The Megyn Kelly Show
The Megyn Kelly Show

Nov 20, 2026 · 1h 42m

Sabatini wins nearly $10 million defamation verdict

Meghan Markle's Dad Ruled Competent, Scientist Wins Case, and Clavicular Charged, with Geragos, Merchant, and Frei | Ep. 1446

The episode examines how allegations, institutional investigations, and post-conviction speech can collide with due process and lasting personal consequences.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Russell Brand’s critics argue that efforts to suppress his platforms threaten speech and his ability to challenge a conviction.
  2. 2David Sabatini’s defamation victory highlights how selectively presented evidence can shape institutional judgments and destroy an academic career.
  3. 3The panel weighs rehabilitation, evidence, and accountability in cases involving K.J. Bierman and influencer Clavicular.

Don't miss

The panel examines how newly revealed texts and testimony helped David Sabatini win a nearly $10 million defamation verdict after losing academic positions.

The brief

Megyn Kelly is joined by Mark Geragos, Ashleigh Merchant, and Viva Frei for a legal-focused episode spanning Russell Brand, Thomas Markle Sr., juvenile justice, and sexual-assault allegations.

The panel argues that pressure to remove Russell Brand’s channels, alongside media coverage of uncharged allegations, risks punishing speech and weakening due-process protections after conviction.

The discussion turns to K.J. Bierman’s adult-court rape charge and possible mandatory sentence, weighing a troubled family environment against punishment, rehabilitation, and parental responsibility.

David Sabatini’s nearly $10 million defamation verdict anchors the episode: the panel says newly revealed messages and testimony challenged the account that helped end his positions at Whitehead and MIT.

The closing case concerns Clavicular’s indictment and alleged conduct involving drugs, controlling behavior, and an underage partner, raising questions about evidence and reckless legal exposure.

What was said on this episode

24 statements · 6 positive · 15 negative · 1 mixed · 2 neutral

  1. Viva Freion Russell BrandNegative4:48

    Russell Brand’s conviction is being used as a pretext to suppress his political and religious speech.

    “It's pretextual to silence someone and his political views and his religious views because they've convicted him in this show trial.”

    Listen at 4:48

  2. The documentary about Russell Brand created an injustice.

    “In this case, in my opinion, it created an injustice.”

    Listen at 8:44

  3. Russell Brand retains the right to publicly assert his version of events.

    “he's got the right to talk and say what the he said is.”

    Listen at 11:51

  4. Viva Freion UK rightsNegative16:01

    Rights in the United Kingdom are treated as privileges rather than inherent rights.

    “rights in the UK are treated as privileges.”

    Listen at 16:01

  5. Mark Geragoson judicial interference with cross-examinationNegative19:26

    Judicial interference with cross-examination undermines the essence of a fair trial.

    “When that judge gets in and starts interfering with cross-examination, that is the essence of, at least in the U.S., of what a trial is supposed to be.”

    Listen at 19:26

  6. Ashleigh Merchanton malingeringNegative22:46

    Malingering involves fabricating symptoms for personal benefit.

    “malingering is lying.”

    Listen at 22:46

  7. Thomas Markle Sr. appears capable of assisting in his own defense.

    “he is assisting in his own defense.”

    Listen at 29:40

  8. Thomas Markle Sr.’s condition may deteriorate substantially within a year.

    “in six months to a year, he isn't in any condition whatsoever.”

    Listen at 32:14

  9. Ashleigh Merchanton K.J. Bierman adult-court sentenceNegative38:52

    K.J. Bierman faces a mandatory 25-year sentence without parole if convicted in adult court.

    “if he's tried in adult court and he is convicted, he is facing 25 years. mandatory, without parole.”

    Listen at 38:52

  10. Ashleigh Merchanton juvenile versus adult courtMixed39:51

    Juvenile court emphasizes rehabilitation, whereas adult court emphasizes punishment.

    “juvenile court is focused on rehabilitation and treatment, and adult court is not. It's punishment.”

    Listen at 39:51

  11. Ashleigh Merchanton K.J. Bierman brain developmentNeutral41:43

    K.J. Bierman’s adolescent brain is still developing.

    “His brain's still not formed.”

    Listen at 41:43

  12. Megyn Kellyon K.J. Bierman abuse historyNegative45:33

    K.J. Bierman was likely abused if he abused a sibling or family member.

    “if he molested a sibling or a family member, the odds are overwhelming that he was molested himself.”

    Listen at 45:33

  13. Ashleigh Merchanton K.J. Bierman juvenile-court casePositive48:11

    Sending K.J. Bierman’s case to juvenile court would require parental involvement in treatment or punishment.

    “there is some precedent for it sending to juvenile court. court, the case being sent to juvenile court, because then the parents have to actually be involved in whatever the punishment is.”

    Listen at 48:11

  14. Ashleigh Merchant successfully overturned Brian Steele’s contempt ruling at the Supreme Court.

    “we won. We got it overturned at the Supreme Court.”

    Listen at 50:15

  15. David Sabatini received nearly $10 million including interest in damages.

    “He was awarded $6 million in damages plus prejudgment interest, bringing the total to just under $10 million and counting.”

    Listen at 58:46

  16. Ashleigh Merchanton Kristen Knauss and David Sabatini disputeNegative1:09:51

    Kristen Knauss’s conduct caused David Sabatini to suffer unfairly.

    “she's the one that's really doing a lot towards him. And he's the one. that suffers.”

    Listen at 1:09:51

  17. Questioning contradictory allegations can expose fraudulent harassment claims.

    “the grift gets exposed the more you just ask the questions, which are utterly ridiculous.”

    Listen at 1:14:10

  18. Megyn Kellyon David SabatiniPositive1:15:43

    MIT should immediately restore David Sabatini to his tenured position.

    “David Sabatini should be restored to his tenured position immediately.”

    Listen at 1:15:43

  19. David Sabatini will not recover the full judgment awarded against Kristen Knauss.

    “He's not ever going to recover the judgment that he got.”

    Listen at 1:23:13

  20. Viva Freion reputational damage from accusationsNegative1:25:46

    Later legal justice will not erase the lasting reputational damage from an accusation.

    “The punishment is the process and him getting whatever form of justice later on. It's never going to undo that that lingering memory.”

    Listen at 1:25:46

  21. Megyn Kellyon Brayden PetersNegative1:32:20

    Brayden Peters has been indicted on rape charges involving a 17-year-old.

    “Brayden has just been charged with rape. He's just been indicted.”

    Listen at 1:32:20

  22. Ashleigh Merchanton constructive force in rape lawNeutral1:39:14

    Some rape charges rely on constructive force when sex occurs with a sleeping person.

    “this whole concept of constructive force. And that's what a lot of rape charges are when you have sex with someone who's asleep.”

    Listen at 1:39:14

  23. Mark Geragoson Clavicular controlling behavior evidenceNegative1:40:54

    Clavicular’s controlling behavior toward women would likely be admissible as probative evidence.

    “Yes, that would come in. Absolutely, that will come in because that's going to be evidence that most judges, I think, would let in as probative”

    Listen at 1:40:54

  24. Viva Freion Clavicular legal exposureNegative1:41:32

    Clavicular’s drug use and involvement with underage people could lead to imprisonment.

    “You get involved with drugs, alcohol, underage people. Don't be surprised. You are. playing with your life behind bars”

    Listen at 1:41:32

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.

Sabatini wins nearly $10 million defamation verdict · PodLume