
Sep 18, 2026 · 21 min
Listen from 11:26
Listen at 11:26
Paul Scott returns after a ten-day illness
Paul’s Podcast - Fri 18 Sept 2026
The episode is primarily a personal reset, framing Scott’s independent investing commentary through his recovery and life in Gozo.
- 1Paul Scott describes recovering from a middle-ear infection after roughly ten days of illness and a hospital visit.
- 2He discusses a conversation with Mario, his Airbnb landlord in Gozo, before setting the episode’s context.
- 3Scott reiterates that his investing commentary is independent and non-advisory rather than personalized financial advice.
Don't miss
Scott’s opening account of recovering from a middle-ear infection and visiting hospital is the episode’s defining moment.
The brief
Paul Scott opens with a personal update, saying he feels more cheerful after roughly ten days of illness involving a middle-ear infection and a hospital visit.
The conversation briefly turns to Mario, Scott’s Airbnb landlord in Gozo, adding a slice of everyday life before the investing discussion begins.
Scott then establishes the episode’s frame: his investing commentary is independent and non-advisory, rather than personalized financial guidance.
What was said on this episode
38 statements · 15 positive · 19 negative · 2 mixed · 2 neutral
Aeorema appears cheap, cash-rich, and currently performing well.
“it's a share I have followed before. Quite a few of my friends have big stakes in this one. It's, um, interesting little, very small nano-cap marketing company, uh, always seems to be in turnaround mode, but apparently it is actually now performing quite well and it's very cheap and it has, uh, net cash as well.”
Listen at 1:39
Aeorema is performing well, cheaply valued, and has net cash
“apparently it is actually now performing quite well and it's very cheap and it has, uh, net cash as well”
Listen at 1:50
Dianomi’s 64p takeover bid plus contingent payment is recommended
“I would recommend a takeover bid at 64p plus a possible contingent payment”
Listen at 3:29
Dianomi’s takeover price is probably fair
“given how disappointing the company's performance has been over the years, it's probably a fair price”
Listen at 4:06
Mothercare shares are likely to become worthless
“the shares are going to be a zero”
Listen at 4:48
Mothercare shares are highly likely to become worthless
“Mothercare is highly likely to be a zero for a long time”
Listen at 5:31
Hedlum is unlikely to achieve a solvent outcome
“I'd be amazed if they managed to, to get that away”
Listen at 6:20
Investors should treat Hedlum as worthless
“I would just treat Hedlum as a zero”
Listen at 6:34
Hedlum shareholders should treat the investment as worthless.
“I would just treat Hedlum as a zero, and if you do get, um, if you do get anything back, you'll have done well.”
Listen at 6:34
Investors should not average down in distressed companies
“just FFS, don't average down”
Listen at 7:12
Investors should not keep investing in companies nearing collapse.
“if you keep throwing money at these types of things, these on the brink of collapse type situations, it's just the worst strategy you can imagine.”
Listen at 7:43
Continuing to invest in near-collapse companies is a very poor strategy
“it's just the worst strategy you can imagine”
Listen at 7:50
Peel Bidco’s Harworth offer is fair
“I actually think it's a fair offer”
Listen at 8:43
Peel will probably succeed in acquiring Harworth.
“Peel have got their teeth stuck into this and are probably going to succeed, if I had to guess.”
Listen at 9:04
Peel Bidco will probably succeed with its Harworth bid
“are probably going to succeed”
Listen at 9:06
Peel’s offer for Harworth is fair.
“I think it's a fair offer from, uh, from Peel.”
Listen at 9:41
Harworth shareholders should sell half and accept Peel’s offer.
“if I held the shares, which I don't, and obviously never ever advice— it's your money, so you have to make these decisions— um, I think I'd probably, um, sell half in the market and accept the offer.”
Listen at 9:45
Harworth shareholders should sell half and accept the offer
“I think I'd probably, um, sell half in the market and accept the offer”
Listen at 9:52
Harworth shares may fall 20–30% if Peel withdraws.
“The shares are probably going to drop 20-30%.”
Listen at 10:02
Harworth shares may fall 20–30% if Peel Bidco walks away
“The shares are probably going to drop 20-30%”
Listen at 10:02
Investec trades at 7.6 times earnings with a 6.3% dividend yield
“You've got a very low PE and a decent dividend yield, 7.6 times PE. 6.3% dividend yield.”
Listen at 11:01
South Africa is economically and politically unstable
“it's fairly unstable economically and politically, I believe”
Listen at 11:26
Softcat’s GDT acquisition is large and must be executed successfully
“this is a big deal, and they've got to get it right”
Listen at 11:58
Softcat’s limited US acquisition expertise may create execution risk
“this maybe introduces some deal or execution risk”
Listen at 12:09
Softcat is relatively expensive
“it's not cheap, pretty expensive”
Listen at 12:20
Defence Holdings’ contract cannot be valued without size, duration, and profit details
“how on earth can we value it if we don't even have any vague idea of what the contract size or duration is and whether they're going to make profit from it?”
Listen at 13:22
A government contract win is not necessarily profitable or cash generative
“you can't just assume automatically that a government contract win is big news and highly profitable and highly cash generative”
Listen at 14:59
Defence Holdings’ announcement sounds promotional rather than substantive
“it sounds like a ramp to me”
Listen at 15:40
Defence Holdings’ government contract may be promotional rather than substantive.
“It really does. And we haven't got the information to assess it. Um, is it real or just a ramp? I asked here. Could be either, I put diplomatically in our written report. But I have to say, my antennae are twitching and saying could well be a ramp.”
Listen at 15:41
Investors should avoid Defence Holdings.
“I wouldn't touch it with a barge pole. That's ALRT Defence Holdings.”
Listen at 16:04
Investors should avoid Defence Holdings shares
“I wouldn't touch it with a barge pole”
Listen at 16:04
Eagle Eye’s long-serving management team is highly committed
“I think they're really passionate about it”
Listen at 18:19
Eagle Eye is an attractive investment opportunity.
“I think this is quite an exciting share.”
Listen at 19:02
Eagle Eye is an exciting investment opportunity
“I think this is quite an exciting share”
Listen at 19:02
Eagle Eye is expensive but has very strong recurring-revenue growth
“we both think Eagle Eye, it's not cheap on conventional metrics, but you've got very, very good ARR growth”
Listen at 19:36
Eagle Eye is a global leader in personalized supermarket promotions.
“I think it is a global leader in what it does, the personalized customer, personalized promotions for supermarkets.”
Listen at 19:44
Eagle Eye is a global leader in personalized supermarket promotions
“I think it is a global leader in what it does”
Listen at 19:44
Airtel Africa’s proposed divestment or flotation is priced below expectations
“the indicative price range is quite a lot lower”
Listen at 20:36
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.