The NPR Politics Podcast
The NPR Politics Podcast

Aug 17, 2026 · 19 min

Press briefings lose power as presidents bypass the press

Why White House press secretaries still matter

The episode argues that weakening press access and evasive government communication threaten the public’s ability to test official claims and hold presidents accountable.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1The White House press secretary still matters because access, questioning, and transparency shape public accountability.
  2. 2Presidents’ direct communication and declining televised briefings have weakened the press corps’ role as an independent check.
  3. 3Misleading claims about health, war, and national security can erode trust long after the briefing ends.

Don't miss

The hosts connect evasive answers about Biden’s cognitive health with broader failures of transparency, showing how briefing-room credibility can collapse.

The brief

Miles Parks, Tamara Keith, and Mara Liasson examine Karoline Leavitt’s tenure and ask what remains of the press secretary’s traditional role when presidents communicate directly.

Tamara Keith explains why the presidential press pool matters for access and accountability, then examines concerns that White House control over membership weakens its independence.

The hosts revisit Sean Spicer’s false inauguration crowd claims and compare them with evasive answers about Biden’s cognitive health, arguing that credibility is cumulative and fragile.

From Vietnam and Iraq to the current Iran war, the episode links poor wartime communication to public doubt, especially when regular briefings and clear information are missing.

The closing argument is that Donald Trump has long acted as his own spokesman, making the press secretary’s job less about access than managing a president’s direct version of reality.

What was said on this episode

19 statements · 5 positive · 12 negative · 2 neutral

  1. Tamara Keithon White House press secretary roleNeutral0:37

    The press secretary speaks for the president, runs the press office, and manages press relations.

    “There are a lot of things in the job description. There is the very public role that we see speaking for the president. There's also a managerial role running the press office. And then there's the role of managing the relationship between the White House and the press corps.”

    Listen at 0:37

  2. Caroline Levitt successfully fulfilled Donald Trump’s preferred press-secretary role.

    “she was a very successful press secretary if success is defined on being the kind of press secretary that the president wants.”

    Listen at 1:42

  3. Tamara Keithon White House press secretary roleNeutral2:55

    A successful press secretary must understand the president’s thinking through close access.

    “The key to a successful press secretary, and not all of them are successful, the key to being successful is knowing what the president is thinking because you are in the room.”

    Listen at 2:55

  4. Tamara Keithon Caroline Levitt’s press officePositive3:26

    Caroline Levitt’s press office was highly responsive to press inquiries.

    “This press office is actually surprisingly responsive.”

    Listen at 3:26

  5. Tamara Keithon White House–press relationship under Caroline LevittNegative3:55

    Caroline Levitt oversaw a major deterioration in White House–press relations.

    “she oversaw just a dramatic deterioration of that relationship.”

    Listen at 3:55

  6. Tamara Keithon White House press poolNegative6:00

    The White House press pool is less independent than previously.

    “There isn't that level of independence that there had been in the past.”

    Listen at 6:00

  7. Tamara Keithon White House decoy plane operationNegative6:53

    The White House deceived journalists through a decoy plane operation.

    “the White House undertook an incredible deception.”

    Listen at 6:53

  8. Donald Trump has uniquely sought to undermine the press’s credibility.

    “No one has ever set out to really destroy the credibility of the fourth estate like Donald Trump.”

    Listen at 7:28

  9. Sean Spicer’s false inaugural claim damaged his tenure as press secretary.

    “if you come out on the first day and you say something that is plainly not true, then it really casts a shadow over what turned out to be a pretty short tenure as press secretary.”

    Listen at 8:57

  10. Mara Liassonon Donald Trump’s approach to press secretariesNegative10:11

    Donald Trump’s approach made the press-secretary role less fact-based and less important.

    “because of the way Donald Trump has changed the role of the press secretary, that it's kind of untethered from the facts, basically become less important because of that.”

    Listen at 10:11

  11. Karine Jean-Pierre was perceived as insufficiently straightforward despite frequent briefings.

    “they held briefings more frequently, certainly. But there was this sense under Corrine Jean-Pierre that she wasn't always being particularly straightforward.”

    Listen at 10:48

  12. The Biden White House tried extensively to portray Joe Biden as fit for office.

    “it shows the lengths to which the White House went to convince people that Joe Biden was fine and fit for office and not suffering any kind of decline physically or cognitively.”

    Listen at 11:59

  13. Mara Liassonon Joe BidenNegative12:09

    Joe Biden was not physically or cognitively free of decline.

    “And it turned out that was not the case.”

    Listen at 12:09

  14. Mara Liassonon Democratic governancePositive13:05

    Democracy requires transparency, candor, credibility, and honesty from government.

    “one of the most important things in a democracy is that there is a certain amount of transparency and candor and credibility. And that means honesty.”

    Listen at 13:05

  15. Mara Liassonon Donald Trump’s Iran-war goalsNegative14:44

    Donald Trump’s stated Iran-war goals have not been achieved.

    “He said that he went to war to achieve certain goals. None of them have been achieved.”

    Listen at 14:44

  16. Tamara Keithon Administration communication about USS Abraham LincolnPositive15:41

    Earlier transparent communication would have improved the administration’s response to USS Abraham Lincoln reports.

    “clear and transparent communication up front probably would have put them in a better position to speak to this. very bad headline than they're in right now.”

    Listen at 15:41

  17. Mara Liassonon Donald TrumpNegative16:36

    Poor communication about the Iran war contributes to Donald Trump’s approval below 40%.

    “That's one of the reasons Donald Trump's approval rating is below 40.”

    Listen at 16:36

  18. Tamara Keithon Government accountabilityPositive17:53

    Accountability helps produce better-considered policy.

    “Accountability actually does have some value in creating better, more thought out policy.”

    Listen at 17:53

  19. Mara Liassonon Donald TrumpNegative18:22

    Donald Trump has long presented versions of reality that often conflict with facts.

    “Donald Trump has been engaged in this kind of... I don't even know what you want to call it, but giving his version of reality, which often doesn't conform to the facts, for his entire career.”

    Listen at 18:22

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.