Paul Scott penalizes MJ Gleeson for its communication and forecast downgrade.

    “So Gleason goes on the naughty step.”

    Listen at 13:49

  17. Paul Scotton GleesonPositive14:11

    Paul maintains a positive rating because MJ Gleeson is attractively cheap.

    “I'm sticking stubbornly to green because I think the value is now so attractively low.”

    Listen at 14:11

  18. Paul Scotton GleesonPositive14:13

    MJ Gleeson’s valuation is attractively low despite sector risks.

    “I think the value is now so attractively low.”

    Listen at 14:13

  19. Paul Scotton GleesonNegative14:22

    MJ Gleeson may trade below half of net asset value.

    “I think it might even be less than half NAV.”

    Listen at 14:22

  20. Paul Scotton GleesonMixed14:55

    Paul will continue holding MJ Gleeson but will not currently add.

    “I'm happy to continue holding. I'm not going to buy any more just yet.”

    Listen at 14:55

  21. Paul Scotton GleesonNegative14:57

    Paul Scott recommends not buying additional MJ Gleeson shares immediately.

    “I'm not going to buy any more just yet.”

    Listen at 14:57

  22. Paul Scott judges Pearson Group to be fairly valued.

    “we think it's priced about right.”

    Listen at 15:16

  23. Paul Scotton RotorkNeutral15:24

    Paul Scott judges Pearson Group and Rotork to be fully valued.

    “Both we think are fully priced really for our purposes”

    Listen at 15:24

  24. Paul Scotton NatWest GroupPositive15:48

    Paul Scott considers NatWest Group shares good value.

    “But we think they're good value.”

    Listen at 15:48

  25. Paul Scotton NatWest GroupPositive15:48

    NatWest Group and other banks are good value.

    “we think they're good value.”

    Listen at 15:48

  26. Paul Scotton NatWest GroupPositive15:49

    NatWest has a single-digit P/E and a 6% yield.

    “NatWest, a single-digit PE, 6% yield.”

    Listen at 15:49

  27. Paul Scott views Shield Therapeutics favorably overall.

    “So overall on Shield Therapeutics, I do quite like it”

    Listen at 17:39

  28. Paul Scotton Shield Therapeutics interim CFO arrangementNegative18:14

    Paul views Shield’s CEO becoming interim CFO negatively.

    “the CEO is taking over as interim CFO, which I don't like.”

    Listen at 18:14

  29. Paul Scott likely excludes Shield Therapeutics from future consideration.

    “So I think for me that probably rules out Shield Therapeutics from, from, from now on.”

    Listen at 18:29

  30. Paul Scotton PulsarNeutral19:46

    Paul Scott and John decline to rate Pulsar because it cannot be valued reliably.

    “So we agreed on no color now for Pulsar.”

    Listen at 19:46

  31. Paul Scotton PulsarNegative19:50

    Pulsar cannot currently be valued under Paul’s stock-selection criteria.

    “we don't want— we don't— we can't value it.”

    Listen at 19:50

  32. Paul Scotton PulsarNegative19:51

    Pulsar cannot currently be valued under Paul’s criteria.

    “we can't value it.”

    Listen at 19:51

  33. Paul Scotton Financial marketsPositive21:09

    Paul believes markets generally find a way through difficult conditions.

    “his view is that the market finds a way to muddle through, um, and that, and that's broadly my view as well.”

    Listen at 21:09

  34. One Health Group could become a major multibagger long term.

    “I think long term that could be a serious multibagger.”

    Listen at 22:22

  35. Paul Scott judges One Health Group fairly valued currently.

    “I think it's priced about right now.”

    Listen at 22:28

  36. Paul Scotton UK housebuilding sectorPositive23:08

    Paul remains bullish on housebuilders because valuations are too low.

    “So I remain, um, pretty bullish on that simply because I think it's way too cheap”

    Listen at 23:08

  37. Paul Scotton UK housebuilding sectorPositive23:11

    The housebuilding sector is substantially undervalued.

    “I think it's way too cheap”

    Listen at 23:11

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.