The Ezra Klein Show
The Ezra Klein Show

Nov 17, 2026 · 1h 5m

Listen from 16:18

Listen at 16:18

Rob Sand bets Iowa on breaking the two-party grip

The Winning Democrat Who Wants to Break Up Political Parties

Sand’s governing experiment tests whether electoral reform and cross-partisan trust can survive the incentives of modern party politics.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Sand argues that two-party competition rewards corruption, complacency, and lesser-of-two-evils choices over effective governing.
  2. 2He proposes open primaries, multiple finalists, and approval voting to weaken party organizations and broaden voter choice.
  3. 3His governing strategy starts with shared rituals and practical wins before confronting issues where compromise may be impossible.

Don't miss

Sand recounts opening town halls by applauding Republicans, Democrats, and independents before singing “America the Beautiful” together.

The brief

Rob Sand’s decisive Iowa victory gives an anti-party argument an unusual test: can a candidate run against political institutions and then govern through them?

Sand defines corruption broadly, arguing that a two-party system can misuse public power by rewarding political failure, complacency, and lesser-of-two-evils campaigns.

His proposed remedy is structural: open primaries, multiple general-election finalists, and approval voting that give candidates incentives to compete for broader support.

Sand describes town halls that included Republicans, Democrats, and independents singing “America the Beautiful,” using shared ritual without pretending partisan differences had vanished.

The central tension remains unresolved: trust may grow through shared wins, but abortion and institutional resistance could expose the limits of cross-partisan governing.

What was said on this episode

44 statements · 25 positive · 17 negative · 2 neutral

  1. Rob Sandon Public corruptionNegative3:07

    Abusing entrusted public power for personal enrichment violates public service.

    “people in positions of trust and power who were abusing their trust and power to enrich and serve themselves”

    Listen at 3:07

  2. Rob Sandon Public-sector corruptionNegative4:05

    Public-sector corruption damages public trust and self-government.

    “those crimes are also crimes against public trust. They're crimes against our idea of self-governance.”

    Listen at 4:05

  3. Rob Sandon Two-choice political systemNegative6:45

    A two-choice system enables corruption and political laziness.

    “it allows corruption, it allows laziness”

    Listen at 6:45

  4. Rob Sandon Iowa film tax-credit programNegative9:15

    Iowa film-tax-credit rules enabled highly lucrative aircraft purchases and resale.

    “you could buy a 747, use it in the background of a single shot, sell it for 95 cents on the dollar of what you got it for, and then get another 50% on top of that of your purchase price in refundable transferable tax credits.”

    Listen at 9:15

  5. Rob Sandon Legislative accountabilityPositive10:23

    Greater accountability would improve legislators’ consideration of flawed laws.

    “if people really had a sense of accountability who are in elected office and a sense of true public service where making mistakes like that could really cost them. They probably would think a little bit more clearly about passing a law like that before they do it.”

    Listen at 10:23

  6. Rob Sandon Two-choice political systemNegative14:01

    The two-choice system tempts political actors toward dishonest electoral strategies.

    “all I see is temptation. Temptation for elected officials and candidates and consultants to get people to take the easy way.”

    Listen at 14:01

  7. Rob Sandon Two-party political systemNegative14:22

    Politicians can win reelection without solving problems under the two-party system.

    “they don't have to solve problems to get reelected. They just have to be the lesser of two evils.”

    Listen at 14:22

  8. Rob Sandon Citizens UnitedNegative16:18

    Citizens United was the worst Supreme Court decision of Sand’s lifetime.

    “Citizens United was the worst Supreme Court decisions in our lifetimes. Absolute embarrassing failure of the Roberts Court.”

    Listen at 16:18

  9. Rob Sandon Citizens UnitedNegative16:25

    Government should respond to Citizens United’s campaign-finance effects.

    “We do need to do something about it.”

    Listen at 16:25

  10. Rob Sandon Corporate political powersPositive16:38

    States should restrict corporate powers to address Citizens United.

    “I think that we should do that everywhere.”

    Listen at 16:38

  11. Rob Sandon DuopolyNegative17:34

    Duopolies are economically unproductive.

