The NPR Politics Podcast
The NPR Politics Podcast

Nov 19, 2026 · 20 min

Listen from 10:39

Listen at 10:39

States weigh replacing Electoral College with popular vote

This relic of U.S. politics may be on its way out

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact could reshape presidential campaigns and turnout, but rural representation, partisan distrust, and legal uncertainty threaten its path forward.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1The Electoral College can award the presidency to a candidate who loses the national popular vote.
  2. 2The interstate compact would redirect participating states’ electors once member states reach 270 electoral votes.
  3. 3A national popular vote could broaden campaigning, but constitutional challenges and rural concerns may block implementation.

Don't miss

The discussion of whether states can join the compact without a constitutional amendment reveals the legal uncertainty that could prevent it from taking effect by 2028.

The brief

The Electoral College awards the presidency through 538 electoral votes, allowing a candidate to win the office without winning the national popular vote.

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact would have participating states award their electors to the national popular vote winner once members reach 270 electoral votes.

A national popular vote could push candidates beyond battleground states and change turnout incentives, but its effects on rural communities and population centers remain uncertain.

The proposal faces a political test in states including Arizona, Pennsylvania, and Nevada, where bipartisan support may determine whether it avoids a partisan backlash.

The episode’s sharpest tension is legal: states may control their electors, but court challenges and the difficulty of amending the Constitution could delay the compact beyond 2028.

Ashley Lopez and Miles Parks examine whether frustration with minoritarian elections can overcome constitutional uncertainty, rural concerns, and resistance from state leaders.

What was said on this episode

13 statements · 5 positive · 5 negative · 1 mixed · 2 neutral

  1. Ashley Lopezon U.S. presidential election systemNeutral1:01

    The national popular vote does not determine who becomes president under the current system.

    “the national popular vote is not factored into who becomes president”

    Listen at 1:01

  2. Miles Parkson Winner-take-all state electoral allocationNegative1:25

    Winner-take-all states can make Electoral College outcomes diverge from the popular vote.

    “The Electoral College is sometimes out of whack with the popular vote because of that, because the states are winner take all.”

    Listen at 1:25

  3. Democratic control of enough state governments could put the compact under serious consideration.

    “they now control enough state governments to potentially, potentially is the key word here, put this thing at least on the table.”

    Listen at 3:50

  4. Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Nevada, and Arizona could push the compact above 270 electoral votes.

    “those five states, which is Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Nevada and Arizona, their electoral votes add up to about 61. That gets the interstate compact to more than the 270 votes that it needs.”

    Listen at 6:05

  5. The compact would likely create state-level results diverging from the presidential outcome.

    “if this compact were to go into effect, you almost certainly would see an opposite dissonance”

    Listen at 8:31

  6. The current presidential system leaves a few states decisive in choosing the president.

    “it is basically up to a few states to decide who is the leader of the free world.”

    Listen at 10:39

  7. The outcomes of adopting the compact are uncertain.

    “we don't know what the outcomes of this are going to be”

    Listen at 12:32

  8. The compact is unlikely to take effect despite political support in some states.

    “I personally think it's pretty unlikely that this goes into effect, even if there is political support in some of these states.”

    Listen at 15:21

  9. The compact is very unlikely to take effect by 2028 because of unresolved legal questions.

    “The idea that this is an effect for 2028 feels very unlikely based on just the amount of legal questions that are going to have to be sorted out.”

    Listen at 15:27

  10. A court could require the compact to be implemented through a constitutional amendment.

    “if the court says, hey, something this big needs to be done through a constitutional amendment”

    Listen at 15:53

  11. Miles Parkson Katie HobbsPositive17:05

    Katie Hobbs generally supports Arizona joining the compact.

    “In general, she's in favor of it.”

    Listen at 17:05

  12. Ashley Lopezon Josh ShapiroPositive17:51

    Josh Shapiro appears open to Pennsylvania joining the compact.

    “We know where Josh Shapiro stands in Pennsylvania. He seems to be open to it.”

    Listen at 17:51

  13. Miles Parkson Election-rule changesPositive18:16

    Election-rule changes should have bipartisan support to avoid accusations of rigging.

    “if you're going to change the rules, you always want it to be bipartisan because otherwise the accusation of cheating or rigging the system is just so easy to make.”

    Listen at 18:16

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.