Nov 11, 2026 · 1h 14m
Sofia Franklyn and Dave Portnoy clash over Call Her Daddy’s origin story
All New LAWSUIT! Sofia BLASTS Affair in Her New Book! Alex Cooper is Not Happy & Kylie in Hot Water
The episode revisits a defining podcast-business breakup while weighing competing accounts alongside several unresolved celebrity and legal stories.
- 1Sofia Franklyn’s account portrays Call Her Daddy’s rise, contract fight, and breakup through her own post-Barstool perspective.
- 2Dave Portnoy disputes key elements of Sofia’s version, defending Barstool’s compensation and casting Alex Cooper as the central force.
- 3The episode broadens its tabloid lens to a Kylie Jenner housekeeper lawsuit, a concert cancellation, and an insurance dispute.
Don't miss
Dave Portnoy’s account directly challenges Sofia Franklyn’s version of Call Her Daddy’s success, compensation, and rooftop breakup.
The brief
Zach Peter frames Sofia Franklyn’s account of Call Her Daddy’s rise against Dave Portnoy’s version, turning a familiar breakup into a dispute over credit, money, and leverage.
The recap follows the rooftop meeting, Barstool’s proposed deal and intellectual property offer, and the competing roles attributed to Alex Cooper, Suitman, and Scooter Braun.
Sofia’s post-Barstool career, personal turmoil, and dispute over the Unwell brand become part of the question of whether her independent momentum lasted.
Portnoy pushes back on the show’s early success, compensation, merchandise economics, and contract demands, while The Toast hosts challenge his reliance on Alex’s account.
The episode then shifts to allegations by Kylie Jenner’s former housekeeper, an Usher and Chris Brown cancellation, and the unresolved $100,000 Ashley Flynn insurance payout.
The standout tension is not a new revelation but the collision of two incompatible accounts of who drove Call Her Daddy’s success and who controlled its future.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.