
Nov 6, 2026 · 39 min
Small-cap warnings test investors’ discipline after market sell-off
Paul’s Podcast - Fri 6 Nov 2026 - correct audio file now, apologies for earlier mistake
The episode weighs company-specific damage against broad market fear, showing where balance sheets, valuations and conviction still matter.
- 1Broad sell-offs do not automatically invalidate investment theses, but excessive gearing can turn volatility into permanent losses.
- 2Company updates reveal sharply different risks, from delayed housing demand and contract problems to speculative fundraising and weak Chinese sales.
- 3IAG and Record Group offer relative strength, while Man Group, Rightmove and Naked Wines raise distinct valuation or governance questions.
Don't miss
Scott’s discussion of Naked Wines challenges the proposed tender offer, inventory accounting and EBITDA presentation, making it the episode’s strongest warning about business quality.
The brief
Paul Scott opens after a sharp US technology sell-off and a V-shaped FTSE 100 decline, arguing that falling markets demand reassessment rather than automatic panic-selling.
Macro uncertainty spans lower bond yields, cheaper oil, inflation and geopolitical risk, while UK smaller companies remain weak despite potentially more attractive valuations.
Company news separates deferred demand at Gleeson, contract trouble at Billington, construction weakness at Lords and a deeply discounted, speculative Roebuck Foods fundraise.
IAG delivers strong results and Record Group earns an upgrade, while Man Group faces a legacy-claim risk and Rightmove confronts questions about valuation and AI.
The sharpest discipline lesson comes from Naked Wines and from Scott’s own portfolio changes: avoid excessive gearing, cut low-conviction holdings and back stronger ideas.
What was said on this episode
22 statements · 14 positive · 7 negative · 1 mixed
US AI, chip, and cloud stocks became excessively overvalued
“the AI and chips, plus cloud and all sorts of things got way, way, way too frothy”
Listen at 0:59
Market panics and sell-offs usually reverse quickly
“far more times than not, these... these panics and sell-offs, whatever, quite quickly reverse”
Listen at 3:17
UK smaller mid-cap shares trade below private-market valuations
“UK smaller mid caps are priced way below. What private markets value these companies at”
Listen at 4:12
US technology sell-offs may benefit UK value and GARP shares
“I think it's good for UK value in GARP shares”
Listen at 4:28
Lower oil prices and inflation enable central banks to cut interest rates
“which then means central banks can drop interest rates”
Listen at 6:34
MJ Gleeson is likely to miss its June 2027 forecast
“I suspect this significant H2 weighting that it expects is very likely to mean it's going to miss the June 27 forecast”
Listen at 11:51
MJ Gleeson should see stronger demand and completions from late 2027
“it should then start to be showing much, much stronger demand and completions. from probably, you know, in the second half of calendar, 2027”
Listen at 12:16
Billington Holdings’ strong balance sheet has limited downside
“the strong balance sheet has protected the downside somewhat”
Listen at 14:30
Lords Trading could recover if construction conditions improve
“it is set up for a recovery if and when a cyclical recovery actually happens”
Listen at 17:02
Eco Animal Health’s non-China, non-Japan revenue grew 6% in H1
“the rest of the world was up 6% in H1 revenue”
Listen at 21:54
IAG remains reasonably valued despite recent share gains
“We still think it's reasonable value”
Listen at 23:45
Jet2.com is Scott’s preferred airline investment
“I still prefer Jet2.com. That's my pick of the airlines”
Listen at 23:48
Record Group has improving assets, results, forecasts, and balance sheet
“we've got assets under management going up. We've got good H1 results. We've got broker forecasts going up. We've got a sound balance sheet”
Listen at 26:27
Rightmove’s market saturation makes it difficult for alternatives to compete
“I can't see why anyone would use any other service to search for a property than Rightmove because it has market, complete market saturation”
Listen at 28:31
Rightmove’s valuation is not attractive enough given AI risk
“I'd want a PE of about 10 or something to make me want to take that risk”
Listen at 29:07
Naked Wines’ tender offer could result in a small buyback
“it could be quite a small buyback”
Listen at 29:55
Fully expensing Naked Wines’ unsellable inventory would make it loss-making
“I think the reality is, if you're having to write off a lake of wine, which is not worth even its cost price, then... I think that should be fully expensed, and that would mean that it's actually loss-making”
Listen at 31:20
Naked Wines’ business model has failed
“I just think the business model has failed”
Listen at 31:42
UK stocks are currently cheap
“UK stocks are cheap”
Listen at 34:03
Investors should retain or add to winning positions during dips
“Surely we should be keeping or adding to the winners on the dips”
Listen at 34:49
Renters’ Rights Act penalties could drive landlords toward Foxtons
“the penalties are so high. So that, I think, is a nice catalyst for Foxton's”
Listen at 35:10
Plexus may lack sufficient cash to continue operating
“I need to know Has it got enough cash to keep going? Because I reckon it must be running on fumes by now”
Listen at 37:32
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.