Modern Value Investing with Sven Carlin

Sven Carlin Finds Cyclical Stocks Priced for Perfection

Caterpillar CAT, Hershey HSY, Honeywell Aerospace HONYHONA, Polaris PII...

The episode tests whether strong businesses and recent results justify valuations that may leave little protection when economic cycles turn.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Hershey and Honeywell offer limited prospective returns despite business quality, growth, and aerospace exposure.
  2. 2Rollins and Polaris remain difficult value propositions because elevated multiples, leverage, and discretionary demand amplify downside.
  3. 3Caterpillar’s strong results mask substantial cyclical risk as construction, mining, and data-center demand normalize.

Don't miss

Carlin contrasts Caterpillar’s strong data-center, construction, and mining-driven results with the sharp downside its cyclical earnings could face when conditions normalize.

The brief

Sven Carlin examines Hershey, Honeywell, Rollins, Polaris, and Caterpillar through a value-investing lens, asking whether quality and recent performance justify today’s prices.

Hershey’s quality, modest growth, and dividend yield do not translate into compelling prospective returns, while Honeywell’s aerospace-related valuation carries risk if industrial earnings weaken.

Rollins still trades at a high earnings multiple after its decline, and Polaris’s attractive results are offset by debt, leverage, and discretionary exposure.

Caterpillar’s current strength reflects data-center power demand, construction, and mining investment, but its long revenue history shows how sharply earnings can fall across a cycle.

Carlin ranks Caterpillar and the other featured stocks as expensive, arguing that their risk-reward profiles compare poorly with the value opportunities emphasized on his platform.

What was said on this episode

19 statements · 2 positive · 14 negative · 1 mixed · 2 neutral

  1. Sven Carlinon HersheyNeutral1:15

    Hershey offers roughly 5–7% prospective returns at its current valuation.

    “dividend yield just 3%, P-ratio 20. When you sum it all up, 5%, 6%, not to say always 6%, 7% return.”

    Listen at 1:15

  2. Sven Carlinon HersheyNegative1:25

    Hershey’s growth does not justify expecting returns much above 5% Treasury yields.

    “If you look at the business, okay, yes, 4%, 5% growth, but with treasuries at 5%, 10-year treasuries, you cannot expect much more.”

    Listen at 1:25

  3. Sven Carlinon HersheyNegative1:36

    Hershey is fairly to exuberantly priced based on past success.

    “Good business, but still fairly or exuberantly priced based on that past historical success.”

    Listen at 1:36

  4. Honeywell Aerospace trades at a 24 P/E and 4% free-cash-flow yield.

    “The P ratio is 24, it's okay. 4% free cash flow yield.”

    Listen at 2:22

  5. Honeywell Technologies could fall 50% when the industrial cycle reverts.

    “50% down easily when things revert.”

    Listen at 2:42

  6. Sven Carlinon RollinsNegative3:37

    Rollins remains expensive at a P/E ratio of 30.

    “the p ratio is still 30.”

    Listen at 3:37

  7. Sven Carlinon RollinsMixed3:45

    Rollins is fairly priced for its quality but remains very risky.

    “it is fairly priced for the quality it is but that's it it's still a p ratio of 30 it's still very risky”

    Listen at 3:45

  8. Sven Carlinon PolarisNegative4:08

    Polaris has significant debt and leverage relative to its market capitalization.

    “there is significant debt, some dividends, significant leverage, compared especially to the market cap.”

    Listen at 4:08

  9. Sven Carlinon Off-road vehicles, boats, and RVsNegative4:38

    Off-road vehicles, boats, and RVs are a difficult sector for investment.

    “very, very difficult sector to invest in.”

    Listen at 4:38

  10. Sven Carlinon AI bubbleNegative4:56

    An AI bubble burst could force AI millionaires to reduce spending.

    “especially if the ai bubble bursts and all these ai millionaires have to tighten up we'll see”

    Listen at 4:56

  11. Caterpillar supplies most data-center power-generation equipment.

    “everyone says across the data centers, it's mostly CAT.”

    Listen at 5:23

  12. Construction stabilization and mining investment are driving Caterpillar’s current performance.

    “Good construction will likely stabilize a little bit. And then mining, a lot of investments, gold going up, things like that. Those are the cycles there that are leading everything.”

    Listen at 5:27

  13. Caterpillar is highly cyclical and may earn nothing during downturns.

    “it is... a crazy cyclical and in the downturn of the cycle they don't make any money”

    Listen at 5:58

  14. Caterpillar’s market capitalization could fall to $100 billion or less in a severe downturn.

    “when they will make 2 billion when the world will look like very ugly the market cap will be 100 billion or even less”

    Listen at 6:09

  15. Caterpillar faces substantial downside risk over the next five years.

    “that's the risk it's a pretty strong risk in the next five years”

    Listen at 6:19

  16. Caterpillar is currently a gambling-like stock.

    “for now it's a gambling stock like the others were like many are still”

    Listen at 6:26

  17. Caterpillar’s across-cycle P/E is approximately 35.

    “where would i put caterpillar p ratio 35 across the cycle”

    Listen at 6:44

  18. Caterpillar belongs among the expensive companies.

    “We go here with the expensive bunch of the companies out there.”

    Listen at 6:56

  19. Sven Carlinon Discussed stocksNegative7:16

    The discussed exuberant stocks are too risky and offer low rewards.

    “These exuberant stocks are not. my style of investing, too risky, low reward.”

    Listen at 7:16

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.

Sven Carlin Finds Cyclical Stocks Priced for Perfection · PodLume