    “a shared monopoly between two people or two companies, a duopoly, isn't productive”

    Listen at 17:34

  12. Rob Sandon Electoral choicePositive18:12

    Electoral systems should provide voters with more ballot options.

    “I just think it's about having more options on the ballot.”

    Listen at 18:12

  13. Rob Sandon Independent voters in IowaNeutral18:55

    About one-third of Iowans are independent voters.

    “if you're an independent voter in Iowa, which about a third of Iowans are”

    Listen at 18:55

  14. Rob Sandon Rob SandPositive19:53

    Sand plans to hold 100 public town halls annually as governor.

    “I'm planning to do it, continue to. 100 public town halls every year”

    Listen at 19:53

  15. Rob Sandon Radon levels in IowaNegative23:35

    Iowa has the nation’s highest radon levels, six times higher.

    “We have the highest radon levels in the country. 6X.”

    Listen at 23:35

  16. Rob Sandon RadonNegative23:39

    Radon is the second-leading cause of lung cancer after smoking.

    “Radon is the second leading cause of lung cancer behind smoking, and lung cancer is the leading killer.”

    Listen at 23:39

  17. Rob Sandon Iowa radon disclosure requirementsPositive24:05

    Iowa should require housing professionals to document radon-risk acknowledgments.

    “Every time a home inspector does an inspection, every time a realtor sells a house, documented, they need to show that their client initials every one of these.”

    Listen at 24:05

  18. Rob Sandon Nitrates in Iowa waterNegative24:56

    High nitrate levels in Iowa’s water contribute to cancer risk.

    “nitrates cause cancer. We have incredibly high nitrate levels.”

    Listen at 24:56

  19. Rob Sandon Iowa wetlands restorationPositive24:58

    Sand wants Iowa to undertake an unprecedented wetlands restoration.

    “I want to do the single biggest wetlands restoration that anyone has ever seen.”

    Listen at 24:58

  20. Rob Sandon Iowa wetlands restorationPositive25:33

    Wetlands restoration could improve water quality, cancer rates, recreation, and youth retention.

    “let's clean up our water, reduce our cancer rates, improve our ability to have fun outside and retain our young people all with that one solution”

    Listen at 25:33

  21. Rob Sandon U.S. political systemNegative26:20

    The current political system prioritizes reelection over solving public problems.

    “our political system is designed to reelect politicians rather than to solve our problems.”

    Listen at 26:20

  22. Rob Sandon Electoral reformPositive27:43

    Electoral reform could make government address future problems more quickly.

    “if we have a system, if we have an ax that's sharp. a system that is more ready to actually address issues because politicians actually have to serve us to get reelected instead of just demonizing their only opponent, then those problems that future generations face will fade more quickly.”

    Listen at 27:43

  23. Rob Sandon Iowa Democratic and Republican partiesPositive28:29

    Iowa should end the Democratic and Republican parties’ special legal privileges.

    “Let's end the special legal privileges of the Democratic and Republican parties.”

    Listen at 28:29

  24. Rob Sandon Iowa open-primary systemPositive28:57

    Iowa should advance three to five primary candidates to the general election.

    “So then send the top three to five to the general election.”

    Listen at 28:57

  25. Rob Sandon Approval votingPositive29:06

    Approval voting lets voters support multiple candidates in the general election.

    “Approval voting. Here are five candidates. Vote for as many of them as you approve of.”

    Listen at 29:06

  26. Rob Sandon Approval votingPositive30:21

    Approval voting incentivizes candidates to treat opponents respectfully and honestly.

    “how am I going to treat Ezra in order to get his voters to also support me? And people will shout out. You'll be nice. You'll be respectful. You'll be honest.”

    Listen at 30:21

  27. Ranked-choice voting is confusing and delays election results.

    “rank choice is confusing and it delays results as we're seeing right now.”

    Listen at 30:56

  28. Rob Sandon Top-two primary systemNegative33:33

    Top-two systems preserve lesser-of-two-evils choices in general elections.

    “if you just end up with the top two, you still just have the lesser of two evils for the entire general election”

    Listen at 33:33

  29. Rob Sandon AlaskaNegative34:00

    Under Alaska’s system, insulting opponents makes candidates less popular.

