Nov 9, 2026 · 1h 5m
Listen from 4:11
Listen at 4:11
Treasury stress could force a new market regime
Structural Flows Will Support Stocks Until the U.S. Treasury Crisis in 2027 | Cem Karsan & Noel Smith | Kai Asset Management
The guests connect compressed index volatility, higher rates and fiscal pressure to a possible rotation from growth stocks toward value before renewed policy intervention.
- 1Compressed index volatility can conceal extreme dispersion and a substantial left-tail crash risk.
- 2Higher rates, fiscal spending and refinancing pressure could favor cash-generating value businesses over long-duration growth stocks.
- 3A future Treasury-market crisis may force large-scale Federal Reserve intervention despite policymakers’ stated balance-sheet goals.
Don't miss
Cem Karsan argues that a Treasury-market crisis may be the event that justifies renewed quantitative easing to sustain growth and support debt markets.
The brief
Cem Karsan and Noel Smith argue that compressed index volatility is masking extreme dispersion, leaving markets supported on the surface but vulnerable underneath.
The guests debate whether to buy or sell volatility, focusing on skew, dealer positioning, seasonal flows and the narrow window in which a selloff could accelerate.
Their longer-term thesis is a rotation from growth to value as populist fiscal policy, inflation, protectionism and refinancing pressure keep rates structurally higher.
Karsan’s sharpest warning is that Treasury stress could eventually require quantitative easing to sustain growth and stabilize debt markets, reviving the policy backstop markets depend on.
Smith translates the regime shift into defined-risk structures, while both guests argue that active risk management matters more as easy monetary support fades.
What was said on this episode
29 statements · 9 positive · 16 negative · 2 mixed · 2 neutral
QE is the only way to sustain current growth and market support.
“The only way out of this mess. point blank period the only way to continue the growth that we want that we're that's supporting this market at this point given the interest rates given the wave there's only one way out qe”
Listen at 0:23
Structured-product growth has driven index volatility compression for four years.
“The growth of structured products, which is the primary driver of that vol compression, has been 100% year over year now for four years.”
Listen at 1:59
Extreme dispersion can break the broader market structure and release index volatility.
“my opinion is at some point that itself can break the bigger picture and unpin ball. And I think that's what we're starting to see.”
Listen at 2:52
The dispersion trade can rise substantially from current levels.
“that trade from these levels has got a lot of blue sky above it, which is to say it can go way, way higher.”
Listen at 4:11
Structural flows are holding together a fundamentally fragile market.
“the macro and the fundamentals and the realities underneath this market are incredibly fragile but it's being held together by massive structural flows”
Listen at 6:48
Investors generally should not buy volatility at current prices.
“I think this is a terrible time to buy volatility unless you really, really need it.”
Listen at 8:01
The highest-probability macro risk window is year-end through early next year.
“our highest probability comes at the end of the year and into early next year”
Listen at 10:55
Historically elevated skew preceded major market declines by roughly six months.
“They all preceded, then let's say six months, a decline, the beginning of a major decline.”
Listen at 11:52
Downside protection is substantially overpriced relative to realized volatility.
“downside protection on a realized basis versus implied is incredibly overpriced”
Listen at 13:07
One-sided structured-volatility positioning has enlarged the market’s downside tail.
“Because the reason that structural trade exists is because it's one-sided and everybody has one side of the trade, which means that fat tail is bigger than ever.”
Listen at 14:23
A major risk-off move followed by reflation will likely revive single-stock call buying.
“you would need to have it in my opinion a big risk off and then a reflation again and i think that's what is probably coming”
Listen at 18:03
Call spreads and call flies are superior to outright call buying.
“I think call spreads, call flies, which is to say buy one, sell two, buy one further up. That's a fly. Is a superior trade than just closing your eyes and buying deltas”
Listen at 20:06
The market is unlikely to bounce immediately back to Monday’s levels.
“That just does not seem likely to me.”
Listen at 21:46
Downside stress requires continued selling within the next several days.
“you would need a continuation soon really in the next several days”
Listen at 24:27
Without continued decline, markets could quickly return to all-time highs.
“If we don't continue this decline, then we could be right back at all time highs pretty quickly.”
Listen at 26:42
Reduced data-center funding could compress IPO valuations and delay offerings.
“that's going to compress IPO valuations, maybe push back a date or two.”
Listen at 28:59
Continued index compression and gains will produce massive dispersion.
“expect massive dispersion if this market continues to get compressed and go higher in November, December.”
Listen at 30:56
Weak market segments will worsen while new leadership emerges.
“what's weak, continue to get worse while you start to see other leadership.”
Listen at 31:06
A renewed populist policy wave would make value outperform for 20 years.
“if it does, the value factor will outperform for the next 20 years.”
Listen at 35:47
Policies prioritizing median outcomes imply higher interest rates.
“that little thing means higher interest rates.”
Listen at 37:39
Higher interest rates are harmful to duration-sensitive assets.
“if interest rates go higher, if the... price of money goes up. That's really bad for duration.”
Listen at 38:25
Inflation has remained at or above 2% for 68 months.
“We have not been below 2% inflation in 68 months.”
Listen at 45:08
Interest rates are structurally headed higher.
“The answer is higher. And the base case is structurally higher.”
Listen at 48:27
The United States will pursue large-scale state equity purchases and money printing.
“We are going to push massive state run buying of equities and printing of money.”
Listen at 51:24
Large-scale intervention is necessary to support markets, monetize debt, and pursue populism.
“There is no way out of this mess to compete with China to support this too big to fail market, to monetize the debt and to run right wing populism, you know, other than this.”
Listen at 52:20
Large-scale monetary and equity-market intervention will arrive within six months.
“That's coming and it's coming in the next six months.”
Listen at 52:36
A market decline will occur before June and resolve by December next year.
“The decline that's going to come is necessitated to roll out this plan and naturally would happen without this response is in our opinion. coming sometime before June of next year, right? And will be resolved by December of next year.”
Listen at 55:52
Government officials are proactively managing financial markets.
“the people in power are proactively trying to manage markets.”
Listen at 59:34
Sustaining AI-led growth requires massive intervention triggered by a crisis.
“the only way we can do that is through massive intervention. And the only way we can do that is through a crisis.”
Listen at 1:01:36
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Books & mentions
Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.