    “when I insult other people and I'm rude, it actually just makes people like me less.”

    Listen at 34:00

  30. Rob Sandon Sand’s proposed electoral systemPositive34:55

    Sand’s proposed electoral system removes incentives for candidates to lie or demonize opponents.

    “if we have a system like the kind that I'm proposing, that's used in a few different jurisdictions, that incentive isn't there.”

    Listen at 34:55

  31. Rob Sandon Political division in the United StatesNegative36:26

    Political division weakens the country’s social fabric.

    “Furthering division is weakening the social fabric of this entire country.”

    Listen at 36:26

  32. Rob Sandon Shared singing at town hallsPositive38:26

    Shared singing helped town-hall attendees feel included without pretending to agree.

    “people would cry, Ezra, because it was like it was the first time they had been invited not to pretend that they'd agree.”

    Listen at 38:26

  33. Rob Sandon Winneshiek County votersPositive42:45

    Winneshiek County voters favor authentic candidates who challenge their own parties.

    “they're more interested in someone who's willing to be who they are, be true to themselves, and challenge their own party”

    Listen at 42:45

  34. Rob Sandon Political institutionsPositive46:44

    Political institutions must enable shared interests rather than incentivize division.

    “you have to create a system that allows that to rise to the top as opposed to one that pushes our leaders to divide us”

    Listen at 46:44

  35. Rob Sandon Cooperative political systemPositive48:32

    Cooperative electoral incentives would produce progress on broadly supported issues.

    “If you have a system where people are actually incentivized to work together to find practical solutions in places of agreement instead of grandstanding and bomb-throwing in places of disagreement, then all of those issues, I actually think, will find those places where the vast majority of people agree and we'll see progress on them.”

    Listen at 48:32

  36. Rob Sandon Cross-partisan deliberationPositive49:54

    Including dissenting perspectives improves decision-making.

    “Balancing out your own thinking with people that you often disagree with ends up being very effective.”

    Listen at 49:54

  37. Rob Sandon Bipartisan compromisePositive52:46

    Good-faith bipartisan compromise can strengthen legislation and earn support.

    “You can strengthen the bill. You can earn that bipartisan support if you have good faith actors who are just trying to get to good solutions and you're willing to compromise.”

    Listen at 52:46

  38. Rob Sandon Durable public policyPositive53:15

    Durable policy should be acceptable across differing values and perspectives.

    “We should want to build solutions that people can look at from different positions in life who have different values and they can all agree, okay, that would actually be good.”

    Listen at 53:15

  39. Rob Sandon Cross-partisan cooperationPositive54:39

    Accomplishing shared tasks builds trust for future cooperation.

    “The more things you can accomplish with someone else, whether that's working in your office or a campaign or an elected office, the more you trust them to do other things.”

    Listen at 54:39

  40. Rob Sandon Iowa Republican legislatorsPositive55:43

    Sand plans to invite supporting Republican legislators to every bill-signing ceremony.

    “every single bill that legislators vote for, the Republican majorities, where I sign is a bill signing ceremony you are invited to.”

    Listen at 55:43

  41. Rob Sandon Rob SandPositive58:02

    Sand will hold 100 public town halls as Iowa governor.

    “I'm going to be doing 100 public town halls as a governor, same way I did as a state auditor.”

    Listen at 58:02

  42. Rob Sandon Rob Sand’s Iowa gubernatorial vote totalPositive58:58

    Sand received more Iowa gubernatorial votes than any postwar candidate except 1964’s candidate.

    “I got more votes for governor than any other candidate since World War II in Iowa, with a single exception, 1964.”

    Listen at 58:58

  43. Rob Sandon Voter information preferencesNeutral1:01:03

    Voters want to understand candidates’ identities beyond policy promises.

    “People want to know who they vote for.”

    Listen at 1:01:03

  44. Rob Sandon ChristianityPositive1:02:34

    Sand characterizes Christianity’s core as recognizing God in others and treating them well.

    “the heart of Christianity really at the end of the day is about seeing God and everyone else around you and treating them the way that you would want to be treated”

    Listen at 1:02:34

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Books & mentions

Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.